12/30/23, 9:47 AM - Great note, I just so happened to write Foradori today asking if it's time to open my 2018. Do you think this has legs to go a few more years and develop secondary notes?
12/18/22, 12:32 PM - Thanks!! :)
5/22/23, 4:23 PM - thanks @Thierry!
3/27/23, 11:41 AM - I follow you on Delectable - I opened this last night and what a fun wine - I swear this smells just like Chartreuse. Thanks for the writeup!
5/15/22, 6:25 PM - Thanks! Really appreciate the kind words - hope you enjoyed Bourdy just as much!
5/13/22, 10:51 AM - Thank you! I put some work into this one :)
1/14/22, 7:18 PM - well you just made my night! Thank you so much for the kind words! I don't imagine you'll have trouble finding an ice bath in Canada :)This is a great wine - let me know what you think when it arrives!
1/7/22, 3:58 PM - I think we both bought from Wine Merchant :)I opened mine today - drinking nicely at cellar temp
1/8/22, 3:26 PM - Right after I opened, I called and tried to get some more - unfortunately no more :(Today I did pick up some fun ones though - some radikon, Jamet, Baudry, and Querciabella on clearance....
9/13/21, 4:21 PM - I felt the exact same. Everyone had high hopes for this because of the 100 points it received a year before, but 2017 was clunky to me. I'm on the fence whether it could eventually come around or not - I hope you're right!
9/13/21, 4:30 PM - The vineyard should be ok - since the year before it was apparently exceptional - I think it's either an off year or just needs time in bottle...
3/3/21, 7:59 AM - Thank you! :)
2/11/21, 9:33 AM - I felt the exact same as you described when I first opened this. I have another bottle on hand which I'm keeping around in hopes for some retribution. I'm glad to hear you found some improvement.
12/28/20, 3:48 PM - I 1000% percent agree - a lot of people bought because 2016 got 100 points from Vinous, but I was really disappointed by 207 - sour and clunky. I have another 2017 and I'm hoping if I keep it around long enough it'll find it's sweet spot
11/25/20, 6:11 PM - Kent and Janelle! You are keeping up with the reviews and I love ever word of them! Can't wait to hang post-pandemic :)
8/29/20, 3:45 PM - Was yours effervescent? Did it fizz? Mine is good but totally flat...
2/14/20, 5:20 PM - Not to my knowledge - I think just different :)
4/12/19, 5:04 PM - completely agree
9/13/18, 11:42 AM - Thanks! I need to try the rest of his wines as soon as I can find some :)
9/13/18, 12:02 PM - It really was mind blowing. I think my best rated wine that I've opened at home. Let me know if you have other suggestions for me to look out for.
6/29/18, 12:26 PM - I had the same experience - I put in a call to Rosenthal to find out what's going on since so many people have had the same issue - I am waiting to hear back.
7/30/18, 8:02 PM - I ran into a dead end with Rosenthal. They did not have any of the 2014's left in stock and had not seen any returns or complaints from their distributors. Clearly something was off with those wines but I'm not sure what else to do. Carlo, and Grape Ape - did you see issues with 2013 or 2014? From what I recall I had the 2014, though I could be wrong.
2/24/18, 11:05 AM - I'd have to agree!
12/29/17, 4:09 PM - Thanks for the review! Good write-up! This has to be near 15% - still in balance and a nice wine :)
12/18/17, 12:42 PM - No kidding! I actually emailed Rosenthal to see if they had heard similar experiences from others. I'm glad to hear I'm not crazy :)Ely
12/5/17, 5:18 PM - so good right?!
3/2/17, 6:25 PM - Nice writeup!
2/12/17, 4:01 PM - really nice write up - thanks!
1/29/17, 10:13 AM - Let me know what you think!
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search