Very natural with a little reductiveness on the nose. Felt like it had some skin contact with a orange and grapefruit notes, screechy acid that I didn’t love. Think the others liked this more than me.

Typical Riesling nose. Austere with a lack of fruit, but confusingly it had a round texture. Still don’t quite get GGs.

Very old-school, especially next to the 2010 Lynch Bages. Some funk on the nose, the dark fruit was still rather tight and brooding. Quite unforgiving behind a wall of tannins at the moment, will hold off on my bottle for a while yet.

Modern with ripe blue fruit and immense concentration. A confected sweetness on the finish.

Previous notes suggested this wasn’t ready but this was showing quite differently. Brilliant nose of raspberries, a silky and elegant palate. Texturally very sensual and the red fruits showed wonderful purity. Clear favourite for everyone on the night, an exceptional wine.

Suffered in comparison to the Clair. Similar red-fruited nose but structure seemed to be missing and a little dilute.

Wanted to do a comparison with the 2018 Volnay I tried earlier in the day and Pommard definitely managed better as mentioned by many reviewers. Still very 2018 but not disjointed.

This domaine has been getting some hype recently but guess this was before the style change. Good typicity for Gevrey but not a particularly memorable wine. Towards the black-fruited end of the spectrum with high acidity.

Very impressive weight and concentration, yellow fruit of mostly lemons. Round texture and very good persistence, showing some signs of secondary development. Excellent for its level.