Important Update From the Founder
Read message >
A Tour of Stellenbosch WIneries
The Estates in Stellenbosch
Tasted December 17, 2015 - December 20, 2015 by cab blends with 471 views
Introduction
The results of our 4 days of meeting winemakers and tasting great wines.
It will take a while for me to get all the wine notes in.
Pictures and details of the trip are noted at www.ballington.us.
Flight 1 (4 notes)
White
2007 Klein Constantia Mme. Marlbrook
80 points
Glass potato - I think this was corked but Anton the guy pouring the wine at the estate didn't seem interested at all to even discuss the wine and what we were tasting.
Very woody herbaceous with green wood throughout.
Very woody herbaceous with green wood throughout.
White - Sweet/Dessert
2011 Klein Constantia Vin de Constance
94 points
includes 2010 juice as well. There was no 2010 release.
Flight 2 (2 notes)
Red
2012 Vilafonté Series M
91 points
Light fruity nose although no fruit on the palate.
Dark red color with a dry start which turns into a dark fruit with dry stone finish.
R425
Dark red color with a dry start which turns into a dark fruit with dry stone finish.
R425
Red
2013 Vilafonté Series C
94 points
Charcoal with a smoke nose. Very dark red almost carmenere like.
Good strong tannins at 7.5/10
R625
Good strong tannins at 7.5/10
R625
Flight 3 (6 notes)
Red
2013 Rust en Vrede Syrah
89 points
Leather and black pepper on the nose.
Tannins at 7/10 with a dry rock finish like the merlot.
Tannins at 7/10 with a dry rock finish like the merlot.
Red
2013 Rust en Vrede Cabernet Sauvignon Estate Vineyards
90 points
A hint of cheese and light chalk on the nose. Classic french dry style. Tannins at 7/10. This needs to warm up and age for a while (as do all of the R&V I believe - they all do better at closer to 10 years)
Red
2012 Rust en Vrede Estate Red Wine Stellenbosch
91 points
There is a lot more going on in this than the single varietals R&Vs. Tannins are strong at 7.5/10. Full bodied in the french style.
Red
2007 Rust en Vrede 1694 Classification
94 points
The nose may have put me off had I not known what it was and thus continued to enjoy it. Dirty toes, dark brown dirt, cheese, mushrooms and asparagus. Powerful tannins 8.5/10
Flight 4 (4 notes)
Red
Red
2013 De Toren Z
93 points
Ruby red with tobacco leather. Strong tannins 8/10.
The slight heat in the finish was concerning and I hope that is not the norm. This was from a small 375ml bottle so variation exists. There was a little wet potato in the nose. I have ignored that for this rating.
I do have a slight preference for this over R&V and Vilafonte M (I think?)
The slight heat in the finish was concerning and I hope that is not the norm. This was from a small 375ml bottle so variation exists. There was a little wet potato in the nose. I have ignored that for this rating.
I do have a slight preference for this over R&V and Vilafonte M (I think?)
Red
2013 De Toren Fusion V
92 points
This was of course very youthful. Very strong tannins 8 to 8.5/10. Full bodied and a light fruity cassis nose (in the french style)
1 person found this helpful
Comment
Red
2013 De Toren Decade
88 points
De Toren's latest addition to the stable. A response to the successful first 10 years of De Toren Z their Merlot based blend.
This is a powerhouse merlot and I would not drink for 10 years. The heat is immense and made the wine undrinkable to start. Only after 3 days of being opened and 10 hours of air, did the heat begin to dissipate. A merlot in the biggest Napa type style for a SA wine.
I find this very difficult to rate (88-93)
This is a powerhouse merlot and I would not drink for 10 years. The heat is immense and made the wine undrinkable to start. Only after 3 days of being opened and 10 hours of air, did the heat begin to dissipate. A merlot in the biggest Napa type style for a SA wine.
I find this very difficult to rate (88-93)
Flight 5 (5 notes)
White
2014 Raats Chenin Blanc Original
92 points
Initial nose seems concentrated and fresh. You expect it to hit with strong acidity. But it does not; it is smooth with a hint of sweetness.
White
2013 Raats Chenin Blanc Old Vine
87 points
Smoother finish than the Original Chenin Blanc but less nose and enticement.
Red
2013 Raats Cabernet Franc
90 points
Lighter chalk than the Red Jasper. Tannins at 7/10. Full bodied but young and needs to lie down.
White
2015 Bruwer Vintners Muscat B de Alexandria
88 points
Powerful fruity nose but very dry on the palate. 12%.
Flight 6 (5 notes)
Rosé
2015 Kanonkop Pinotage Kadette Rosé
87 points
lovely outdoor drinkers - lightly sweet - beautiful picnic wine
Red
2013 Kanonkop Pinotage Kadette
90 points
Nice rounded tannins. A long finish. This is outstanding value for price. R90
Red
2013 Kanonkop Pinotage
96 points
Strong and tannic (9/10) - all new oak - this is big and bold - should last for at least 15 years.
Red
2011 Kanonkop Cabernet Sauvignon
93 points
Red fruit - 50 new oak and 50 2nd fill. Nice strong tannins 7.5/10.
This is bold yet very drinkable. Heavy with a dry finish - It might even be work an extra point or two in the future.
This is bold yet very drinkable. Heavy with a dry finish - It might even be work an extra point or two in the future.
Red
2012 Kanonkop Paul Sauer
91 points
Bright red with light cherry on the nose. Tannins are moderately high at 7.5/10.
The mid palate softens but it ends strong.
This is 24 months in new oak and I thought I would feel the tannins more but they are integrated.
The mid palate softens but it ends strong.
This is 24 months in new oak and I thought I would feel the tannins more but they are integrated.
Flight 8 (8 notes)
White
2015 Tokara Sauvignon Blanc Reserve Collection Elgin
85 points
Guava, green peppers and spring onion. Initial sweetness in the mouth with good acidity.
Red
2012 Tokara Syrah Reserve Collection
87 points
Light nose. Dark fruits then goes dry. Heavy tannins 7.5/10
White - Sweet/Dessert
2013 Tokara Sauvignon Blanc Noble Late Harvest Reserve Collection
89 points
Nice nose with pears and apples. But the body does not continue with any strength. Nice but not Vin de Constance.
Spirits
2008 Tokara 5 year Old Potstill Brandy
Made from chenin blanc. Starts with an initial hint of sweetness.
Red
2011 Tokara Director's Reserve
92 points
Chalky dust and sweet feel on the mouth. The initial attack is sweetish yet dry on the finish. Very young with nice strong tannins 7.5/10.
Red
Flight 9 (8 notes)
White
2010 Hartenberg Riesling Tenacity
91 points
Darker yellow than the standard riesling. There is initial sweetness which gives way to the fresh wine - and the palate and finish is long lasting.
Red
2012 Hartenberg Shiraz The Stork
91 points
Although I understand this won the top Shiraz in France last year, it lost the first place for me to Hartenberg's own Gravel Hill (see separate tasting note).
Fruity nose with tomato and subtle caramel. Far more fruit forward and extracted than the Gravel Hill. The palate is integrated and smooth feel overall on the mouth.
Fruity nose with tomato and subtle caramel. Far more fruit forward and extracted than the Gravel Hill. The palate is integrated and smooth feel overall on the mouth.
Red
2006 Hartenberg Merlot Tenacity
90 points
Chalk and tomato on the nose. THe oak is beautifully integrated 7/10
White
2015 Hartenberg Sauvignon Blanc
85 points
Guava and melon on the nose. Heavy melon on the palate as well.
Red
2008 Hartenberg Shiraz Gravel Hill
94 points
The nose is muted which was the only point holding it back. Strong tannins 8/10 with a very dry finish.
Red
2012 Hartenberg Shiraz
89 points
Dark ruby red.
Definitely young and needs time. 7/10 with tannins hitting the top palate.
Definitely young and needs time. 7/10 with tannins hitting the top palate.
Flight 10 (5 notes)
Red
2012 Muratie Cabernet Sauvignon Martin Melck
93 points
This is a big tannic but not a fruit bomb Napa style cab.
Fruity nose and initial front palate but dry and high tannins (8/10). - and as for the Ansela vd Caab, I am concerned my rating may be high - maybe a point or 2 lower
Fruity nose and initial front palate but dry and high tannins (8/10). - and as for the Ansela vd Caab, I am concerned my rating may be high - maybe a point or 2 lower
Red
2011 Muratie Wine Estate Ansela van de Caab
94 points
The Cab Franc provides a nice backbone in the finish. Tannins are already well integrated and the wine is a dark red. Its initial attack is somewhat smooth and feminine.
Something tells me that I should not keep this beyond 2020? and I am concerned my rating may be high - maybe a point or 2 lower
Something tells me that I should not keep this beyond 2020? and I am concerned my rating may be high - maybe a point or 2 lower
Red
2013 Muratie Wine Estate Pinot Noir George Paul Canitz
83 points
classic pinot nose with strawberry and metallic/vegetal finish
Red
2013 Muratie Wine Estate Merlot Alberta Annemarie
87 points
Earthy but very fruity. In fact too fruity for me today. Strawberries and body with tannins in the finish (6.5/10)
Red
2008 Muratie Wine Estate Shiraz a tribute to ronnie melck family selection
89 points
Hints of raisin on the nose and then in the palate. Not necessarily what I like in a Shiraz.
Flight 11 (5 notes)
Red
2011 Dornier Donatus
90 points
A hint of fruit upfront with very heavy tannins 8/10. Not a stunner for me.
Red
2013 Dornier Tempranillo
87 points
A hint of dark chocolate and strawberry. Dark ruby red with a very dry finish. Tannins 7/10
Red
2013 Dornier Malbec
88 points
Purple with all 3rd oak fills. Clearly young and spicy but a light starts (probably the 3rd fills) with a peppery finish. Good tannins at 7/10.
Red
2012 Dornier Cabernet Sauvignon/Merlot
84 points
Fruity pencil shavings on the nose. A dark but not bright red.
Red