This appears to be past its time. I opened the last one two years ago and it was sensational. While the color was still solid and vibrant, the fruit has faded, leaving a leather nose and flavors and slightly drying tannins. A note to this bottle was there appeared to be some storage issues as there were some signs of heat damage on the cork, but the fill was still above the neck and zero signs of seepage.
Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
/ Comment
Beautiful, perfectly balanced and integrated and flawless wine. Medium bodied, not of great density nor depth nor complexity but that isn't all that counts, as so many complex and dense wines lack the elegance and class of this wine. Exudes red fruits, plums and sweet earth. I'm sure many wouldn't score it as highly as I did but I find it to be excellent. So many 97 bordeaux are just like this - beautiful, elegant, enjoyable wines that simply aren't blockbusters or terribly complex but are all that you can ask shy of that.
Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
/ Comment
Tres grand vin, nez de liqueur et de cassis qui tire sur des fruits rouges confiturés. Des aromes de cafe apparaissent apres 1 heure. C'est un vin avec une belle matiere et surtout tres concentré !!! Pas mal de dépôt, c'est un st émilion grandiose qui ne demande qu'à s'épanouir....dégusté avec stef, seb et marie le 10 juillet 2004. Un grand potentiel
Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No
/ Comment
Professional reviews have copyrights and you can view them here for your personal use only as private content. To view pro reviews you must either subscribe to a pre-integrated publication or manually enter reviews below. Learn more.
5/11/2008 - tim_c wrote:
This appears to be past its time. I opened the last one two years ago and it was sensational. While the color was still solid and vibrant, the fruit has faded, leaving a leather nose and flavors and slightly drying tannins. A note to this bottle was there appeared to be some storage issues as there were some signs of heat damage on the cork, but the fill was still above the neck and zero signs of seepage.
Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment
10/10/2006 - pbjosh wrote: 88 Points
Beautiful, perfectly balanced and integrated and flawless wine. Medium bodied, not of great density nor depth nor complexity but that isn't all that counts, as so many complex and dense wines lack the elegance and class of this wine. Exudes red fruits, plums and sweet earth. I'm sure many wouldn't score it as highly as I did but I find it to be excellent. So many 97 bordeaux are just like this - beautiful, elegant, enjoyable wines that simply aren't blockbusters or terribly complex but are all that you can ask shy of that.
Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment
7/10/2004 - agallut wrote: 94 Points
Tres grand vin, nez de liqueur et de cassis qui tire sur des fruits rouges confiturés. Des aromes de cafe apparaissent apres 1 heure. C'est un vin avec une belle matiere et surtout tres concentré !!! Pas mal de dépôt, c'est un st émilion grandiose qui ne demande qu'à s'épanouir....dégusté avec stef, seb et marie le 10 juillet 2004. Un grand potentiel
Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment