Community Tasting Note
-
Poll86 wrote: flawed
June 8, 2020 - Possibly an off-bottle. Very reductive and yeasty on the nose. Opened up with aeration to fresh citrus, toast and bright red fruits. Too little acidity but could be the bottle. Not amazing but enjoyable
3 people found this helpful 5,563 views
8 Comments
-
Buller commented:
6/8/20, 9:12 AM - How many points would you have given this bottle, if it was amazing? You give it the maximum 100 points and describe it as “possibly off” and “only” enjoyable.
-
RED AND BLACK commented:
6/8/20, 9:16 AM - I guess the 100 points rating were given by mistake?
-
Poll86 commented:
6/8/20, 9:21 AM - Don’t support the idea of giving wine scores, so just default all my wine scores to 100 points
-
RED AND BLACK commented:
6/8/20, 9:24 AM - You know you can also not rate the wines? They appear as NR. Just leave the rating blank. Hope it helps, otherwise by giving 100 points you actually rate the wines you taste
-
NickRut commented:
6/8/20, 11:15 AM - Giving them all 100 throws off the rating for the wines for the rest of us 🤦🏻♂️
-
Eric commented:
6/8/20, 11:35 AM - Hello, Eric here, CEO and Founder of CellarTracker.
Please don't add scores if you don't agree in scoring. Putting 100 on every wine just thumbs your nose at our site. By the way, your notes are fantastic and on a really interesting range of wines. But please just don't score if you don't believe in it. -
Poll86 commented:
6/8/20, 6:27 PM - Duly noted Eric. And thanks for a great app
-
Eric commented:
6/8/20, 7:25 PM - Much appreciated.