Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(9 comments on 9 notes)

1 - 9 of 9 Sort order
Red
2004 Penfolds Grange South Australia Shiraz Blend, Syrah
Barossa Vintage Festival 2015.

Penfolds Magill Estate Restaurant.
78 Penfold Road
Rosslyn Park, South Australia, 5072, Australia.

Tasting glass arranged by Martin and Patrick.

Black impenetrable heart and dark ruby rim.
Primary fruit nose, young buoyant, vanillin.
Medium full bodied, great fruit weight, delish sweet black and red fruit flavours. Seamless mid palate with mocha tannins through the finish.

Blackberry, no Ribena, dark cherry. Enjoyable smokey aromas from 5 hours open.
  • MyCellar01 commented:

    4/23/17, 7:31 AM - Wizlb,

    This was a glass pour from the bottle and was tasted over four hours, I believe the bottle was opened two hours prior.

    At this price point, Grange deserves 20 years in the cellar before opening your first bottle. There are many more less expensive wines to open earlier.

    We purchased a '96 for dinner that night, decanted and consumed over 4 hours. Decanters are a great way to enjoy the development of wine over time as it is exposed to air.

    I have purchased older vintages to drink whilst I wait for the younger bottles to mature, it all depends on your palate preferences as to whether you drink younger or older bottles, and the quality of the wine to improve with age.

White - Sweet/Dessert
1985 Domaine Huet Vouvray Moelleux Clos du Bourg Chenin Blanc
7/20/2016 - MyCellar01 Likes this wine:
95 points
Out of the cellar and into the fridge for two hours.
Popped and poured at the table.
Transparent liquid gold in the glass.
Vouvray honey wafts from the get go, biscuit and bale, mandarin rind, lime zest.
Silken golden lava flows deliciously on the tongue.
Tropical island flavours sell a summer's island holiday to your palate.
One and a half hours open the juice is on song. Lightly honeyed undertones set the course, sweet dried apricots, ride over a plate of ripe orchard fruit with apples and oranges followed by a refreshingly citrus zest endlessly caressing the long finish, all at a sprightly 31 years young.
  • MyCellar01 commented:

    4/8/17, 6:06 PM - Curse autocorrect...
    Thank you ohne_musik. Enjoy!

White
2012 Gérard Boulay Sancerre La Comtesse Sauvignon Blanc
5/11/2014 - d'Artagnan wrote:
93 points
Une version plus qui parait plus travaillée du Monts Damnés, mais il est sans doute simplement plus mûr, car il est élevé en cuve.
Au nez, des notes de citron confit et d’herbes fraiches, d'estragon.
La récolte était sans doute bien mûre car ce Sancerre montre un beau fruit, une belle richesse, avec une saine acidité qui rehausse le tout et apporte la fraicheur naturelle de l’appellation. La finale est subtile et longue. C’est un très beau Sancerre, avec plus de chair que la moyenne, qui parait donc plus dodu, moins tranchant que d’autres vins de l’appellation, superbement équilibré. Avenir assuré. 93 pts

De mémoire, le Monts Damnés « régulier » était plus ouvert et minéral, j’ignore lequel je préfère, il faudrait les prendre côte à côte.
  • MyCellar01 commented:

    1/9/15, 3:44 PM - Google translation to English, with thanks to d'Artagnan.

    "A version that seems more polished over the Monts Damnes, but it is probably just more mature, because it is high in tank.
    On the nose, candied lemon and fresh herbs, tarragon.
    The harvest was probably ripe for it Sancerre shows a beautiful fruit, a nice richness, with a healthy acidity that enhances and brings all the natural freshness of the appellation. The finish is long and subtle. This is a very nice Sancerre, with more flesh than the average, which therefore seems plumper, less sharp than other wines of the appellation, superbly balanced. Secure future. 93 pts

    From memory, the Monts Damnes "regular" was more open and mineral, I know which I prefer, it would take together."

White - Sparkling
N.V. Louis Roederer Champagne Brut Premier Champagne Blend
12/12/2014 - Xavier Auerbach wrote:
91 points
A pretty recent disgorgement, probably late 2013. The back label states: L 03884 1A101814. If someone can make sense of this code, please let me know. Anyway. Vinous and rich style, red apple fruit from the Pinot Noir, complex and masculine but also silky and stylish, hint of honey and nutty evolution (white walnut), very good intensity and length. Exemplary Brut Premier.
  • MyCellar01 commented:

    12/12/14, 11:26 AM - http://www.louis-roederer.com/en/identification/L037420A106671

Red
2008 Castelgiocondo (Marchesi de' Frescobaldi) Brunello di Montalcino Sangiovese
5/18/2014 - MyCellar01 wrote:
88 points
Light nose, medium fruit, nice mouthfeel, medium chalky tannins mid-palate overwhelm the fruit to finish earthy.
  • MyCellar01 commented:

    11/2/14, 11:25 PM - Happy to hear my note was helpful mulligan452.
    Only a quick TN at the Emirates lounge in Rome, much rather a sit down with the bottle over a number of hours or days if required.
    Having no prior knowledge of the Producer I called it as I found it in the glass. That said, the current release ('09) is five years old which suggests the Producer knows this wine needs time, and CT users suggest a start on the drinking window of 7-9 years on differing vintages and I would agree, the '08 could use another two or three in the cellar.
    I do like to let my wines lie in the cellar and CT users suggest a drink by date of 12-17 years, vintage depending.
    However, '08 may be regarded as a lessor vintage in Tuscany, and make for earlier drinking than other fruit focused years, with a half bottle maturing in two-thirds of the drinking window of a 750ml.

Red
2002 Penfolds Bin 389 South Australia Cabernet-Shiraz Blend, Red Blend
4/22/2013 - deverett wrote:
91 points
Drank over two days and this was significantly better on day 2. The first day was still very closed, very coarse tannins with the cabernet profile dominating. Day 2 was completely different with more balance, black fruit, liquorice, bitter chocolate, vanilla and some toasty oak with the shiraz appearing more dominant. A good 389 with plenty of gas left in the tank.
  • MyCellar01 commented:

    8/25/14, 5:42 PM - My thoughts exactly.

White
2011 Domaine François Cotat Sancerre Les Monts Damnés Sauvignon Blanc
6/21/2014 - d'Artagnan wrote:
89 points
Un nez de poires caramélisées, de citron confit.
l’acidité me parait relativement basse et il est plutôt rond, davantage que tranchant. La finale apporte des sensations de pierre chaude et de craie, avec une longueur correcte, mais relativement modeste pour le domaine.
Après des Boulay en demi-teinte, ceci me confirme que 2011 est un millésime chaud dans l’appellation, qui manque de profondeur. Heureusement, il est encadré par deux millésimes magnifiques en 2010 et 2012.
En bref, un beau vin mais pas au niveau des meilleures réussites du domaine. 89 pts
  • MyCellar01 commented:

    6/23/14, 12:07 AM - Google Translation, hopefully, accurate..

    A nose of caramelized pears, lemon confit.
    acidity seems to me relatively low and rather round, rather than cutting. The final brings sensations of hot stone and chalk, with proper length, but relatively modest for the domain.
    After Boulay halftone This confirms that 2011 is a hot year in the label, which lacks depth. Fortunately, it is framed by two magnificent vintages in 2010 and 2012.
    In short, a nice wine but not at the highest achievements in the field. 89 pts

Red
2010 Vietti Barolo Castiglione Nebbiolo
5/28/2014 - MWiking wrote:
92 points
fin näsa, aningen fet i doften, smörkola, mörk frukt, mörka körsbär, hallonlakrits, violer.

smak, lätt mjukt vin, mycket körsbär, mycket taniner som klistrar sig i gommen, väldigt stiligt och kommer nog utvecklas till nåt stort längre fram. Behöver tid
  • MyCellar01 commented:

    5/28/14, 2:24 PM - Google translation for our non-Swedish users (hope you don't mind MWIKING, and hope Google translates correctly).

    "fine nose, slightly oily on the nose, caramel, dark fruit, black cherry, raspberry licorice, violets.

    taste, slightly soft wine, very cherry, very tannins which adheres to the palate, very stylish and will probably evolve into something big later on. needs time."

White - Sweet/Dessert
2002 Domaine Huet Vouvray Moelleux 1ère Trie Le Mont Chenin Blanc
6/30/2012 - Paul S wrote:
95 points
Loire Odyssey, Part V - I did it my Huët (Absinthe, Boat Quay): The youngest wine of the night, and I thought the best. This was pretty special stuff. It had an amazing nose, going off like fireworks in the glass, with an explosion of honeyed aromas and ripe red apples, flint and smoke, white meat and earth, and lifted accents of freshly mown grass with touches of lanolin and a hint of spice. Beguiling stuff, expressive, yet with a mellow gentleness to the way it came together in beautifully integrated whole. The same could be said about the palate. Soft, melting, luxurious, it glided across the mouth with golden honeyed tones and pure flavours of ripe red apples, fresh apricots and sweet lemons ,edged with a touch of burnt creme brulee and butterscotch at the fringes. Absolutely complex and delicious. It was so very creamy and velvety, yet was at the same time lifted by a beautifully integrated stream of acidity that kept the wine incredibly pure and perfectly balanced. A profound wine, complex yet effortless, deep yet weightless, mature yet ageless, and all underlined by a tremendous minerality that gave the it a great sense of defintion. A very complete wine. Good when first poured from the decanter, this just grew and grew in the glass too, opening up in generously fleshy white fruit flavours across the mid and back-palate. To top it all off, it was a mindblowing pairing with a simple but perfectly executed dish of foie gras and white truffles on toast over a bed of caramelised onions. Something just clicked as the savoury food and the honeyed fruit of the wine came together - the heavens opened, angels sang, and we fell into a blissful silence. One of the best pairings I have ever had. Great food, brilliant wine. Wow. It was such a moment that it almost made be give up my notes and quite forget that the wine is actually very, very young. It was drinking beautifully now, but like so many of these Huëts, it is probably indestructible and will last for decades more.
  • MyCellar01 commented:

    5/3/14, 8:22 AM - If there were such a wine which could be described as 'Nectar of the Gods,' then THIS is it!

    I could write no better tasting note than that of Paul S, and so with all credit due, would like to repost his tasting note in exaltation of a great wine, and a true connoisseur in Paul S, and his eloquent elevation of text to the rarified air of prose which Angels speak.

    Thank you Paul S.

1 - 9 of 9
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close