Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(4 comments on 4 notes)

1 - 4 of 4 Sort order
Red
2018 Domaine Mee Godard Morgon Corcelette Gamay
11/22/2020 - Bearbus wrote:
Good dark berry fruit, good acidity and some grip. But for the money, there are so many others at lower prices that offer more
  • Bearbus commented:

    3/7/22, 2:41 AM - Top marks for persistence, Captain Cutlass.

    The organic/semi-natural qualifer restricts things more, but for a start, Joseph Chamonard (natural and biodynamic-organic), Château Thivin (now organic) and Daniel Bouland (minimal intervention) come to mind...

White
2018 Savaterre Chardonnay Beechworth
12/2/2020 - Bearbus wrote:
Riper fruited and less reduction than the 2017 (which we prefer), the palate is reasonably broad/wide/visocus but is also pretty elegant for it, and has good saline acidity
  • Bearbus commented:

    3/10/21, 7:16 PM - We prefer the 2017. We also prefer more reduction (which the 2017 has).

Red
2010 Torbreck Grenache Natural Wine Project Barossa Valley
4/23/2011 - Bearbus wrote:
(Stelvin Screwcap)
"Hand harvested Grenache fermented and bottled using no artificial yeast, acid, chemicals, preservatives or sulphur. Bottled unfiltered. Harvested 7 April 2010, Bottled August 2010, Best by 7 April 2012. 14.7%"

The fact it's hand harvested and without added acid gives me optimism. The fact that they predict just a two year life (or even specify a "best by" date*), and the 14.7% alcohol are concerning.

One of the movements in the Australian wine industry (as it's commonly referred to, though it might equally be said "in Australia winemaking culture") has been the rise of "natural" wines, i.e. wines with limited chemical additions, indigenously fermented, with low (or no SO2) added.

I've had quite a lot of "natural" wine recently, including wines from Australia and elsewhere (mainly France and Italy). I'm not new to them, but I've never had so many in such frequent succession before.

It's interesting that it's now normal to specify a "best by/before" date now with so many other foods and drinks, even those foods/drinks that would never harm us if we ate them many years old; and yet it's not normal to specify a "best by/before" date for bottles of wine.

21°C (70°F), not decanted ("cracked and poured")

Very slightly mirky and with a darker tinge than a typical Barossan Grenache of this age. It's a bright maroony boysenberry red - yes, it's colour is already putting me in mind of certain aromas (something we often neglect to realise when we taste, I think).

Slightly seedy and very slightly green blend of red raspberry, blueberry, plum, boysenberry? :-), dried out moss, and sweet very slightly decaying wood. It's quite an attractive nose actually. It's certainly fruity, but it has other things going on than are more intriguing compared to the, IMO, typical spice and oak aromas of Barossan Grenaches.

On the palate, it's quite svelte - with a silky kind of mouthfeel that would seem sickly-weighty and overly-viscous if it weren't for the ultra fine tannins in suspension holding up that 14.7% alcohol like a cloud. There's not as much flavour intensity on the palate as I'd hope for, and the acid does tug in the back palate and finish, but it's pretty drinkable.

It's downfall is pretty much the same as most Aussie wines of this kind: sociable, almost gluggable (if it weren't for the alcohol), but ultimately uninspiring and with a bit of a kick in the back palate/finish.
  • Bearbus commented:

    6/26/20, 6:34 PM - That's a nice coincidence, Sam. Back then, the natural wine movement was just starting to take off in Australia (it was, of course, already well established elsewhere in the world). I do think that Aussie natural wines have come a long way since. But as a generalisation, I still don't think they compare favourably to those from elsewhere (particularly France) - the balance was, and still is, often off for me.
    Surely there are some natural wines that you have liked though? It's a broad category, though I suppose it also depends whether we're using the term as a viticultural/winemaking approach (which is really what it means) or whether we mean a "natural wine" style of wine (i.e., more VA/funk/acid). I really enjoy many natural wines (particularly for the funk factor), but am well aware it's not everyone's thing.

Red
2006 Lake's Folly Cabernets Hunter Valley Red Blend
4/26/2019 - Bearbus wrote:
A bit ripe for a LF Cab, and certainly not got the funk that Scott M's bottle had, but it has nice balance and lightness to the palate, and is pleasant to drink. Missing a wow factor, but could actually do with more time
  • Bearbus commented:

    6/1/19, 4:13 PM - Yes, given how these age, I'd try another 3 to 5 years before checking in. It may develop more secondary character by then, and have therefore gained more classic LF Cab character.

1 - 4 of 4
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close