3/17/24, 7:36 PM - How about a substantive comment instead of a vapid declaration?
3/6/24, 9:57 AM - Kind of opposite rhings...
1/29/23, 8:59 PM - Why such a high score, then?
1/14/23, 6:59 PM - Interesting. It is a Michel Rolland consulted wine. Maybe what you are getting is from micro-ox plus time. Others seem to still like it, so your note is a very useful red flag for those whose sensitivities would have them share your experience.
12/20/22, 4:24 PM - What's the flaw?
11/13/22, 10:51 PM - It doesn't make sense to conform to the paradigm of some dinosaur has-been critics of a dying era. Why the hell would you even think to rate a "big" wine you don't like so much over a lighter wine you prefer? Use the scale literally and call it how you see it. Your note explains your rating.
7/19/22, 11:43 PM - When we opened on, it needed a lot of air, bu smoothed out. It's low acid, so won't stand up to some things a tawny Port would. Perhaps a light, creamy dessert.
3/7/22, 2:16 AM - I think they're keeping the brand name, but only making Syrah from the vineyard. Also, there's no reason to assume the intermittent vintages won't be released. We'll see...
1/9/22, 1:47 PM - This is not a Pinot.
11/22/21, 4:28 PM - Funny that PIntag said he usually does assign scores, but wasn't confident or whatever here. Wines change over time in the glass, sometimes dramatically to the good or bad. Some wines you just don't have a grasp on how they'll age. A score without a well-written note is useless. A score can help a note, as a crutch or emphasis. This particular note is well written and describes a sub-par wine I'd have no interest buying. Some negatives, as well as redeeming qualities. Easy to see how that would be difficult to rate. Since some people are much more sensitive to some negative traits than others, this is probably a wine that would generate a large range of scores from people sharing the same bottle.
6/13/21, 2:24 PM - How is that 92 pts?
9/11/20, 1:28 PM - "Corked" is a very specific flaw. You're describing a bottle fermentation. Depending on the microbes at play, they can produce off/funky notes, or just be the regular wine yeast converting a little remaining sugar to ethanol and CO2. If it's just a little spritz, you can recork, shake the bottle, uncork and wait a few minutes for the CO2 to dissipate.
3/22/20, 3:07 PM - It's not a Napa Cab.
3/12/20, 2:49 PM - It says Syrah and old vine Grenache.
7/7/19, 9:49 PM - "Close to TCA" or TCA? I suspect the brett was obscuring the corked character a bit, but that's why you had such a huge contrast with your other bottle.
5/25/19, 9:16 PM - As a tip, there's no way I'd decant a wine like this. Contrast the nose you got to Aagrawal's "highly aromatic". Dry wine from this grape is best made to maximize and maintain its aromatics, then be consumed within the year after release (at most). Aging or decanting will only lose the best part of the wine.
12/5/17, 10:55 PM - Lalande? Did you post this note to the wrong wine?
1/20/16, 8:18 PM - Sounds like the opposite of "classic". Ugh, and please don't say "Cali". Same rule as "Frisco". Hells Angels can say it because no one would dare to try to knock their teeth out for doing so.
11/23/14, 1:41 AM - Sounds like a cork issue.
1/14/14, 3:14 PM - Zach, there's no distinct varietal character to steer one towards an obvious guess. Just dark, dense neutral fruit completely enveloped in stemmy spice.
7/8/13, 3:32 AM - You posted this note for a Cab as a Zin.
7/1/13, 3:37 AM - It's not a Zin, it's a Charbono.
3/24/13, 8:37 PM - Yes, this was Ridge's experiment at adding Merlot to Monte Bello. As with the regular '76 Monte Bello, all previous vintages had been 100% Cabernet Sauvignon.
1/9/13, 7:37 PM - It's 50% Pinot Noir, with the balance equal parts Charbono, Teroldego and Lagrein.
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search