Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Tasting Notes for Paul-SA

(258 notes on 230 wines)

1 - 50 of 258 Sort order
Red
4/21/2024 - Paul-SA wrote:
94 points
Lovely ages Cabernet. Impressed with how fresh it still is. Starting to show some aged characteristics but still fresh.
Red
3/9/2024 - Paul-SA wrote:
94 points
What a lovely Pinot noir. Very light and delicate but with a strong peppery / spicy note. Really beautiful and complex. Drinking beautifully.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
12/27/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
95 points
Beautiful aged barolo. Still has good tanins but drinking well (no decanting). Light rusty color. Dark Cherry flavour with more rustic overtones which is really nice.
Red
12/15/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
This 2008 Cab has aged well. Still plenty of structure and could age longer. Lovely cab. Not overly oaky with good fruit The nose shows some age in a good way and the mouth still has lots of fruit but a little secondary flavours coming through. Really nice wine.
Red
11/18/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Living in South Africa I don’t get to drink many barbarescos. Luckily I have a number still in the USA which I bring over when I can. I really am enjoying this old Italian. The nose is beautiful with a herby rusty component. The tanins are still strong but enjoyable and Well integrated. Drinking well now but it will still last as it opens up beautifully in the glass.
Red
11/12/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Lovely cool climate style cabernet. Less upfront fruit compared to previous vintages, nice structure. Decanted for an hour and drinking beautifully. Will last. Lovely wine.
Red
11/4/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
94 points
Lovely old Sangiovese. Lots of dark earthy flavours. Beautiful
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
10/13/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
This consault is drinking beautifully now.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
9/9/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
Nice old Pinot from South Africa. Most of the fruit has gone but still a lot of secondary flavours coming through. A little cherry on the nose. A little savoury on the mouth. Drink up if you have any.
White
2022 Rall White Coastal Region White Blend (view label images)
9/8/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
What a lovely white blend. Like most of the white 2022 vintage, the wine is extremely open and drinking well already.
Red
2001 Morgenster Estate Reserve Stellenbosch Red Bordeaux Blend (view label images)
7/30/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
I was very surprised with how nice this wine was. Initially it smelled. Wry old old world but within an hour it opened up with fruit coming out on palate. The secondary flavours came through with a a little bit of wood influence Overall it was drinking very nicely and for a wine of its age it was delicious
Red
2014 Meerlust Rubicon Stellenbosch Red Bordeaux Blend (view label images)
7/22/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
The 2014 is showing really well. Fruity nose. Light fruit with a little herbal note on the palate. Really impressive for the price and age. Much better than I expected. The oak influence was very subtle which I enjoy. It has aged beautifully.
2 people found this helpful Comment
White
7/22/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
94 points
Lovely expression of Chenin. Very typical of the 2022 vintage very expressive on the nose and palate. The 22 whites are much more approachable than the 2021. Enjoy.
Red
2020 Rall Red Swartland Red Rhone Blend (view label images)
7/21/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Really nice blend the dryness of the carignon comes through which I really enjoy.
Red
7/13/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
85 points
No thanks
Red
7/13/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
84 points
No thanks
Red
2004 Château Monbousquet St. Émilion Grand Cru Red Bordeaux Blend (view label images)
6/18/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
Great mature Bordeaux. Very smooth tannins with tobacco flavours.
1 person found this helpful Comment
White
6/17/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
Great expression of Chenin.
Red
5/27/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
94 points
Lovely freahness to the wine. Still tight and needs more time but lots of flavours. Dark fruit with a tight powedery tanins.
White
5/1/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
Summer in a glass. Lovely pineapple on the nose and palate. Enjoyable and great value
White
4/28/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
Really interesting Sauvignon Blanc. The 50% skin contact adds to the colour and texture of the wine. Not sure I would pick this out as Sauvignon Blanc in a blind tasting. Interesting and enjoyable.
Red
4/26/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Really nice Cinsault. A lot darker fruit compared to most top end cinsault Drinking really well for such a young savage.
White
2021 Savage Wines White Blend Western Cape Sémillon-Sauvignon Blanc Blend (view label images)
4/26/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
Another great vintage of this Sauvignon blanc blend.
Red
3/26/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
94 points
Wow this wine is super pure. Nose has bright plumbs. Palate is right but enjoyable. Really clean finish with complext flavours of dark fruit with a little olive note. I would leave it for another year or so.
Red
3/7/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
87 points
Oaky nose. A little vanilla and wood. Upfront mouthfeel is smooth and round with good fruit. Finish is a little disjointed.
Red
3/4/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
This is really sinking well now. Decanted for an hour The Grenache, Cinsault and Syrah all come through. Light but with good acid and structure.
Red
2/18/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Lovely 10 yr old Syrah from South Africa. Has an old school wooded style. A little wood on the nose on the palate but lovely syrah.

Really interesting and enjoyable.
White
2/18/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Lovely chenin. Rich and flavourful. Good acidity. Which it was more readily available
Red
2/17/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Tart cherries with a good tanin and acid structure. Enjoyable and could go with a little more age.
Red
2005 Château Gruaud Larose St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend (view label images)
2/11/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Still lots of life. Dark fruit smooth and delicious.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
1/22/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Very good Syrah but I think it needs more time to show its form.
Red
1/15/2023 - Paul-SA wrote:
94 points
What a lovely Cinsault beautiful delicate mouthfeel but with a nice rich cherry flavour. Breat balance resulting in a beautiful wine. Enjoyable now but will benefit from time in bottle.
White
12/31/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Another great example of a South African white blend. Really complex and full of fruit. It has both citrus and stone fruit on the mouth.
Red
12/27/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
94 points
Super impressive 19+ year old barolo. Lots of dark cherries on the nose and palate. Drinking like a young wine. Impressive for its age. Good tanins and acid make it feel young but with a little age on the old world wine. Delicious and plenty of life left.
Red
12/21/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
94 points
Lovely brunello. Very typical flavours of dried dark fruit , tart cherries and a rusty component that I always associate with brunellos. Still lots of tanins and structure. Plenty of life left but drinking well now especially if you like younger wines.
White
12/21/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
94 points
Wow. Lots of fruit and good structure. On the nose, very pithy and lost of fruit on palate. Really impressed with this 8 yr Chenin.
White
12/15/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
94 points
Lovely nose and texture on this chenin blanc.
White
12/14/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
90 points
Very good value white blend.
Red
11/26/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
95 points
What a wine. So impressive for a wine if this age. Still loads of fruit and freshness what a great Italian version of a Bordeaux blend. Super complex. Constantly evolving. One of the best wines I have had recently.
1 person found this helpful Comment
Red
11/5/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
A little disappointing given the hype on release Very old world. Ery tradition nose and flavor but potentially a little corkage on the nose. Still. Drinking well.
White
11/4/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
Really Nice blend. complex but if you don’t pay attention you will finish your glass without even thinking about the wine. Maraliese does it again. Another great wine by her.
Red
11/4/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Another great Cinsault. Very fragrant with good structure and tanins. Can do with aging but still is drinking well now. Light cherries but still good structure.
Red
11/3/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Really interesting syrah. It has a taste and feel of a unoaked syrah. Darker fruit than light fruit. A little olive, tanpenade blackberries flavor.
White
11/3/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Really good chenin. Good complex nose and flavor profile. tastes like a high end chenin producer
Red
2021 Tim Hillock Rooi Western Cape Syrah Blend, Syrah (view label images)
11/2/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
91 points
Easy drinking, light. Nice blend. Good value.
Red
10/22/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
Super dry tanins Dark fruit flavours but needs more time. Decanted for 30min.
White
10/11/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
92 points
A very saline, lemony chenin. So interesting to see the different Chenin styles.
White
10/9/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Lovely chenin. Alittle saliene but good fruit. Good combo of both. has improved with a year of aging. Wish I had more
Red
10/2/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
94 points
Wow this barolo is drinking well now. So much fruit and freshness to it. Lovely rose petal, cherry with a little herb on the nose. On the palate it is dart cherries with a little Tabacco. Loved this wine tonight
Red
10/1/2022 - Paul-SA wrote:
93 points
Impressive 15 yr old Pinot from Oregon still has so much life left. Good fruit and structure. The palate as nice tart fruit. Drinking well but still has a lot to give over the years.
1 - 50 of 258
More results
  • Tasting Notes: 258 notes on 230 wines
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close