Important Update From the Founder Read message >

My Tasting Notes from "Domaine de Montcalmes"

(5,000+ notes on 4,820 wines)

1 - 50 of 5,000+ Sort order
White
5/14/2024 - lukeintowine wrote:
91 points
Tasting at the winery.

Sadly I did not take notes during the tasting.
From memory this was a very clear-cut, fresh and mineral Riesling.
Nice balance and structure.
Exactly the style that I like, contrary to some of the other Rieslings I had in Alsace in the last few days.

Bought some bottles to reassess with more time.

Excellent. (91-92)
White - Off-dry
5/15/2024 - Paul D wrote:
88 points
4/4, good cork.
Medium gold. Lightly petrolly, stone fruit, apple, touch of orange blossom. Medium sweetness, light bodied, peach, lightly creamy, lovely oily texture, fresh acids, good length finish. This has lasted well and is still going strong.
Red
5/3/2024 - auldalliance wrote:
Finished bottle prev Coravined. The notes of cinnamon and cloves were a little too dominant over the fruit for me. Maybe needing a little more time in the glass. First of 6. Initial impression was that I preferred the previous 2 vintages,
Red - Fortified
Port can be so attractive when it's young that it's easy to go through your bottles of a given wine before they peak. Fortunately I have a few more of this beauty stashed away. This bottle showed a wonderful balance of sweetness and backbone while displaying a very deep color right to the rim. More pleasures to come as it ages--will ideally go back to this in 5 years or so.
Red
3 months on and a bit more air...definitely a bit easier to drink. Needs food though...steak was good. Acidity supports the fruit, perhaps a little too much. Red fruit dominant, plus dried fruit and herbs. Tannin still a bit drying on finish but I think this will mellow a bit. Give it air.
White
5/16/2024 - Peter Spijker Likes this wine:
89 points
This was quite rich and round with a fair bit of oak influence. A food wine, that for me missed some acidity.
White - Sparkling
4/26/2024 - thewiz Likes this wine:
93 points
(Disgorged in June 2001, base year 1998, approx. 1/3 of each Pinot Noir, Meunier and Chardonnay)
From the old standard bottle, then you know it’s pre-2004 base wine! Wonderful with golden yellow colour and bubbles slowly rising in the glass showing lovely maturity with acacia honey, apricots, minerals and seashells in a delicious way. Smoothing red apples and citrus acidity on the intense palate showing a creaminess on the mid and lengthy finish turning into lime zest bitterness.
(Still drinking very well with more than twenty years of extra cellaring)
White
5/16/2024 - GArpaia wrote:
Rich and buttero style with subite flinty reductuon lift. Vanilla and cream. Crisp stonefruit: peach, apricot. Coffee.
Red
1998 Château L'Evangile Pomerol Red Bordeaux Blend (view label images)
5/16/2024 - Rpfe Likes this wine:
93 points
Double decanted 2 hours before consuming at Elystan Street.Wine is still drinking beautifully a year on from my last note with no significant changes.I note higher community ratings than mine, maybe a little too fruity for my taste, perhaps underlining a left bank bias.
Red
5/16/2024 - Larsrar Likes this wine:
89 points
Very good glass from this "first time for me" DOC next to Montalcino.
Not unlike a good Rosso di Montalcino, or even a modest Brunello. Obviously more forward and friendly. This wine is showing good bite, tertiary notes and at 7 € a glass / 33 € a bootle at a restaurant near Malpensa airport I am very happy...
White
5/16/2024 - EdLark wrote:
89 points
Initial petrol smell subsides to a floral, sweet almost prune like aromas. Taste reminds me of a late harvest. Not sure.
Red
5/12/2024 - faker Likes this wine:
92 points
훌륭한 바르베라. 개인적으로 산드로네 바르베라 보다 좋다

바이올렛 사워체리
처음엔 맹한부분이 있어 갸우뚱 했지만 시간이 갈수록 변하고
팔렛이 차올라 완성되는 느낌.
음식이 없어도 잘 마실수 있다
Red
5/16/2024 - wwolf1 Likes this wine:
90 points
J'ai bien aimé. Un beau nez de syrah et des jolis parfums en bouche. Le vin est assez charpenté mais avec des tanins soyeux. C'est joli et pret a boire.
15/20
Red
5/16/2024 - wwolf1 Likes this wine:
90 points
Un joli vin qui s'exprime enfin ! Dans mon souvenir ce vin était complètement fermé mais cette fois il a pris son envol : des jolis parfums pas très marquées syrahs mais agréables. Un vin assez fin et complexe.
15/20
Red
A bit more evolved....the nose was less exuberant than before, little more secondary flavours coming through now. I possibly preferred this younger for the pure fruit, but still very good and GV.
Red
1/28/2024 - NickA Likes this wine:
92 points
A really pleasant surprise, especially from a hot vintage: elegance personified, with a floral nose, silky body and gorgeous fruit purity. I actually found this more impressive than most Hermitage/Greal I've tried from this address. Super wine. Still fairly primary - no idea why Decanter suggest drinking up by 2024!
White
5/16/2024 - wwolf1 Likes this wine:
88 points
Je suis un peu déçu sur ce millésime : le vin manque de pep's et je le trouve un peu lourd et avec des parfums un peu bizarres. Il n'est pas au niveau ou il devrait être en tout cas.
14/20
Red
5/16/2024 - Larsrar wrote:
86 points
Good, honest, simple, well made, affordable standard Chianti. Slightly chilled in restaurant near Malpensa airport at 4 € a glass / 18 € a bottle. Fine with pizza/pasta.
Red
5/16/2024 - Marc wrote:
91 points
Ripe and rich. Very modern. Deepest black cherry. Superb fruit. Very Queensberry in Stryker - c,early Csntral Otago, but with thick ( but not opaque) density. Excellent wine, and obviously a good vintage for Namny Goat.
White
Doesn't disappoint. Well made entry level GV. Slightly tauter than last year's which IMO is good.
Red
Better than precious bottle. Less angular. Grenache seems more dominant. Probably for drinking in next year or so.
White
5/16/2024 - Larsrar Does not like this wine:
84 points
Lacks sufficient acidity to match the - in my mouth - slightly vulgar Moscato identity.
Not my style at all, but I would like to try some of the better Chardonnay, Pinot Bianco & Pinot Grigio from this, apparently quite famous cooperative.
Red
Drunk over 2 nights. Has integrated well. Fruit a little sweeter, tannin just right. Not complex but good Bourgogne. Ordered 3 more.
Red
5/16/2024 - RichosCellar wrote:
86 points
Easy drinking and paired well with spaghetti bolognaise.
Cherry notes and vibrant dark colour.
Red
5/16/2024 - Tfaure wrote:
87 points
Very acidic. Maybe need to age more ?
Red
2022 Cantina Tramin Cuvée T Rosso Alto Adige - Südtirol Red Blend (view label images)
5/16/2024 - Larsrar wrote:
86 points
Honest, simple, refreshing, well made and good value. 4€ a glass & 18 € a bottle in restaurant near Malpensa airport.
White
5/15/2024 - -Flyingcactus767 wrote:
92 points
Floral balance with the perfectly ripe fruit you’d expect in maybe a vaillons, good village level!
Red
5/16/2024 - stamperb Likes this wine:
90 points
Nose: Ripe plum, red raspberry jam, sweet oak char. Palate: Crunchy tart red berries; polished tannins; initially there's a notable layer of oak that spreads out evenly over the mouth, which does mellow with additional time in the glass. On day two, the oak and other flavors are more integrated, and the wine takes on a warming (almost prickly) kirsch liqueur character.
White
Much as last summer. Still very enjoyable and no hurry.
Red
5/16/2024 - Scott4227 Likes this wine:
88 points
I agree with Robbie K and would add I believe this is early days for this one, might be a different wine in 3-5... worth leaving a few for 5 years I believe... especially at $11AUD!
Red
5/16/2024 - Tgood wrote:
From list at Fagollago in the hills above San Sebastien - great resto - easy cab to and fro and well worth the sojourn - anyway the wine - roasted pruneaux and coffee notes - luxurious structure - no hurries on well-cellared bottles but pulling a cork now is rewarding too. Seems to buck my impression of ‘14 being perhaps a cooler vintage relative to ‘03,’05,’10 and ‘15 but warm tones dominate - nicely.
White
5/16/2024 - smenzies wrote:
92 points
Has developed beautifully as an aged Riesling …
White
5/16/2024 - Fchurl Likes this wine:
92 points
Great now (at peak ?), at least better than few years back.
Red
5/15/2024 - liber Likes this wine:
89 points
6th of 12, decanted 45 minutes, perfect cork and level, another big step up since last bottle in July 22, nicely nuanced bouquet with usual Morra attributes including rose, still slightly tough on palate if with fine and sweetish tannins, just a little on the thin side but could yet round out, if so upside, 10+ years. VG+ (16.5).
White - Sparkling
5/16/2024 - Tgood wrote:
Banana and lemony aromas and flavors on faint yeasty background - crisp fuller body and clean as a whistle finish - 100% chard - a real treat and a steal
Red
5/14/2024 - AGELVIS Likes this wine:
92 points
One hour decant. Very deep magenta color. Caramel green apple and black cherry dominate. Very smooth, dry palate. Firm, lower intensity tannins on the longish finish.

This needed more air time. It’s more acid-driven than I expected. Paired very well with my lamb at Brennan’s in New Orleans. It had stiff competition at the table (‘16 Hourglass Blueline and ‘16 Diamond Creek).
Red
1989 Château La Lagune Haut-Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend (view label images)
5/16/2024 - DanielAVTL Likes this wine:
91 points
* Wine 4/4 (BDX spring tasting dinner). Opened 5 hours before serving (no decant).

Lovely aromas of nutmeg, damp earth, rhubarb and spices right from the start. A few hours in the wine fully unlocked revealing intriguing notes of toffee, caramel and game. Beautiful nose, very promising.

In the mouth - at peak with many years of prime drinking ahead of it. Medium bodied, soft velvety tannins, lovely red fruit and spices. Nice delicate sweetness on the finish, with slight tertiary port notes.

Just a lovely, well rounded and balanced effort. 91 points on the night. Drink now through 2032
Red - Sparkling
5/16/2024 - gparker777 Likes this wine:
90 points
The 2002 Seppelts sparkling red wine displays a deep garnet color in the glass. The nose reveals aromas of Marasca cherries, plums, tawny notes, cedar, and baking spice. On the palate, it offers a touch of sweetness balanced by remarkable freshness, soft tannins, and a medium texture. The long, dry finish is marked by flavors of cola, licorice, and herbal undertones. Overall, this wine has developed exceptionally well given its price point and drinking very nicely.
Red
5/13/2024 - AGELVIS wrote:
91 points
PNP. Deep ruby brick red color. Cinnamon, chamomile tea, chocolate, blackberry, and cassis. Smooth, dry palate. Firm, but soft tannins on the longish finish.
Red
5/16/2024 - syoungrv Does not like this wine:
79 points
Disjointed. Less of that peppery spice I have come to expect from this grape. Won't buy again. Kool Aid artificial flavors too in my view
Red
5/15/2024 - aaronmphoto Likes this wine:
84 points
Was fine. Nothing special. Kinda plain
Red
5/16/2024 - WyattTheSomm Likes this wine:
92 points
Sight: Vibrant medium Ruby color

Nose: This was very closed at first, so I let it sit in the decanter for 2 hours and regularly agitated it. Afterwards, it blossomed like a flower in spring and I was very relived as I thought the wine may have been completely shut-down at first impression. The nose filled the air with Dark cherry cola, Bitter cocoa, Raspberry pop tart, and dusty oak with a wine wonderful touch of vanilla. I love that concentrated red cherry note I find in Peju and it’s here in full swing after two hours. I appreciate that it’s never medicinal always clear and focused like a fresh “Filthy” candied cherry for a old fashioned.

Taste: At first the tannins were way too tight and really gripped; the fruit wasn’t very focused. But yet again after two hours this completely transformed to the point someone who didn’t know about wine would of thought I served them something different haha. The wine became full and round on the palate with ripe tannins and a lush texture making it a joy to drink being 14.4% ABV. The fruit is fresh and focused like a raspberry torte, Dark cherry Cola, Cocoa nib dust, And vanilla. The acid really lifts providing focus and balanced everything making this complete with a delightful spice filled finished.

Overall: Classic Peju and if you like a red Fruit Cab with focus and freshness this will be a great wine for you! They are not shy on the Oak, which is French and American for 18 months but the wine holds it lavishly. I didn’t find this wine too dissimilar from their Rutherford expression as my notes for this almost lined up identically. The only thing I’m sure of is the Rutherford had more oak perception and 1 more month in new oak and it was noticeable. Overall great wine, especially in 2017 this hides the heat of the vintage well.
Red
5/16/2024 - Scott4227 Likes this wine:
90 points
Deep dark red, translucent purple at the edge, nose of red berries, black olives, bramble, pencilshavings, licorice, medium weight body and acidity, red and black berry fruit flavours, good sour berry acidity, pomegranate flavour and nice olive notes on the finish lasting longer than it should for a $11AUD wine... great QPR... totally a new house red blend! Will be great in 5 and will be interesting in 10 years given the heritage and the wine maker's skills... buy more!!!
White - Sparkling
5/16/2024 - Collector1855 wrote:
94 points
Dinner in Reims. Discrete nose at first, then opening up with bruised apples and spices, lime. The oxidation is gentle, not intrusive. Dense palate, dry, feeling brut nature almost. Definitely a food chamapagne. Can keep further. 94-95
Red
Nice midweek sipper.....flavors of cherries and red berries, nothing complicated, but a nice overall blend
White - Sparkling
5/16/2024 - Collector1855 wrote:
96 points
Dinner in Reims. Fantastic as always, This has so much aroma and chalkyness on the palate, you can see that they picked top quality grapes here. The nose has yellow and red fruit, spice box, red flowers. The palate very good density and a wonderful low dosage feeling.
White - Sparkling
5/16/2024 - Collector1855 wrote:
97 points
Domaine visit. Disgorged à la volée for the lunch. What a generous gesture from the house as this is a four digit bottle by now. Showed fresh and absolutely spectacular, combining champignon notes with lemon and yellow fruit, also some nutmeg, forest floor. Perlage only petillant making this like a sublime, old Montrachet. Wonderful experience
Rosé - Sparkling
5/16/2024 - Collector1855 wrote:
92 points
Domaine visit. Discrete nose, needed some swhirling. Raspberry notes intertwined with lemon and spices. Light on the palate with lovely dry extract on the finish. Solid, but not the last word on complexity.
White - Sparkling
5/16/2024 - Collector1855 wrote:
94 points
Domaine Visit. Edition 6 MAG. Like the Inattendu this was a very good BdB. Loved the citrus nose with brioche. Fresh and saüpy. They did not go overboard with the dosage.
1 - 50 of 5,000+
More results
  • Tasting Notes: 5,000+ notes on 4,820 wines
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close