LetItRide

Member #615,098 signed up 11/8/2018 and last accessed 4/27/2024

This Member Is a Fan(6)

1 to 3 of 6

  1. Juliansi

    Juliansi

    828 Tasting Notes

  2. Putnam Weekley

    Putnam Weekley

    1,144 Tasting Notes

  3. S-F

    S-F

    226 Tasting Notes

More

Fans(4)

1 to 3 of 4

  1. Juliansi

    Juliansi

    828 Tasting Notes

  2. Sagan99

    Sagan99

    365 Tasting Notes

  3. Clark W Griswold

    Clark W Griswold

    1,080 Tasting Notes

More

Friends(11)

1 to 3 of 11

  1. Juliansi

    Juliansi

    828 Tasting Notes

  2. Motz

    Motz

    13,080 Tasting Notes

  3. Sagan99

    Sagan99

    365 Tasting Notes

More friends

Member since November 2018

Locale: Olympia, Washington, USA
Favorite region: or regions : Piemonte / Oregon / Horse Heaven Hills / Hunter Valley
Dream wine: ~~~1971 Giacomo Conterno Barolo Monfortino Riserva Speciale~~~
He got this right:
“Wine is one of the most civilized things in the world and one of the most natural things of the world that has been brought to the greatest perfection, and it offers a greater range for enjoyment and appreciation than, possibly, any other purely sensory thing.”
… Ernest Hemingway, circa 1932

My lifelong infatuation with wine began in student days in 1970 when I (just shy of the legal drinking age) was indulged by the benevolent proprietors of a sweet little Fairhaven, Washington wine shop, who gave me a wink-n-nod as I nervously placed the fish-net wrapped Riojas on the counter and bathed in their largesse.

This passion was cemented in 1972 when climbing ( ok.. “ hard walking”) to the summit of Mount Kilimanjaro.
I produced a 375 ml. bottle of Hugel Riesling from my backpack to celebrate with my fellow hikers.
It was holding nicely at sunrise in just above freezing temperatures.
Finally figured out that Alsace meant absolutely nothing to my fellow travelers and did the right thing…. dispatching it solo & savoring the view and the brisk quenched thirst all as one.

As for dream wines
I opened that ‘71 Monfortino back in 1987 when it was still so young. If I only knew~
ahh but it still
“blew my nose & then it blew my mind”
even though a crime of infanticide.

My tastes are far flung when it comes to wine.
Nice when a given bottle matches the moment,
Be it humble or profound.

  • 2016 Gulfi Sicilia Nerobufaleffj

    I had not yet read the previous tasting note from FRACTALAGE when we opened this wine today & yes we detected the same exact faint (musty TCA like notes on nose & palate) but it couldn’t be that, as the cork smelled clean and the described offensive odor blew off after a few minutes.
    It’s certainly drinking ok now with a medium plus acidity and diffuse red fruit on the palate along with a pedestrian finish. Makes me think Ian D’Agata’s critical palate must have been on a vacation the day he hung a generous 96+ rating on this wine or perhaps it is a result of bottle variation.
    A final possibility is that the 5 years passage of time since his review has not been kind to this Nero D’Avola.
    I don’t foresee much benefit in holding my remaining few bottles.

    Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment

  • 2018 Hundred Suns Gamay Noir Tualatin Estate

    This is my last remaining bottle from a winery purchase in 2020 . Count me as a big fan.
    The positive development is very impressive.
    Loaded with floral stem inclusion spice, mulberries and kiwi fruit on a racy brisk mid palate carrying through to the seemless finish. I underestimated how great this wine would become and in hindsight wish we still had a few in the cellar.

    Do you find this review helpful? Yes - No / Comment

  • 2018 Carlisle Syrah Sierra Mar Vineyard Santa Lucia Highlands

    This Syrah showed its pinnacle drinking enjoyment on day 2.
    Opens with a nose of deep violet florals and gaminess on day 1. Nice integrated dark fruits,orange rind, tar, trace of menthol, minerality, long finish & medium + acidity.
    It has a nice silky mouthfeel and is just hitting its stride. Glad to have another bottle for a few years down the road.

    1 person found this helpful, do you? Yes - No / Comment

View all 135 Tasting Notes

Message Board Post Public Message

  • LetItRide says:

    12/18/2022 10:06:00 PM - The single blind results in our group of 8 surprised me somewhat factoring the perfect & near perfect ratings of the Paillac first growths and the hype surrounding the ‘82 vintage in Bordeaux. All wines were purchased soon after release by me and cellared identically so provenance and storage & identical decanting do not provide an obvious explanation for why Quilceda Creek ‘83 was the consensus WOTN followed by Ridge Montebello ‘81, Lafitte ‘82 ( in a near tie with the Ridge) and Robert Parker’s 100pt. ‘82 Mouton “Wine of the vintage” dead last. Mercer Ranch ‘85 (old block 1 Champoux vineyard) was oxidized and not served. Your question prompted me to revisit various tasters impression notes and what I noticed is that both the Lafitte and to a greater extent the Mouton were well received initially and faded while both new world wines blossomed over the 4 hours. The Quilceda was blessed with intoxicating florals, cassis and a finish that lasted over a minute. Some of the comments described the Mouton as rather “thin” on the mid palate. I retasted all four wines from the several ounces remaining in the decanters 20 hours later and the rankings held . Alex Golitzen produced a dandy in 1983. These results almost mimic the trends shown in the 2005 San Francisco/ London re-creation of The Judgement of Paris. I mentioned my October blind tasting to the great Somellier Larry Stone a few years ago and he offered one possible explanation: postulating that back circa 1984 wines shipped from Europe sometimes underwent perilous handling on cross Atlantic journeys. On a different subject Motz, I’ve enjoyed reading your savvy contributions to CellarTracker ! Merry Christmas, Mark

  • Motz says:

    12/18/2022 7:45:00 PM - How did the Lafite and Mouton show?

  • LetItRide says:

    6/7/2022 7:34:00 PM - Yes that was a fun blind tasting circa October 2017. Perhaps no cellar overlaps. But we may share a philosophical perspective along the lines of Terry Theise and his “ What Makes A Wine Worth Drinking “ approach to the subject. Salud !

  • Harley1199 says:

    6/7/2022 3:51:00 AM - There are not wines in common but a very nice pic, my friend.

×
×