Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Dinner at Tosca

Tosca Restaurant, Ritz-Carlton Hotel, Hong Kong

Tasted July 25, 2015 by Goldstone with 367 views

Introduction

A quiet threesome dinner on the 102nd floor overlooking Victoria Harbour on a clear night - what's not to like!

I had promised to bring the wines and thought I'd go for one of my "Might this be the next Grange?" purchases that I last tried 5 years ago and a Bourdeaux-like Napa paired vs a Napa-like Bordeaux.

The Chef at Tosca was joined by the Ritz-Calton's Executive Chef - Peter Find - to deliver us a perfect 7-course indulgent dinner of their own composition.....brilliant job, guys!

I will always remember how the room filled with the lovely richness of great wine when the first two were poured.......and the food was fantastic, if a little rich.

Flight 1 - Beef Tatare, Two Pastas & Roast Lamb (2 notes)

I really thought that I might fool Mark & Tracey with these two wines and they'd get them the wrong way around........nope, the Dominus was spotted and drooled over in a moment.

Interestingly, the Pontet-Canet has become much more Bordeaux-like in the 5 years since I last drank it, when it was a dead ringer for a Pahlmeyer.

I was not surprised by the stellar quality of the 1997 vintage of Dominus and the fact that it has at least another decade to fully open up but I was more intrigued by how the Pontet-Canet is evolving into a 1st-Growth wine in terms of sophistication. Comparatively, it is 5 times the wine I paid for it en primeur.

Red
2003 Château Pontet-Canet France, Bordeaux, Médoc, Pauillac
93 points
Decanted for 4.5 hours before taking to the restaurant. It is still a teeth-staining dense and thick red-purple colour. The nose just jumped out of the glass and filled the room........ deep, deep, rich essence of St. Julien with superb fruit concentration and purity....as if a Michelin chef had created the perfect blackcurrant pastille....lots of graphite, really linear in the perfectly machined black slab way. Palate has become more rounded since I last drank it. Very extracted but not in a bad way ( I generally don't like extracted wines), mouth-coating in texture and sensation, still lots of new oak and the tannin on the finish is quite austere with the same 'black slab' sensation as the nose. This has become a younger, more structured and more serious wine in the recent times I have drank it and I think that something extremely good will emerge over the next 5 years or so. A triumph for the vintage.
2 people found this helpful Comment
Red
1997 Dominus Estate USA, California, Napa Valley
94 points
Decanted for 2 hours then re-bottled for another 4 hours before taking to the restaurant. Perfect cork as though it had been bottled yesterday. Completely opaque and dense purple-red colour that looks 10 years younger than its age. Nose filled the room on pouring..... very perfumed, almost Merlot-like.....complex, deep and mesmerising. Palate has that perfect immediate top-tier Napa attack of gorgeous fresh acidity and purity of fruit but the tannins are still young and not very well integrated on the mid-palate; then BANG! ....a wonderful rolling, ascending, reverberating resonance on the finish that blows you away and resonates for a minute or more and leaves you simultaneously with a belly-filling richness of fruit and spice. Quite acidic and tannic even 8 hours after the initial decant - this is a young wine that is only just entering its proper drinking window even though it seduced me when I last drank it in 2010. Everybody's WOTN.....next time I will open the 1986 and keep the rest of these for 5 more years.
1 person found this helpful Comment

Flight 2 - Three Gorgeous Italian Cheeses (1 note)

These cheeses really did the wine proud and allowed it a few more hours' decant.

Red
2001 Clarendon Hills Astralis Australia, South Australia, Fleurieu, Clarendon
92 points
Decanted for 10 hours before pouring with a return to the bottle in between home and restaurant. Seeped but completely intact cork. Gosh....the colour is a vivid and dense purple with highlights of velvet red......I can't help but think that it would appeal to Donatella Versache. Nose is Barolo-esque black liquorice stick spice, black and red liquorice bootlaces candy, tar, sun-warmed asphalt, dried star anise in a curry. really mesmerising but still young and playing 'catch me if you can'. Palate is deep, rich, rounded, very heady and reverberant even before you swallow - star anise, black liquorice root and tons of fresh cardomon that really stands out. Ultra-smooth and unctuous mouthfeel with superb resonance and reverberance and endless length. Ultra-yummy and the most hedonistic of the wines tonight but a bit one-dimensional in comparison. We made a good decision to hold off on this until a course of 3 beautiful Italian cheeses as it repaid the extra time in the decanter. I wanted to like this wine more but I can't see it developing the multi-dimensional complexity for a Grange or a Hill of Grace as it ages over the next decade, although I'm sure it will improve.

Closing

We all agreed that the Astralis won the 'Yummy" award but it lost out on any more sophisticated measures to the Pontet-Canet and the Dominus.

© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close