Important Update From the Founder
Read message >
18 wines on a Saturday afternoon
Tasted November 28, 2009 by Loren Sonkin with 719 views
Introduction
A group of us got together to open some bottles blind and do some "holiday shopping". The theme was "not from North America". Blind tasting is hard, but it gets harder when you know everyone elses cellars and factor that into your guess. This time, many of us, tried to stretch out a bit. Lots of good wines, nothing incredible although there were many wines I had not tried before and that is always fun and appreciated. Thanks to Bob for hosting. Thanks to Tom and Dave for the food. Let's not wait so long for the next time.
Flight 1 (18 notes)
White
2000 Weingut Hirsch Riesling Gaisberg
91 points
Golden in color. The nose has honey and a slight petrol note. Not completely dry which curprised me. Complex with a pineapple and mineral note. More pineapple on the finish. I really thought this wine was in a very good place. Not showing its age IMO.
White
2004 Radford Wines Riesling Old Vines High Altitude
85 points
Blind this had me stumped. Light golden in color. The nose was a bit metallic and seemed slightly oxidized. Also some orange peel. Thin and a good amount of acidity. Once I saw what it was, it made more sense. The metallic note seemed more petrol. was it air or the power of the mind. I am not sure, but i liked it better after knowing what it was. Still, not my favorite expression of Riesling.
Red
1999 Domaine de l'Oratoire St Martin Cairanne Cuvée Prestige
86 points
Ruby in color, mostly clear and bright. The nose is dusty with plenty of funk and slight cherry notes. Soft. Light cherries on the palate. Just lacking some oomph.
Red
2000 Domaine de l'Oratoire St Martin Cairanne Cuvée Prestige
89 points
The best of the three IMO although some said they got some spritz on the palate. I did not notice that but I did get a lot of acidity. Dusty, musty nose with cassis and black raspberries. On the palatte, this is sweet on the attack. Complex. Black raspberries. Good acidity. Lots of tannins. Long finish. I liked this wine.
Red
2001 Domaine de l'Oratoire St Martin Cairanne Cuvée Prestige
88 points
Purple in color, mostly opaque and bright. The nose is dusty with cherries and leather. Complex. On the palate, this has tart cherries. Seems slightly over the hill though. A bitterness mars the finish. Drink up.
Red
2001 Emilio Clemente Utiel-Requena Crianza
90 points
Ruby in color, clear and bright. The nose has black cherries, black licorice and slight leather notes. On the palate, black cherry cough syrup. Slight tannins. this seems quite young still.
Red
1999 Luigi Pira Barolo Marenca
flawed
Ruby in color, clear and bright. The only Barolo I noted blind. The nose is dusty with cherries and tar. Medium bodied. The palate seems a bit muted with good acidity. After about two hours, it was clear, this wine was corked. I wondered earlier on, but was not sure. then it really showed the TCA. Too bad.
Red
2000 Bodegas y Viñedos San Roman Toro Viña San Román
90 points
Purple/ruby in color. The nose is very unique with cinammon, spice (allspice?) and cherries. A bit thin at first but with air it builds out. Young and very tannic.
Red
2001 Mount Mary Quintet
91 points
Blind I thought this was Bordeaux. If Charlie had not brought it, I would not have even thought Oz. Ruby in color with some purple swirls. Mostly clear and bright. The nose is dusty, complex with cassis, cherries, pencil led and a bit of tobacco. A bit tart with great cherry and cassis fruit. Excellent acidity. Long finsih. 12.5% Alc. Very impressive.
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Red
1999 Coriole Cabernet-Merlot Mary Kathleen Reserve
92 points
I liked this even better than the mount Mary due to its complexity. Ruby?purple in color. The nose is dusty black raspberries with graphite and some mint. I was not surprised to find this from Oz. Complex and restrained with great fruit. Medium tannins. I thought this perhaps had some Shiraz, but I was wrong. Another new wine for me that was very good.
Red
1996 Cavallotto Barolo Bricco Boschis
88 points
Blind, I had no clue that this was Barolo. Still, I enjoyed it. Ruby in color, clear and bright. There was little nose. With coaxing, I got earthy cherries. More raspberries on the paalte. Very one dimensional and simple. Medium tannins. I had no clue what this wass, but thought perhaps a Rhone wine of some kind. Still, it was pleasurable drinking.
Red
1998 Buil & Giné Montsant St. Gregori
87 points
Ruby in color, clear and bright. The nose has a lot of funk with cherries, black olives and iodine. I am guessing some Monastrell here, but don't know the grapes. On the palate, more black cherries. Nice acidity. Nice wine that is very Rhone like. 13.25% Alc.
Red
1998 Silvio Grasso Barolo Bricco Luciani
92 points
My favorite wine on this afternoon. Ruby in color, clear and bright. The nose is dusty with cherries, cassis, graphite and tar. Soft texture. Mature and complex. Cherries on the palate with excellent minerality. Slight tannins. I thought this was from the southwest of France, but in retrospect, I should have guessed this. Jeff brought it, and I think I factored that into my decision.
Red
2004 Marquis Philips Cabernet Sauvignon S2
82 points
Not sure if this was an off bottle. Inky purple in color. The nose has tons of alcohol. Disjointed. A dead animal note but lots of black raspberry fruit. A bit better on the nose with sweet black raspberry jam. Some pepper. This was very alcoholic tasting. I suppose some must have liked it more than I but there was little discussion on this wine.
Red
1997 Rainoldi Valtellina Superiore - Sassella Riserva
Light ruby in color. The nose is dusty with cherries and roses. Complex on the palate but a bit faded. Cherries with mild tannins. Surprisingly, I thought this put on weight and body and color as the afternoon progressed. Never a block buster, but a nice mature nebbiolo.
Red
2001 Il Molino di Grace Gratius Toscana IGT
90 points
Ruby/purple in color but slightly cloudy. The nose has cherries and oak with hints of cassis. Some complexity on the palate, but still seems youthful. Nice finish. We discussed the producer a lot (who has some Cleveland ties). I like them very much, but I am not ready to put them in the top tier (yet). Very fruit forward stuff.
Red
2006 McPrice Myers Hommage a Stevan Larner Larner Vineyard
92 points
Mike added this after the tasting. Off theme but that's ok. Magenta purple in color. The nose has raspberries, cocoa, black raspberries and grilled meats. Sweet black cherry fruit on the palate. Easy to drink with some heat (probably needs just a bit of air) and slight tannins. Very gulpable wine but also quite interesting.
Red
2001 Señorío de Sarría Reserva Especial
89 points
Dark purple in color with some maroon. Dusty cherries and hints of dill on the nose. Sweet black cherry fruit on the palate and also a prune note. Lots of tannins, but this was popped and poured right near the end so perhaps some air will help this settle out. Some dill follows thru to the palate. Very modern wine. I thought it was mostly Tempranillo, but others thought Garnacha. Perhaps a blend?