2/8/16, 12:31 PM - I had a very similar impression after having a bottle at a restaurant here in Columbus. I stay away from repeating the same old reviews but the word elegant is what resonates from your description. Some very subtle complexities in the profile that I didn't bother to study because I was having too much fun with a group of friends. I REALLY enjoyed this bottle. My kind of well crafted and silky style. 93 points
7/13/15, 11:43 AM - I hope I am right, too, Night Train. I've got the case minus the 1 bottle but am completely confident this will be near Special Selection quality (very similar profile) when all is said and done. A good friend of mine is also a member here and gets bothered by some of the reviews that are made that lack a perspective that only experience can bring. I hope this doesn't sound horribly condescending but it just seems an injustice to see scores of 88 or 89 points for wines that merit much more. It could be a style of wine issue but I would hope that people are able to enjoy this kind of quality and know it.By the way, I'm in Columbus too. Worthington actually.
7/13/15, 3:45 PM - Miller, I appreciate your response and think we can just have a friendly "agree to disagree" as I wouldn't say this wine is flabby at all.I do have a question, how would you like to have professional judges review wines? They certainly judge a wine on what they think it's merit will be at peak. What value would their opinions be if they judged a wine on how it tasted right then and there in barrel, just released, or just young. It's that level of experience and insight that makes their opinions valuable. My wife's opinion of that Molly Dooker would be just "not good" but her favorite wine is Kim Crawford Sav. Blanc. and has never warmed up to Cabernets or any wines with structure and pedigree. I love her to death and could care less about what her taste in wine is (as long as she's drinking wine that's all I care about!) but her opinions on the wines I drink would not be useful at all.
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search