Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(24 comments on 24 notes)

1 - 24 of 24 Sort order
White - Fortified
N.V. Glunz Family Winery and Cellars Mission Angelica Paso Robles
11/13/2023 - yhn wrote:
60 points
Clunky, awkward, imbalanced, harsh extraction. Very dark in character, charmless. Badly amateurish effort. This is way too dark to be just Mission, since that's a thin skinned grape. Mission is also quite tannic, so you want to avoid too much extraction and allow its tawny inclinations when fortified.
  • yhn commented:

    3/17/24, 7:36 PM - How about a substantive comment instead of a vapid declaration?

Red
1982 Diamond Creek Cabernet Sauvignon Volcanic Hill Diamond Mountain
11/21/2014 - fournet wrote:
89 points
very closed and a bit past its prime
  • yhn commented:

    3/6/24, 9:57 AM - Kind of opposite rhings...

Red
1981 Château Pape Clément Pessac-Léognan Red Bordeaux Blend
Don’t waste your time, this wine is long gone.
  • yhn commented:

    1/29/23, 8:59 PM - Why such a high score, then?

Red
2005 Château Clos de Sarpe St. Émilion Grand Cru Red Bordeaux Blend
I’d say this wine is flawed but it is the exact same experience I had with a bottle at a restaurant and it had the same issues. Someone earlier said it came across as a “dirty old wine” which I agree with. There are oxidative features that are hard to get past. RP points pointed this out and said it might haunt owners at a future date and gave it 95? With the dread ? LPB and JD gave it very high scores. Wonder if there are different bottles out there. Love right bank wines. Not this one. The 2000 was quite nice. Not sure what happened with some of these bottles.
  • yhn commented:

    1/14/23, 6:59 PM - Interesting. It is a Michel Rolland consulted wine. Maybe what you are getting is from micro-ox plus time. Others seem to still like it, so your note is a very useful red flag for those whose sensitivities would have them share your experience.

Red
2003 Château Sociando-Mallet Haut-Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend
11/26/2022 - thalver wrote:
flawed
CORKED! Little is more frustrating than coddling a bottle for 16 years only to find it tainted. What other items do we put up with such frequent failure with absolutely no ramifications for the maker of the product?
  • yhn commented:

    12/20/22, 4:24 PM - What's the flaw?

Red
2020 Louis Claude Desvignes Morgon Javernières Gamay
9/23/2022 - jocelyng wrote:
I won’t rate it. It is a very good Morgon. Strawberry pie, with baking spices and pepper. A lot of sour red fruits on the finish. The « problem » is that it is quite powerful. I prefer these kinds of wine lighter in general. So it is probably a 90+wine but I prefer a lighter style Cru of beaujolais to enjoy with a simple sandwich. If that makes any sense.
  • yhn commented:

    11/13/22, 10:51 PM - It doesn't make sense to conform to the paradigm of some dinosaur has-been critics of a dying era. Why the hell would you even think to rate a "big" wine you don't like so much over a lighter wine you prefer? Use the scale literally and call it how you see it. Your note explains your rating.

Red - Fortified
N.V. Miraflores Angelica El Dorado Mission, Listán Prieto
1/5/2022 - wetlandwino wrote:
87 points
This is an interesting desert wine, but not to my tasting. It is very botanical on the nose and palate, reminding me of root beer-flavored cough medicine when I was a kit. I tried pairing it with blue cheese (Gorgonzola), but it didn't help. I am still trying to find some food item that pairs well with it. Any ideas?
  • yhn commented:

    7/19/22, 11:43 PM - When we opened on, it needed a lot of air, bu smoothed out. It's low acid, so won't stand up to some things a tawny Port would. Perhaps a light, creamy dessert.

Red
2019 Halcon Vineyards Syrah Alturas Yorkville Highlands
95% Syrah with 5% Viognier. 50% whole cluster and just neutral wood. Love this stuff. Dried purple flowers/potpourri and ground black pepper aromatics, even a little bacon fat too. With no aeration this drinks super. Some plushness that is framed by blackberry, cherry and a bunch of tar, creosote and garrigue. Finishes with black licorice and a moderate kick of acidity. In contrast to the 2018, I suspect the 2019 will be attractive to a bigger audience. I like both vintages but the striking aromatics of the 2018 still haunt me. I wish Jackie and Paul Gordon the best, as they sold the vineyard and are going back to the UK. You guys made some of the best syrah in California and it will always hold a special place in the palates of many of the wine dorks, including me.
  • yhn commented:

    3/7/22, 2:16 AM - I think they're keeping the brand name, but only making Syrah from the vineyard. Also, there's no reason to assume the intermittent vintages won't be released. We'll see...

Red
2019 Tenuta Tascante Etna Ghiaia Nera Etna DOC Nerello Mascalese
This Pinot has complexity and high tannins. Wasn't my fave to drink by itself. It was more enjoyable and paired well with spicy Indian food. The tannins were negated by the Indian spice.
  • yhn commented:

    1/9/22, 1:47 PM - This is not a Pinot.

Red
2003 Midsummer Cellars Cabernet Sauvignon Mann Vineyard Napa Valley
10/30/2021 - PIntag wrote:
13.5% abv. Recent auction purchase.
Interesting Napa Cab. There's a little bit of a roasted note that points to the hot vintage, but it's not too bad. Seems kind of tight and wound up still, even on the second evening (stoppered overnight). Acid was pretty high and stuck out a bit. Not the most attractive flavor profile but an interesting drink for the $22 I paid for it.
  • yhn commented:

    11/22/21, 4:28 PM - Funny that PIntag said he usually does assign scores, but wasn't confident or whatever here. Wines change over time in the glass, sometimes dramatically to the good or bad. Some wines you just don't have a grasp on how they'll age. A score without a well-written note is useless. A score can help a note, as a crutch or emphasis. This particular note is well written and describes a sub-par wine I'd have no interest buying. Some negatives, as well as redeeming qualities. Easy to see how that would be difficult to rate. Since some people are much more sensitive to some negative traits than others, this is probably a wine that would generate a large range of scores from people sharing the same bottle.

White
1996 Joseph Drouhin Rully Blanc Chardonnay
3/1/2007 - Yagil wrote:
82 points
undrinkable; yellow; bad smell
  • yhn commented:

    6/13/21, 2:24 PM - How is that 92 pts?

Red
2017 Analemma Wines Mencía Mosier Hills Estate Columbia Gorge
11/24/2019 - jaredoco wrote:
flawed
Bought at winery and travelled back to NY with us (via united airlines luggage). We intended to hold this for a while but the cork was leaking real bad. So we opened it, nervous it might be undrinkable. Turns out to be pretty tasty. The cork issue might’ve caused it to mature faster or something because it’s really savory & meaty but it’s still fruity too. There is the tiniest bit of that fizz on your tongue that you’d expect from a zero sulfur wine, so I guess it is kind of corked. Maybe we’ve been drinking too much natty wine lately but this was tasted like it was mostly fine. I want to find more bottles of it in NY cuz it’s an interesting wine, but nervous if this bottle was messed up by travel (none of the others we flew with were) or if this could be a trend with their wines.
  • yhn commented:

    9/11/20, 1:28 PM - "Corked" is a very specific flaw. You're describing a bottle fermentation. Depending on the microbes at play, they can produce off/funky notes, or just be the regular wine yeast converting a little remaining sugar to ethanol and CO2. If it's just a little spritz, you can recork, shake the bottle, uncork and wait a few minutes for the CO2 to dissipate.

Red
1990 Mount Eden Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Old Vine Reserve Santa Cruz Mountains
1/25/2019 - KCC320 wrote:
93 points
Nose :mint, green pepper , ceder, tobacco
palate: nice acidity , a bit ripe on attack, tobacco, mint, smooth tannin, very matured !
Showing well how well of an aged Napa cab can be ! Only the bits of sweetness made it different from Bdx, but already a classic cab!
  • yhn commented:

    3/22/20, 3:07 PM - It's not a Napa Cab.

Red
2016 Domaine Lafage Côtes du Roussillon Bastide Miraflors Syrah Blend, Syrah
3/5/2020 - Z1nnfull Likes this wine:
87 points
Very good Tuesday night wine, but not life changing. Basic French Rhone blend (it says Syrah and old-vine Grenache)more approachable, very tame/lighter, but with some surprisingly good fruit complexity for the price. Highly recommend for the price point, not a stellar performer but at this price point you will have visions of being served this at a sidewalk cafe in France and just go...yessss. Every house wine should be this good.
  • yhn commented:

    3/12/20, 2:49 PM - It says Syrah and old vine Grenache.

Red
1983 Château Gruaud Larose St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend
6/24/2019 - acyso wrote:
88 points
Champagne, Riesling, and Bordeaux with Skippy (Chicago, IL): I didn't like this bottle anywhere as much as the bottle I had last year. The nose showed too much of the Cordier funk (which is far too close to TCA for my comfort), and the palate had a fairly dirty character as well. Lean and structured and a little meagre in the fruit department. I can understand the allure, but I'm impervious to this (lack of) charm.
  • yhn commented:

    7/7/19, 9:49 PM - "Close to TCA" or TCA? I suspect the brett was obscuring the corked character a bit, but that's why you had such a huge contrast with your other bottle.

Red
2017 Sandlands Mission Amador County
4/15/2019 - VeniceCalif wrote:
88 points
Guess what: There are varying styles of Mission wines in CA. This one is from the lighter end of the spectrum. Decanted 1 hr. ahead. Very pale ruby with an orange edge, halfway between a Pinot Noir and a rosé. Nice but shy nose of cherry, white pepper, peach. Pleasant on the palate, with earthy and orange peel flavors leading. Quite light-bodied as befits the color, with easy acid balance. Finishes with light grip and low tannins. Only 2 barrels made.
  • yhn commented:

    5/25/19, 9:16 PM - As a tip, there's no way I'd decant a wine like this. Contrast the nose you got to Aagrawal's "highly aromatic". Dry wine from this grape is best made to maximize and maintain its aromatics, then be consumed within the year after release (at most). Aging or decanting will only lose the best part of the wine.

Red
1975 Château Pichon-Longueville Baron Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
9/29/2015 - tooch wrote:
92 points
Senndoff (Adrian's Apartment - Chicago, IL): Really liked the nose of this after it got some air. Had that classic, Lalande floral note along with some nice graphite and dark fruit tones. Smelled VERY Pauillac. Palate was edgy and firm. It was kinda a tough nut to crack, but I think that's somewhat typical for the vintage. While it won't have the fleshy character that some of the more generous vintages may have, this seemed to fit into the 1978, 1983, 2004 mold of stern, dark, unforgiving wines. May not work for some, but this was right in my wheelhouse for BDX.
  • yhn commented:

    12/5/17, 10:55 PM - Lalande? Did you post this note to the wrong wine?

Red
2010 Big Basin Vineyards Pinot Noir Coastview Vineyard Monterey County
5/10/2015 - jnewman77 wrote:
Classic cali style pinot with rich, ripe fruit, baking spices, and cola scents. The palate is forward and big, but reasonably balanced and overall pretty good. If ripe California pinot is your style this will be very enjoyable.
  • yhn commented:

    1/20/16, 8:18 PM - Sounds like the opposite of "classic". Ugh, and please don't say "Cali". Same rule as "Frisco". Hells Angels can say it because no one would dare to try to knock their teeth out for doing so.

Red
2003 Big Basin Vineyards Syrah Rattlesnake Rock Santa Cruz Mountains
2/15/2013 - sbtoby wrote:
84 points
Still drinkable, but well past it's prime. Very musty and slightly mildewish. Seems like this was at one time a good wine.
  • yhn commented:

    11/23/14, 1:41 AM - Sounds like a cork issue.

Red
2011 Arnot-Roberts Pinot Noir Peter Martin Ray Vineyard Santa Cruz Mountains
1/13/2014 - yhn wrote:
No formal notes, but here's my impression: Well made, intense dark fruit, pretty extreme in whole cluster character and very complex. Very compelling and has the stuff to age. Initially tasted blind, at a winery, with Pinot Noir producers. No one thought this was a Pinot. Also, at this point, this wine shows zero vineyard character from what is a unique, and one of my favorite, Pinot Noir vineyards in California. Maybe, hopefully, time will change that. Duane Cronin, Frank Ashton and Ian Brand manged to make compelling PMR PNs. I would think the A-R guys, with their resources, would improve on that. Not sure they did, not sure how they could by using 100% whole cluster.
  • yhn commented:

    1/14/14, 3:14 PM - Zach, there's no distinct varietal character to steer one towards an obvious guess. Just dark, dense neutral fruit completely enveloped in stemmy spice.

Red
1994 Ridge Zinfandel Jimsomare Santa Cruz Mountains
5/21/2008 - locovino wrote:
90 points
Stored in my cool temperature controlled cellar since release. Dark ruby color. Classic SC mountains Cabernet Sauvignon nose of pungent cassis, green olives and minerals. Well balanced in the mouth with some tannin and good acidity. Still moderately youthful with at least five more years of enjoyment ahead. Very nice Jimsomare.
  • yhn commented:

    7/8/13, 3:32 AM - You posted this note for a Cab as a Zin.

Red
2003 Schrader Cellars Charbono Vieux-Os Old Vine Tofanelli Vineyard Napa Valley
11/9/2010 - Ekoostik wrote:
84 points
Probably was better 2 years ago as this seems to have lost its zip. Its not done by any means but I think I just like my Zin younger. A bit of raison and prune on the nosedecent cherry mid palate followed with some tartness and tannin on the finish. Fine for the $10 I paid but not worth anywhere near full tariff any longer.
  • yhn commented:

    7/1/13, 3:37 AM - It's not a Zin, it's a Charbono.

Red
1976 Ridge Cabernet-Merlot Monte Bello Santa Cruz Mountains Red Bordeaux Blend
12/29/2006 - psmith wrote:
Impromptu drinking (Columbus, OH): Labeled as "Ridge California Cabernet/Merlot Monte Bello" with a 85/15% Cab/Merlot blend with only 11 barrel total production. Seems like it may be an experimental wine. Color-wise showing very few signs of bricking or age. Classic, merlot influenced wine showing plum, menthol, and mushroom notes along with a distinct green streak. Grainy, tannic palate. Would never guess this is 30 years old, but hard to believe the fruit will last as long as the tannins. Enjoyable, and impressively robust, but not special.
  • yhn commented:

    3/24/13, 8:37 PM - Yes, this was Ridge's experiment at adding Merlot to Monte Bello. As with the regular '76 Monte Bello, all previous vintages had been 100% Cabernet Sauvignon.

Red
2011 Harrington Wine Grape Pile-up California Red Blend
11/18/2012 - Scharin wrote:
89 points
I think (if i recall correctly) this is a blend of Charbonno, Teraldego, Pinot Noir, and Tannat. Odd blend, but it really works. Nice nose with blackberries and dust. There's plenty of dark fruit, with some chalky earth, minerality, and light herbs. Moderate acidity with light tannins and just a bit of alcohol heat. This bottle was better on the second day, so clearly we didn't let it open enough.
  • yhn commented:

    1/9/13, 7:37 PM - It's 50% Pinot Noir, with the balance equal parts Charbono, Teroldego and Lagrein.

1 - 24 of 24
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close