Tasting pour. Green apple, juicy, slight yeastiness. More similar to champagne than say a vintage Schramsberg.
Nice bright fruit.
Me - 91, Wife - 90

Tasting pour. High toned acid touched by slight oak. Some richness.
Fair amount of oak/butter, as well as stone fruit.

Me - 90/91, Wife - 92/93

Tasting pour.
Odd bottle -- the group discussed whether it was flawed but in the end decided against it.
Definitely Burgundian in style, but even so this just lacked fruit and acidity, although it did show some spice.

Tasting pour.
Bright fruit (especially following the Rhys), well structured, lush, earthy w/great acidity and spice. Some notes of vanilla and smoke on nose - roasted marshmallow?

Me - 92, Wife - 92/93 (but less balanced than others in lineup after returning, 91 pts)

Tasting pour.
Well balanced, dried & dark fruit. Smooth, and a more elegant expression of zinfandel than say a Bedrock or Carlisle. In this tasting format we actually enjoyed the wine much more than the bottle drunk last year. This seemed rich compared to other wines in the lineup (other than the Saxum).
Me - 91, Wife - 92

Tasting pour.
This is a burly steak wine with enough Napa fruit to keep it interesting. Smooth, integrated tannins.

Me - 91, Wife - 90

Tasting pour.
Even with a 3 hour decant this seemed tight, too young, and quite tannic. Hard to evaluate with a tasting pour, but in general this was not my preferred style of high-toned Napa fruit.

Tasting pour.
Ya, more our style of cab - high toned ripe fruit, red fruited. This was PnP so a little tight/tannic, but man this is flavorful. However, despite a fair amount of tannins they were somewhat disorganized and didn't provide as much structure as expected.
All that said, this is a fun Napa cab. Drink now, age, whatever.
Special thanks to the host for opening this extra bottle for the group.

Me - 91, Wife - 93

Tasting pour.
Hard to evaluate at this point of the evening. This stood out as such a big wine, but seemed almost over the top compared to the other wines in the lineup. However, this was still our WOTN and the group's WOTN. I'd like to drink a full bottle of this wine sometime in order to better evaluate it. I am curious how this will age.
Big, powerful, and tasty. At 15.8% ABV it was a little boozy, but the tannins were well integrated. If I were to have this wine with food I'd pair a nice juicy steak.
The finish stood out compared to others in the lineup -- long, long finish.
Thanks to Joe for sharing.
Me - 92/93, Wife - 92/93

Tasting pour.
Inky black, super spicy, secondary aromas and flavors (mushroom, earth), black fruit. Tannic yet smooth. An interesting wine.