Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(9 comments on 9 notes)

1 - 9 of 9 Sort order
White
2012 Jean-Paul & Benoit Droin Chablis 1er Cru Montée de Tonnerre Chardonnay
12/1/2018 - Pebben wrote:
92 points
From memory: “Modern” in style with notes of ripe yellow fruit, honey, seashore and oak. Concentrated and long, with beginning signs of age-induced complexity. A big and bold Chablis that in my view lands just on the right side of overdone. I find it delicious, but it's probably not a favourite with purists.
  • Pebben commented:

    12/4/18, 12:01 AM - Thanks for commenting. I guess that’s how it goes – even hear they’re growing Riesling on the west coast of Norway now.

Red
2013 Greywacke Pinot Noir Marlborough
9/18/2016 - Pebben wrote:
92 points
Tasted immediately after opening. Medium purple core, pink rim. On the nose; wild strawberries, floral perfume, moist earth, Asian spices and salty caramel. On the palate; medium bodied, good depth and lovely balance. Certainly a top quality NZ Pinot that seems to improve every year, but given the latest price increase ($50 as opposed to $43 for the 2011 vintage here in Norway) the list of good alternatives has expanded quite a bit. Drink 2016-2021.
  • Pebben commented:

    8/20/17, 11:14 AM - Thanks for the comment. I'm afraid I'm not up to date with the exhange rate. I have been using a fixed rate of 6 NOK/USD since I started posting notes. This was perhaps correct in 2010, but not any more. $50 would thus imply NOK 300 (which is still a bit more than you're paying in Sweden - as usual for wines in this price bracket...).

Red
2011 Alonso del Yerro Ribera del Duero Tempranillo
4/10/2016 - Pebben wrote:
90 points
Popped and poured. Opaque purple colour – more or less black. On the nose; mostly black fruit, liquorish and wood, but also some faint green notes in the form of pine needles and bell peppers. On the palate; sweet fruit and viscous texture – lacks a little depth on the mid-palate, but has enough structure to prevent it from feeling too jammy. Definitely a BIG wine that won’t appeal to everybody, but in my view a fine example of this style of winemaking. Great value too – you could probably pay twice as much for a muscle Ribera without getting anything materially superior. Drinking well even now, but should keep past 2020 – one for the upcoming barbecue season (and the next one...).
  • Pebben commented:

    6/12/16, 4:54 AM - Thanks

Red
2012 Radio-Coteau Pinot Noir Savoy Vineyard Anderson Valley
5/16/2016 - Pebben wrote:
91 points
From memory: Dark Pinot fruit, dry soil, spices, vanilla-toffee and a touch of stable on the nose and palate. Medium bodied, smooth and well balanced – very nice! At close to $80 a bottle (roughly $20 more than I paid for the 08 La Neblina back in 2012), the QPR is however no longer particularly impressive.
  • Pebben commented:

    5/17/16, 12:02 PM - Thanks for the tip, but since I live in Norway I'm pretty much stuck with the prices offered by the state wine and spirits monopoly.

White
2011 André Perret Condrieu Chery Viognier
5/16/2015 - Pebben wrote:
Popped and poured. Pale straw colour. Peaches, tropical fruit, white flowers, sea spray, honey and caramel on the nose and palate. Rich, concentrated and slightly oily textured. Obvious qualities here, but in my view desperately lacking acidity – not a major problem on the attack or mid-palate, but the finish comes across as both cloying and short. Being out of step with the CT majority on my first (serious) Condrieu, obviously makes me cautious as far as scoring is concerned. Perhaps this bottle should have been popped two years ago, or perhaps this is just a varietal thing that requires experience to properly appreciate – hard for me to judge.
  • Pebben commented:

    6/12/15, 6:46 AM - Thanks for commenting. Well this means I just have to practise more - not the worst thing in the world come to think of it :-)

Red
2009 Dominio de Tares Bierzo Cepas Viejas Mencía
5/10/2015 - Pebben wrote:
93 points
See earlier notes.
  • Pebben commented:

    5/19/15, 1:27 AM - Thanks for commenting. Unfortunately the alcohol tax is substantial in this country (combined with a high price level in general). Since the tax is flat, relatively inexpensive wines will seem (very) pricy compared to most other countries. However, since the state monopoly is one of the world's biggest buyers, there are often great bargains to be had if you venture up the price ladder. Enjoy the wine!

Red
2010 Giacomo Conterno Barbera d'Alba Cerretta
3/7/2015 - Pebben wrote:
90 points
Decanted for just under an hour before tasting. Dark purple core, pink rim. Still young and a bit rough around the edges. Ripe black cherries, dry soil, spices and vanilla on the nose and palate. Doesn’t quite display the same depth and concentration as the Casina Francia, but shares the same need for further oak integration. Finishes off with powerful and slightly bitter tannins. Enjoyable today, but should improve during the next three to four years (90-92 points).
  • Pebben commented:

    3/7/15, 8:01 AM - Thanks for commenting. I saw your note just after posting my own, and, while not completely shut down, the wine was considerably more restrained on the palate than I remember the Casina Francia to be (which I had quite a while back). I have little experience with the producer and vineyards, so it was hard for me to judge if this was an expression of natural terroir differences or not. After reading your note, however, things started to make sense. Still enjoyed the wine though...

Red
2005 Domaine de la Vieille Julienne Châteauneuf-du-Pape Red Rhone Blend
1/25/2015 - Pebben wrote:
88 points
Decanted for close to two hours before tasting. Opaque purple core, pink rim. Ripe black fruit, dried figs, Christmas spices, garrigue, leather and vanilla on the nose and palate. An absolutely massive CdP that in my view lacks the acidity to maintain balance – nice flavours, but comes across as very heavy and uninspiring after only a few sips. There’s also a fair bit of heat on the finish that adds to the general feeling of disappointment. Will no doubt divide opinions, though – if Amarone is your thing, you might have a very different take on this than me.
  • Pebben commented:

    1/26/15, 5:29 AM - Thanks for commenting. I don't mind muscular wines from time to time, but they need lots of acidity to avoid coming across as flabby. This was clearly not the case here... I have no experience with this producer, but based on general reputation I would regard this as a disappointment. I have one bottle of 07 in stock - let's hope that's better (though I have my doubts)...

Red
2004 Château La Conseillante Pomerol Red Bordeaux Blend
8/23/2014 - Pebben wrote:
88 points
Not nearly as good as my previous three bottles. Displays the same lovely bouquet, but comes across as fairly austere and one-dimensional on the palate. It’s been almost two years since I last had one of these, and though I currently believe this to be an isolated case, there’s always a chance that the wine is on its way down. I’ll open another bottle within the next couple of months before I cast my verdict.
  • Pebben commented:

    8/23/14, 4:39 AM - Thanks for commenting. The wine was decanted for approx. two hours (which is just about the same as the three previous bottles), and drunk over the next three. I really see no reason why this wine shouldn't keep for many more years (which also is supported by your experience of the wine improoving after opening), so I think this was just one of those (fortunately few) bottles that are not exactly flawed, but still not quite right.

1 - 9 of 9
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close