Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(22 comments on 20 notes)

1 - 20 of 20 Sort order
Red
2014 Tercero Verbiage (Rouge) Santa Barbara County Red Rhone Blend
3/22/2023 - Jay Hack Likes this wine:
92 points
A Berserker day wine. Wow. I don't know what I paid for this, but it was absolutely worth it. It was a little rough but still complex with a delicious flavor of berries, earth, herbs and all sorts of other stuff right out of the bottle, but after two hours in the decanter, it exploded with flavor while the roughness disappeared completely. It became extremely smooth with an excellent of any mouth feel. The blend is 46% Grenache, 30% Syrah, 20% Mourvedre and 4% Cinsault, so a classic Châteauneuf blend. In my opinion, this is the kind of wine that shows the greatness that California warm weather and terroir can do to grape varieties. These are grapes that flourish in warm weather. Larry Schaffer, the owner and winemaker, does a great job of blending these different grapes into a seamless whole. And don't be scared off by the screw cap. All it does is make it easier. I don't know what the oxygen penetration is on this particular variety of screw cap, but whatever it is, it works very well and seems to put in just the right amount to age the wine at 19 years old.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    3/23/23, 6:21 PM - I have met Larry twice at Falltacular (once pre-haircut and once post-haircut) and I ran a virtual tasting for him in NY for the Wine Beer and Spirits Law Committee of the Business Law Section of the NYS Bar Association (a committee I created and chaired).

Red
2006 Wendouree Malbec Clare Valley
3/13/2021 - Jay Hack Likes this wine:
94 points
This wine was awful. It really sucked. No one in the United States should ever buy this wine and I do not know what all the fuss is about. So what if the order forms have crayon doodles with a secret code telling you what you are allowed to buy? So what if it is completely unavailable in the US? Why did I spend all that time searching the world to buy the entire supply available in Europe and have it shipped to my house cold chain? By its reputation, I expected that it would be a revelation like La Tache. The fact that I have never had La Tache might explain why it did not taste like La Tache.

Just kidding. still a baby. Three hour decant not nearly enough. Probably should have let it sleep for another 5 years, but I'm not getting any younger. 12 hour double decant back into the bottle and left in the cellar would have been a better protocol.

I found a source to buy another 9 bottles, which will last me for quite a while, so I no longer need to criticize the wine to try to keep the price low. There is a shipment on its way to the US and I wanted to buy all of it, but SWIMBO said only 2 or 3 bottles, so I bought 9. Please don't tell her.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    1/5/23, 5:11 PM - By the way - the reference to buying the entire retail stock in all of Europe is true. We cornered the market and my only mistake was to share it with three friends! I got all 29 bottles available and ended up with 9 bottles. Then Zachy's got some more and gave me an early shot before the public announcement, perhaps since I have been a customer since 1976. Hence the 9 additional bottles, which have now been delivered as well.

Red
1973 Château Mouton Rothschild Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
5/26/2022 - vinodc wrote:
Purchased on release. Below shoulder fill but still a good bottle. Fruit is all gone and entirely tertiary notes. Tannins are completely dissolved. Bottle went belly up into harsh acidity after an hour, this was far past it’s prime and isn’t getting any better. Drink up.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    5/27/22, 10:07 AM - I bought one in 1976 at Zachy's that I still have. Probably my first First Growth purchase. I think RMP gave it 65 points, but it's the Picasso label, after all. I think I'll open it just for fun but keep the label. Picasso prints are valuable, you know.

Red
2009 Martinelli Zinfandel Jackass Vineyard Russian River Valley
8/2/2012 - Lord Rodney wrote:
95 points
Still an awesome wine! But more full of orange peel and apricot than a year ago. Long long finish. Still just a notch below last year
  • Jay Hack commented:

    12/25/21, 9:01 PM - How are you doing? Just saw this not you wrote on the Jackass Zin. If you get to NY, or if I get across the pond, I'll give you some Black Sears Howell Mountain Zin that will give the Martinelli a run for its money. Pepper and other spice with no jammy fruit.

  • Jay Hack commented:

    1/9/22, 7:06 AM - Hopefully the plague will pass over us soon. My wife is the ZinMaster in the house and we have over 100 bottles of it, although I need to diversify because I have only 4 producers with any volume.

Red
2002 Domaine Ghislaine Barthod Chambolle-Musigny 1er Cru Les Cras Pinot Noir
10/27/2021 - olemski wrote:
88 points
Double decanted about 100 minutes before tasting. Smell of strawberries and liquer. A bit of furniture polish, with good grip and fine fruit with plenty of refinement. The precision is the outstanding feature of this wine, but the notes of oak (or something oak-like) on the aftertaste and the lack of any full integration of the alcohol detract from what would have been an outstanding wine, but which is now excellent. (Note that I now use the scale as it was intended, rather than as the inflated scale it has become. This wine is excellent, so should have something like 88-89 "Very Good to Excellent (85-89)").
  • Jay Hack commented:

    11/17/21, 9:54 AM - I tried to fight the good fight on inflated points 10 years ago because 89 was the high end of good to excellent, but I gave up when I was always averaging down the scores on a wine that I really liked. I have four of these that I bought at auction that I have not opened. Perhaps I will open one and see if your oak note was bottle-specific or perhaps my oak tolerance (I am a big red Cali lover) is higher than yours.

White - Sparkling
2006 Taittinger Champagne Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut Chardonnay
4/25/2021 - Jay Hack Likes this wine:
92 points
I think this has entered a dumb phase, although the four other diners liked it more than I did. It was toasty brioche with some lemon acidity, but not as expressive as I expected. Purchased three years ago from a retailer. I like the Comtes style a lot and this seemed more subdued that the other bottles of the 2006 Comtes that I have has, so I recommend keeping hands off for a few years - preferably five.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    4/26/21, 4:19 AM - No, I think I should wear my "Anorexic minds like anorexic wines" that Elaine Krankl gave to me. The wine was just not as generous and expressive as I prefer. Perhaps I should edit the TN to specify that the four other diners liked it "more than I did." Or perhaps I should have written, "decanting champagne is an under-utilized technique that I have often found to add positive characteristics."

White - Sparkling
2006 Taittinger Champagne Comtes de Champagne Blanc de Blancs Brut Chardonnay
About 2 years ago, I sold off all of this wine from my cellar, as I just didn't find the taste and composition to my liking. I didn't have any challenge finding a buyer, as I know many people like it. As for the note below, the bottle last night was served blind so my reaction was without bias, and we didn't know the wine was 2006 Comtes until we had all tasted it and shared our views. I found the wine heavy in toasted aromas, and my comment to the owner of the bottle was that I thought the wine reminded me of Marcassin Chardonnay with bubbles (I don't care for Marcassin either). It tasted and smelled like wood aromas, and it came across as heavy. There was some aroma of white flower and orange blossom but I could not shake the toasted note. Creamy, with what seemed like a higher dosage as the wine conveys a lime candy and apple feel. The finish to me seemed heavy and sweet. Overall, the wine lacks the finesse and balance that I want in my Champagne. For those that like this bottling, I'm glad it brings joy and pleasure but for me, I just don't care for it.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    4/22/21, 3:58 PM - Frank - I can't serve Comtes blind to the FKALBTG wine group because the bottle shape gives it away, so I wonder about your claim of blindness, BUT your note is spot on to my recollection from a bottle 2 years ago. I was just reviewing the notes because I am going to open one this Sunday at my first Vaccinated Couples Covid-Free Outdoor Restaurant Dinner. I like Marcassin Chard and I like toasty brioche, so I should like this. Sometimes I need to calibrate upside down. Can't wait until the Fall.

Red
2011 Domaine Dujac Vosne-Romanée 1er Cru Aux Malconsorts Pinot Noir
7/27/2014 - Keith Levenberg wrote:
80 points
Uh-oh, smells like an '04 right from the start, and comes across bitter and stemmy. Not sure if I will have the patience to see how this turns out since it did not offer much intrigue even apart from that and obviously is not a cheap bottle. It's red-fruited with some cidery acidity and a touch of raw wood and maybe some wood tannin contributing to a slightly harsh tannic feel. I was expecting a deeper tone and some spicy accents from the Burghound note, neither of which were here, although it did add some flesh to its bones which made it more pleasant to drink with enough air.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    10/12/20, 7:59 PM - This wine is at auction to benefit the ACLU anti-voter suppression efforts in Texas. When I saw your note, I laughed before reading it. When I read it, I knew that God has a sense of humor. I think I'll bid on it! Those who know us will understand. Those who don't may not deserve to know.

  • Jay Hack commented:

    10/13/20, 6:45 AM - Touche. I don't think I've ever had Dujac. I prefer real American made wine, like Sine Qua Non and Saxum. Not that imported stuff that steals jobs from American employers.

White
2002 Trimbach Riesling Clos Ste. Hune Alsace
Riesling Study #1 (Atoboy (Manhattan, NY)): Just a quick taste. This is really austere with barely any fruit with powered stones and chalk and steely minerals. I don't feel like this has budged and not sure how long it would take to come around.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    6/6/20, 7:43 PM - This was my bottle. I have had it for about a decade, maybe more. I agree that it was a bit austere and not showing as I expected, but was still a delicious wine. I was warned about premox, but no sign of that at all. If I had more, I would wait at least until 2025.

Red
1994 Lytton Springs Winery Zinfandel Sonoma County
2/21/2020 - WetRock wrote:
Richer than my last go but not real expressive. Still very Zinny. Holding but not improving maybe.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    3/14/20, 11:13 AM - My wife absolutely flipped over this bottle at the same dinner and thought it was great, but she is a zin fanatic. We had it towards the end of the evening so it was well-oxygenated. I also thought it was very good and would say it was 50-50 on the expressive spectrum. I have been charged with the responsibility of finding more.

White
2017 Loring Wine Company Chardonnay River Quinn California
3/15/2019 - spicy1 wrote:
88 points
Nothing wrong with this bottle. Not buttery. Not over oaked. Just not very interesting. Seems similar to a lot of Santa Barbara chards--maybe overpriced. Bought it at a restaurant with a typically poor, distributor directed selection and this was the best of a weak offering.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    4/28/19, 8:19 AM - I've never commented on a CT note before, and although I own 3 of these, I have never tasted one so I can't speak to the flavors described in the note, but I am about 99.5% certain that this wine was not on whatever wine list where you found it because of a distributor directed selection. Loring is a low production almost cult (although inexpensive) California winery making pinot and chardonnay and I doubt that any distributor would push it on a restaurant.

Red
2000 Château Lascombes Margaux Red Bordeaux Blend
LBTG
  • Jay Hack commented:

    9/29/18, 12:42 PM - LBTG - Leo's Blind Tasting Group. It just tells me that I served it at our tasting group at a dinner I hosted. Served with 2000 D'Issan and 2000 Rauzan Gassies in a flight. The Lascombes was nice but not great. I dod not take contemporaneous notes.

Red
2015 Carlisle Mourvèdre Bedrock Vineyard Sonoma Valley
No note. Consumed in 2017.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    12/23/17, 6:47 AM - When you write over 1000 substantive notes on wines and post them on CT, you can criticize a note I wrote just to keep track of my cellar (but that may be useful to other CT users who know me by my real name that I do not hide behind because I am not a coward), but until then, you can KMA.

Red
2010 Talenti Brunello di Montalcino Sangiovese
killer nose
  • Jay Hack commented:

    4/30/17, 5:13 PM - Hey Serge. Haven't seen you around for a while. I got a case of these but haven't opened one yet.I guess maybe I will hazard a try.

Red
2010 Sine Qua Non Grenache Five Shooter Central Coast
5/7/2016 - coremill wrote:
89 points
Heritage Blind Tasting Challenge (Milling Room): Served double-blind. Sweet, jammy, powerful, ripe, dripping black fruit, noticeable oak, hint of VA. Lots of extract, lots of ripe, rich tannins, surprisingly decent acid and the tannins are from fruit, not oak. No real complexity, but it's pretty darn tasty even if it's kind of boring. No real varietal character to me, but obviously a CA wine. I guessed a 2009 Maybach cab. First time I've ever tasted an SQN and given my usual AFWE preferences I was pleasantly surprised, although I'd never pay the $250 or whatever it is this costs. I may have to surrender my AFWE card now though.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    5/20/16, 6:42 AM - Glad to see you did not give this 73 points! This was the one wine at Heritage that I got the producer on, but I did not get enough raspberry for the Grenache, so I thought it was the Syrah. You can keep your AFWE card if you really want it, but welcome to the land of flavor.

Red
2013 IDS Cabernet Sauvignon A Set of Aces Napa Valley
10/2/2015 - Jay Hack wrote:
95 points
This was delivered to my office yesterday and I brought it home. I had to stop at a dinner meeting and people complained that I had brought no wine, so I went out to my car a brought this in. Pop and pour into glass pitcher and then drink out of crappy hotel glasses. WOW. if this is any indication of the quality of 2013 Napa cabs, back up the truck. Great balance, strong fruit with some chocolate and coffee in the background. Obviously about as primary as it gets, but delivering tremendous pleasure in its youth. Color is dark. Nose is expressive sweet red fruit. Tannin is not astringent or biting. I love this kind of wine. If you wheelhouse is well-made big wines, this is for you. If you like thinner highly acidic wines made from grapes that could not quite reach true ripeness, then stay away and leave this to the rest of us.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    12/28/15, 9:10 AM - I suspect that the answer is that it is not possible to acquire this wine. It was a limited production wine that was specially made by a group of guys who divided it up among themselves and that's all there is. This year was a blend of three vineyards, Three Twins, McGah and Kenefick.

Red
2013 Patricia Green Cellars Pinot Noir Berserkers' Cuvée Willamette Valley
5/15/2015 - dhammer53 wrote:
86 points
Based on the majority of the notes, they must have sent me the wrong wine. On Day 1, this was a thin wine that morphed into watery and thin. This was a little darker than I expected. No nose at all. No tannins. A hint of acid that grew within 60 minutes. The acid faded 4 hours after opening the bottle. This is a young wine, and I'd advise you not to open it for a while. I planned on giving my son a couple of bottles, but he'd drink it sooner rather than later. I'll drink bottle #2 of 12 in May 2016 to see how they're coming along. Maybe then, I'll give my son some wine.

I'm a California pinot noir drinker. I enjoy a good Sojourn pinot noir frequently. I know the Berserker Cuvee is a $19.00 bottle, and I guess I got what I paid for. For now, all I can say is this was some deal. Oye. Maybe I'll feel differently in a few years. Hold. I hope my case is the exception and not the rule.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    5/21/15, 1:51 PM - Sorry Dan, but I got my order and I think you are wrong. Wife and son opened it when I was out and I grabbed a glass when it had been opened for four yours. It is not an Aubert pinot and it is certainly not a Saxum JBV, but it is a nice pinot to drink when you do not want to over-intellectualize your choice, or you want to have a red wine with fish.

White
2001 Trimbach Gewurztraminer Cuvée des Seigneurs de Ribeaupierre Alsace Gewürztraminer
8/30/2014 - Jay Hack wrote:
92 points
Perhaps the best bottle of CSR I have ever had. Outstanding. The roughness you get in a young Gewurz is gone. There is the normal flavor profile of lychee and spice. There seems to be a bit of tart apple on the palate as well. The nose is lychee. The color is a bit darker than a young Gewurz. No sugar and no real apparent sweetness. I bought this when Jean Trimbach was in NY about 5-7 years ago. Holding to age a bit was definitely worth the wait. Glad I have more.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    1/18/15, 1:05 PM - Ya ne Panemayesh, as the Russians would say. I have no idea. I do not think it is at its peak. I have three more. I am thinking I will stage them once every two years for the next six years to watch it develop. That will bring me close to 70 years old. I think it's on the upswig for at least 3 more, maybe all six. Limited experience with really aged Gewurztraminer.

Red
2012 Rivers-Marie Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley
12/16/2014 - Jay Hack Likes this wine:
92 points
Delivered on Friday, picked up from the drop ship location on Sunday, opened on Monday night in memory of a former Cabernet lover who has now gone over to the dark side. You know who he is! This is shockingly approachable in its youth, even in crappy hotel event glasses at a client Christmas Party. Dark red fruit, not overly tannic, some coffee and chocolate. Flavors are strong and primary with bitterness. ABV at 14.3% is balanced by the power of the wine. Outstanding. If the "regular" cuvee is this good, the SVDs must be off the chart, but I think they will wait a few years to see how they develop.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    12/16/14, 8:55 AM - To King Cab - Who are you and why are you mucking up my cabernet note with talk about chardonnay? I may be forced to pull out one of my bottles of Aubert Chardonnay, of which I have more than four cases, and beat some sense into you with it. :)

Red
2007 Saxum Bone Rock James Berry Vineyard Paso Robles Syrah Blend, Syrah
9/22/2014 - Loren Sonkin wrote:
99 points
3 for my birthday (Maybach, Saxum, Clos des Papes) (My Home): Beautiful showing for this wine. Popped and allowed to breath a bit then consumed over a couple of hours. Inky purple in color. No doubt, this is a hug wines. Aromas of black raspberries, blueberries, black pepper, licorice and slight floral notes. Great lush texture. Quite nimble on its feet. No heat. Lots of black and blue fruit. Nice balance. Long finish. Awesome.
  • Jay Hack commented:

    9/22/14, 9:17 AM - Glad you liked it. One of my favorites. Happy Birthday Loren.

1 - 20 of 20
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close