Important Update From the Founder
Read message >
Dinner with Herwig
Heirloom Cafe, SF
Tasted January 10, 2023 by aagrawal with 173 views
Introduction
Superlative dinner. Everything showed well, and the company was fantastic. The Yquem wasn't bad either.
Flight 1 (11 notes)
Red
1995 Philip Togni Cabernet Sauvignon
94 points
Double decanted and tasted. Deep ruby, overall youthful for its age with minimal bricking; high intensity aromatics, classic bell pepper predominant as is common with Togni, blackcurrant, a bit herbal; palate is full bodied, elegant medium to medium-plus acidity, tannins fully integrated, certainly green notes predominate as fruit reaches maturity and is less predominant, twang of bitterness through the midpalate; finish is medium-plus length. For now 92, though this comes across as quite a bit more green than my last bottle two years ago and I expect some air will help this balance out.
30 min air: Greenness is much more integrated into the overall wine, though still a prominent component of the nose and palate. 93+
3 hours in bottle: really markedly better integrated, the black fruit is coming out a bit more, greenness has integrated. Certainly positively evolved with air. 94
30 min air: Greenness is much more integrated into the overall wine, though still a prominent component of the nose and palate. 93+
3 hours in bottle: really markedly better integrated, the black fruit is coming out a bit more, greenness has integrated. Certainly positively evolved with air. 94
1 person found this helpful
Comment
White - Sweet/Dessert
1975 Château Coutet Barsac
92 points
Golden-orange color, great for its age; aromatic, orange blossom, white flowers, citrus peel, slight honey; palate is medium bodied, sweet but balanced by exceptional medium-plus acidity which counterbalances the sweetness until it is barely perceptible through the midpalate, clean palate throughout with some orange blossom, floral, citrus rind; finish is medium length, clean, balanced, and refreshing. Consistent with my last bottle 4+ years ago, this has classic Coutet balance with prominent acidity balancing the sweetness, Barsac-classic florals and orange blossom, not showing any of the caramel but certainly showing some maturity, not reaching otherworldly complexity but a very solid enjoyable sauternes which will age for another decade or two without problems. 92
1 person found this helpful
Comment
White - Sparkling
2008 Louis Roederer Champagne Cristal Brut
95 points
Exceptional aromatics, fresh but with some richness from age, high acidity; long long finish. Lovely young champagne. 95
4 people found this helpful
Comment
White
2013 Littorai Chardonnay Charles Heintz Vineyard
90 points
Golden pear, kiwi, lychee, high intensity aromatics, some floral; palate is full bodied, richly textured, medium-plus acidity, a bit short through the midpalate, white fruited; finish is medium length. Good but lacking the depth in the palate. Aromatics are phenomenal. 90
White
2002 Coche-Dury Meursault Les Rougeots
93 points
Fantastic aromatics, slight reduction, nutmeg spice, mint, white fruit; palate is medium-full bodied, not quite as rich as this level of white burgundy, high acidity, somewhat moderated fruit, lots underlying that will open up; medium-plus finish. Lovely wine burgundy. 93
White
2016 Walter Scott Chardonnay X-Novo Vineyard
90 points
Aromatic with reduction and some spice from oak, a bit hard to evaluate; palate is rich with high acidity, lemon zest; finish is medium length. There nose is a bit difficult but promising overall. Needs air. 90
Red
1992 Calera Pinot Noir Mount Harlan Cuvée
91 points
Aromatic, roses and floral, mature red fruits, lovely nose; palate is light bodied, excellent fruit and maturity, minerality, integrated tannins; medium finish. Gorgeous wine at maturity. 91
Red
2016 Thomas Pinot Noir Dundee Hills
92 points
Aromatic, spicy, red fruited, youthful, almost vosne-styled spices; palate is medium bodied, medium-plus acidity, balanced tannins, youthful, easy drinking; medium finish. Obviously well made with aromatics its strength. 92
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Red
1998 Lagier Meredith Syrah
91 points
A bit plummy and red fruit, minerality; palate is medium bodied, medium plus acidity, lovely elegant and minerality red fruit; finish is medium length. Nice and solid Syrah, balanced. 91
Red
1996 Robert Mondavi Winery Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve
91 points
Black fruited, aromatic; palate is full bodied, still black fruits, integrated but not showing a lot of tertiary character, fades a bit through the midpalate; finish is medium-minus. I think aged but not showing the tertiary character. 89
Over dinner this really integrated well and started showing substantially better. 91, possibly higher, but drink now.
Over dinner this really integrated well and started showing substantially better. 91, possibly higher, but drink now.
1 person found this helpful
Comment
White - Sweet/Dessert
1943 Château d'Yquem
96 points
Deep orange-caramel, appropriate color for its age; intense aromatics with dried orange, apricot, some honey, developed but not quite caramel, a little nutty with almond; palate is richly textured but absolutely vibrant acidity, orange peel, orange marmalade, dried apricot, intense with some spice, complexity; finish is long. The only comparison I have for this is the ‘67 which was more complex, but this is a special experience and certainly a stellar Sauternes and Yquem. 96