Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Blind Tasting - Battle of the States

Tasted October 25, 2014 by CamWheeler with 449 views

Flight 1 (26 notes)

White - Sparkling
1999 Lark Hill Methode Champenoise Pinot Noir Chardonnay Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
88 points
Earth, ginger, ash, some floral notes and also a vegetal undertone. Palate is rounded with a caramel note but it has retained nice acidity. Has some interesting character to it.
White
2004 Lark Hill Riesling Australia, New South Wales, Southern New South Wales, Canberra District
90 points
Floral, musk, some kero, spice and earth. Medium length. Nicely balanced with a touch of sweetness about it. Drinking nicely now.
White - Off-dry
2012 Mac Forbes Riesling EB04 Tradition Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Yarra Valley
90 points
Orange peel, herbs and a soapy floral lift. Good body and really nice texture to it. Wasn't surprised when this was revealed as I had tried it a year ago and it was consistent with that taste.
White
1996 Rockford Riesling Hand Picked Eden Valley Australia, South Australia, Barossa, Eden Valley
86 points
Toast and wooden with some light floral notes in behind. Fading on the palate, with the fruit falling away. Still drinkable but this bottle not providing a huge amount of pleasure.
White
2000 Petaluma Chardonnay Australia, South Australia, Mount Lofty Ranges, Piccadilly Valley
92 points
Talc, spice, honey, pineapple and a light oak note. Great acidity, really nicely balanced. Had this a few months ago and it is maybe even a touch better than the last great bottle. Superb.
White
2007 By Farr Chardonnay Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Geelong
90 points
Smoky oak, bacon and pine aromas. Fairly rounded on the palate, with the oak providing good structure, but not quite having settled just yet. Currently at an in-between stage.
White
1998 Brokenwood Chardonnay Graveyard Australia, New South Wales, Hunter Valley
87 points
Mint, florals and a bit of a freezer burnt character that detracts. Palate is nicely honeyed, with medium length and a kick of acid through the middle. Nearing the end of its life but holding up okay.
White
2000 Bannockburn Chardonnay S.R.H. Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Geelong
flawed
Soy and caramel with a bitter edge. I think good bottles of this might be few and far between at this stage.
White
2011 Chrismont Petit Manseng Australia, Victoria, North East, King Valley
88 points
Pithy lemon, tropical fruit, some musky florals. Provides both sweetness and decent minerality on the palate. Carries nicely. Not complex but has some appeal.
White
2004 Tahbilk Viognier Australia, Victoria, Central Victoria, Nagambie Lakes
89 points
Floral, spice, lemon and honey. Good fresh mouthfeel, nice medium length and still has some fruit weight behind it without feeling dense. No real overt Viognier character to it but holding up really nicely.
White
1999 Tyrrell's Sémillon Futures Australia, New South Wales, Hunter Valley
85 points
Grapefruit, vanilla and honey. Just holding up on the palate, doesn't seem faulty, just seems old without having developed significant character.
White
1999 Mount Pleasant Wines Sémillon Single Vineyard Lovedale Australia, New South Wales, Hunter Valley
flawed
Oxidized. Has elements of goodness but not good.
Red
2004 Keith Tulloch Shiraz Kester Australia, New South Wales, Hunter Valley
88 points
Charcoal, graphite, meaty, cherry and a little bit of VA - plenty going on. Has an interesting savoury character on the palate, the tannins do stand out a bit even with some quite intense fruit. Palate isn't as interesting as the nose but it had certainly developed since I tried it in its youth.
Red
2005 Setanta Shiraz Cuchulain Australia, South Australia, Mount Lofty Ranges, Adelaide Hills
88 points
Herbal, earth, mint and licorice. Nice medium weight profile but started to fade a bit in the glass which is a concern for its future prospects. Medium length and well balanced for now.
Red
2005 Te Mata Estate Syrah Bullnose New Zealand, North Island, Hawke's Bay
86 points
White pepper, sawdust and oak, floral and chocolate. Lean on the palate, and it doesn't carry the oak treatment. Okay but Oaky.
Red
2008 Sutton Grange Syrah HOG Block Estate Australia, Victoria, Central Victoria, Bendigo
89 points
Rosemary, redcurrant, spice and herbs. Nice pure fruit on the palate, with a mineral core and good length. Strongest wine of this Shiraz flight.
Red
1991 Tyrrell's Shiraz Cabernet Show Reserve Australia
90 points
Hunter/Coonawarra blend. Raspberry, redcurrant, earth and charred meats. Very good flavour intensity that really needs food to show its best. A little more complexity and this would be amazing but it is just excellent as it is.
Red
2012 William Downie Pinot Noir Yarra Valley Australia, Victoria, Port Phillip, Yarra Valley
90 points
Floral, raspberry and stems with an additional herbal note to it. Not all about the fruit but it does stand out as Australian anyway. Nicely restrained on the palate, with good acidity. This is very young but I like it and would happily look at it again with some additional age.
Red
1990 Lindeman's Cabernet Sauvignon St. George Australia, South Australia, Limestone Coast, Coonawarra
90 points
Redcurrant, leather and mint. Medium bodied, good tannin resolution with some sweet red fruits still present. Very good!
Red
2003 Seppelt Cabernet Sauvignon Moyston Australia, Victoria
88 points
Chocolate, licorice and vanilla - nose is a little muted throughout. Medium bodied, nicely balanced. Good but not really pushing to be great.
Red
2006 Lake's Folly Cabernets Australia, New South Wales, Hunter Valley
90 points
Chocolate, spice, raspberry and graphite. Good fruit intensity with plenty of tannins to back it up. Still very young and really needs more time.
Red
2012 Cirami Estate Lagrein Australia, South Australia, Lower Murray, Riverland
85 points
Cloudy colour. Citrus and herbal nose, certainly different. Very light body, with some of the herbal element pushing through. Not to my taste.
Red
2013 Unico Zelo Nebbiolo Lunga Kersbrook Australia, South Australia, Mount Lofty Ranges, Adelaide Hills
88 points
Kirsch, smoke, chocolate and tobacco. A little plush on the palate, it doesn't seem to have a huge amount of Nebbiolo character but it is a nice younger drinking style.
Red
2013 Joadja Vineyards Malbec Reserve Australia, New South Wales, South Coast, Southern Highlands
85 points
Ginger bread, bubblegum, pine and herbs. The palate isn't as interesting, it wants some more tannin and acid for structure and lift. Overall good, but I'm okay to have only tried it once.
Red
1994 Mount Pleasant Wines Shiraz Philip Australia, New South Wales, Hunter Valley
85 points
Band aids and spice - fruit is masked. Palate has the same brett taking over. Not a positive bottle to me.
Red
2009 The Colonial Estate Shiraz Mungo Park Australia, South Australia, Barossa, Barossa Valley
87 points
Blackcurrant and oak with some kirsch and pencil shavings. Palate has good richness from the fruit, with medium structure keeping it moving. Nice but a little bit boring.
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close