Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(32 comments on 29 notes)

1 - 29 of 29 Sort order
White
2014 Domaine des Comtes Lafon Meursault 1er Cru Les Genevrières Chardonnay
12/20/2020 - Tim2 wrote:
94 points
to be drunk at Xmas eve dinner 2020
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    12/22/20, 5:40 AM - Why the score if it's not been drunk?

Red
2019 Château du Domaine de L'Eglise Pomerol Red Bordeaux Blend
6/8/2020 - Jeff Leve wrote:
97 points
The color is so dark it tells you that you're not in Kansas anymore. Flowers, licorice, truffle, spice, wet earth, smoke and plum liqueur aromatics get noticed easily. In the mouth, this rockstar wine coats your palate with fruit that does not quit. Opulence bordering on decadence in texture, the fruit feels like polished velvet. Rich and nuanced, concentrated and fresh, the fruit, earth and bitter chocolate endnote sticks with you for over 50 seconds. Produced from a blend of 97% Merlot and 3%, this is so good, I want some for my cellar. This is the finest wine ever produced here in the history of the estate and should age effortlessly for 3 decades. 96-98 Pts
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    6/22/20, 9:46 AM - Just checking this note is against the right wine....?

Red
2016 Château Pontet-Canet Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
5/21/2020 - AaronMaxwell Likes this wine:
95 points
Delicious.

On open, it was all packed really closely together, but I could already tell there was a lot going on.

After an hour in a decanter, it's expanded to fill my palate. Medium tannins, medium body (for me. others say it is fuller)...dark fruit flavors, not overly oaked.

Note to self: don't open the remaining bottles for another 2-4 years!
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    5/22/20, 2:08 AM - I think you’re missing zeroes from those last two numbers!

  • Rob-Rah commented:

    5/22/20, 5:29 AM - Yeah I assumed that.... but genuine word of caution: the wine is highly likely to get worse and worse to drink over the next few years, hitting a peak of rubbishness around age 8-12, which is right when you are suggesting drinking it. These Bordeaux tend to need drinking either young for the quality fruit and structure, or else matured properly. In-the-middle is almost never a good plan.

  • Rob-Rah commented:

    5/22/20, 12:21 PM - Somewhere in its 20s is not at all "old" for a good Bordeaux vintage. 50s is getting a bit grey for many though: though of course plenty will be lovely then. Don't expect any loss of vibrancy or really loss of much fruit for a good Bordeaux in it's 20s: only an increase in overall deliciousness and a degree of flavour breadth that is absent from the younger wine. For example, top bottles from 1990 - for me - are at their chocolately- stewed-plums peak now. None of the top wines taste "old" in any sense whatsoever: they are vivid. Beyond 1990, it's only 4 years ago I had my last Latour '75: no sign of "age" but plenty of "maturity" - if the distinction makes sense. I finished up some other 1980s bottles around 5-10 years ago, and for me that was their peak. 1982s and things like Margaux and Palmer 1983 will run and run: I've had only a few examples at ages around 30-40 showing no signs of being tired or lacking fruit. I think maybe there could be a popular misconception about what aged Bordeaux is like. Something to do with fusty gentlemens' clubs, tobacco, armchairs and fires and musty, fusty characteristics. None of it. :P

Red
2011 Rudolf Fürst Schlossberg Spätburgunder Franken
2/29/2020 - Rob-Rah Likes this wine:
94 points
I found this delicious! A pale-ish brownish-red. Lovely fruit scents and violets. Silky, luxurious palate. Sweetish. Really quite beautiful fruit. Restrained and classy, and just beautiful. Caressing finish. Right up my alley.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    3/14/20, 3:01 PM - I'm not sure with this vineyard. The fruit is so good, and it's drinking so well at the moment I'm not sure what is to be gained from age. Some of the other Furst 2011s indeed need a while more though. For me anyway.....

Red
2018 Boekenhoutskloof The Chocolate Block Swartland Red Blend
11/18/2019 - Rob-Rah Does not like this wine:
78 points
Opaque, black-purple with a reddish-magenta rim. Tight tarry fruit. Bit of floral aspect. Palate hard, tannic, dry. Hot alcohol. No sweet fruit at the moment. Tarry fruit but veering toward red rather than black perhaps. Certainly nothing like the moniker suggests about chocolate. I'll follow over the evening. On initial pour this is not very friendly at all.

A few hours later: nah, this is a tough, charmless, oaky, tarry wine. Big scale but just so unfriendly. Hard to drink and harder to enjoy really. I wouldn't buy this in the hope it transforms after a few years in bottle.

1/3 bottle tried after being corked and kept 24 hours...... still pretty nasty stuff. So bitter and aggressive. Downgraded score.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    1/29/20, 11:36 AM - Oh that's a very kind comment! On this wine, I think there are infinitely better south African Syrahs to be had.

Red
2015 Grgić Vina Plavac Mali Pelješac
12/28/2019 - elevwine Likes this wine:
89 points
According to label this is Bosnian wine, not Croatian. Very drinkable, bright and acidic with an old world style. Paid about half of community valuation and that would be all I would pay for another bottle.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    12/29/19, 10:54 AM - Any chance of a pic of the front and back labels? The standard wine is definitely Croatian, not Bosnian, so I am curious what the label said.

White
2011 A.J. Adam Hofberg Riesling Kabinett Mosel Saar Ruwer
This bottle was in rough shape but the wine made it through very well. Considerably rich in body and flavor for an eight year kabinett. Let it sit open for a while and the acidity will freshen things up. Will age for longer if you want more petrol and condensed flavors, especially if your bottle is in good shape.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    10/31/19, 9:56 AM - 50 points??

Red
2015 Château Pichon-Longueville Baron Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
10/26/2019 - 83Vintage Does not like this wine:
91 points
The ripe weight shows itself too much, with a flat round texture, lacking in focus and form. There is no secondary components, depth, or vibrancy that I’m looking for. Not my style
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    10/27/19, 5:13 AM - Far, far too young! Leave until the later 2020s, and ought to last until the 2050s with ease.

Red
2009 Château Pontet-Canet Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
10/25/2019 - Slaz wrote:
92 points
My first bottle from this vintage. Studied it over 4+ hours of decanting. Overall, fairly unimpressive relative to the price tag of $250. Upon opening, it tasted monolithic and ungiving, as I expected. With air, it improved but not to a point where my tastebuds found this memorable. Plenty of graphite and raw wood, with fairly generous but still moderate acidity. I kept looking for tertiary notes but never found them. The nose was similarly restrained (e.g., I've had much more floral explosion from some of the better Brunellos from 2010, as a reference point). I'll give the rest of my bottles 5+ more years.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    10/26/19, 1:41 AM - If you want tertiary leave until some time c.2030!

Red
2016 Château Pavie Macquin St. Émilion Grand Cru Red Bordeaux Blend
10/15/2019 - csimm wrote:
95 points
This took about 2-3 hours of decanted air to fully open up. Wild blackberry, red and black cherry, red and purple plum skin limestone, muddled strawberry seed, and violets. A near-perfect combination of speed and concentration. Medium-to-full bodied, with a finish that displays notable verve, tension, and back end flavor expansion.

Best to hold for another 3-5 years, but not a sin to open now with a few hours of a decant. Ideally wait until 2023+. 95+ points.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    10/16/19, 12:54 AM - What is a muddled strawberry seed?

Red
2004 Château Simone Palette Red Rhone Blend
5/4/2019 - baxter67 Likes this wine:
89 points
Interesting. I bought this wine at the Chateau, drank three soon after, then put the remaining three in the cellar and forgot about them. A pleasant surprise. Still sound, quite light with good fruit, still redolent of Provence with the Grenache, Mourvedre and other grapes very much in evidence. Reading the other reviews, it seems to have a second wind? ***
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    8/14/19, 9:43 AM - Yes, Ch Simone red is lovely close to the vintage, and shuts down usually quite hard around age 2-3 to somewhere 8-10, and then opens up again beautifully.

    (The whites can also close down like this; the roses I prefer young to aged).

Red
2010 Teliani Valley Kindzmarauli Saperavi
1/16/2013 - Rob-Rah wrote:
Dark. Deep, fruity. Strawberry and roses. Iodine, a little tar. Palate powerful and rather tannic. Covered up by a little residual sweetness. But this is off-dry rather than really semi-sweet. A bit one-dimensional. This appears to be in need of bottle age. Well balanced. I have 12 of these so will save rating until I understand it a bit better. My impression is good though.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    8/10/19, 7:15 AM - They all got consumed within a year or two of that note! They were drinkably pleasant and too great a risk to hog the cellar with long-term in the end.

Red
2015 Montes Purple Angel Colchagua Valley Carménère
1/10/2019 - Rob-Rah Likes this wine:
95 points
A massive, bruising and brooding wine. Already quite some sediment staining the inside to the bottle. Amazing depth both of colour and taste. Superb cassis and dark plum fruit quality with depth and just the right balance of plush sweet fruit and tannins and acid. Long, frankly delicious blueberry-fading-to-chocolate finish. Really very good indeed, and a wonder this isn't far more expensive. But also rather young right now and those tannins need to soften - give a LONG decant, or wait 5-10 years. 95+
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    5/31/19, 11:43 AM - I just bought another 12. The stuff is amazing, and vintages are going up in price since 2015.

Red
2016 L'Aventure Estate Cuvée Paso Robles Willow Creek District Red Blend
5/10/2019 - Justinito wrote:
Stupid Steph
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    5/11/19, 2:01 AM - Anything more enlightening?

Red
2015 Jean Stodden Herrenberg Spätburgunder Großes Gewächs Ahr
5/4/2018 - Benjamin on Wine wrote:
90 points
Spatburgunder at its best and very typical Concentrated red fruit aromas, as well as smoke, cedar wood and overall quite strong in aroma. Very nicely balanced on the palate, with a medium body, medium + tannins and high acidity. That balance makes it so delightful, Ahr this is great!
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    7/25/18, 2:50 AM - A very low score (84) compared to your tasting note!?

Red
2013 Podere Poggio Scalette Il Carbonaione Alta Valle della Greve IGT Sangiovese
6/28/2018 - Rob-Rah Likes this wine:
92 points
Very, very good. Though I have a nasty feeling that I am missing out on something in 15 years by drinking these now.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    6/29/18, 6:08 AM - No, I think this has the stuffing to go. Chianti classico, Brunello and other well-made structured Sangiovese like this are usually super with plenty of age.

Red
2015 Pensées de Lafleur Pomerol Red Bordeaux Blend
5/21/2018 - Jeff Leve wrote:
92 points
Mint with a handful of earth is the first thing you notice. From there the cherry and plum notes pop up. Medium bodied, silky, polished, soft and sweet, the wine offers cherry pipe tobacco, plums and earthy notes, The soft tannins and layers of fruits keep on going on the palate. The wine was produced from a blend of 54% Merlot and 36% Cabernet Franc.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    5/25/18, 1:05 AM - I think a typo in the score there :)

Red
1998 Château Léoville Barton St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend
4/3/2018 - mmh wrote:
Eight years after buying this bottle i finally popped the cork with high expectations....which were not quite met. Decanted for 2 hours. Fairly complex on the nose, worked very well with food but on its own it was slightly astringent and boring. I am not sure if it was past its peak (doubtful), too young or just a slightly off bottle.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    4/4/18, 5:33 AM - My suspicion is just “boring” too

Red
2015 Château Larcis Ducasse St. Émilion Grand Cru Red Bordeaux Blend
1/22/2018 - Eric Guido wrote:
89 points
The Larcis Ducasse was intense on the nose with spiced raspberry and sweet herbs. On the palate, I found silky, broad textures with glossy red berry fruit, yet it lacked in the mid-palate, as I craved acidity and grip. The finish was medium in length with lingering spice.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    1/26/18, 10:20 AM - Is your score correct (98) on this one?

Red
2015 Maison Leroy Bourgogne Pinot Noir
8/18/2017 - evanqian wrote:
87 points
closed nose, powdery tannins, some leafy and earthy notes, dry finish. not open at all. this bottle seems weird.

Ap 5/5, Ar 11/15, Palate 16/20, Overall 3+3/10
Total 87/100
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    8/18/17, 7:10 AM - Too young. It is barely out of cask.

Red
2010 Château de Beaucastel Côtes du Rhône Coudoulet de Beaucastel Red Rhone Blend
5/14/2017 - zut alors! Likes this wine:
94 points
Completel agree with TREPAK (1/29/17): perfect resolution. balanced, slightly acidic (just enough to cut through the fat of a steak). Better than most entry-level Chat du Papes. Burnt toast notes and Black berry so dark and flavorful, practically seemed syrup-y. Quoi se veut "Coudoulet" en fancais? Une traduction, s'il vous-plaît!
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    5/16/17, 12:41 PM - Coudoulet is not French, but is Provençal for "pebble" (like the ones all over CdP).

Red
2003 Henry's Drive Shiraz Reserve Padthaway
11/11/2016 - Tgarthe Does not like this wine:
85 points
Upon opening I got plenty of hay and leather on the nose before it turned quite pugnant.

It improved after an hour or so, although prune was evident throughout.

Was ok on the palate, didn't feel like it had much body, although the long finish was there.

Think it had just fallen apart a little too much. Purchased from graysonline, so unsure of cellaring conditions.

Will try again soon.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    11/11/16, 4:54 AM - Most definitely flawed

  • Rob-Rah commented:

    11/12/16, 11:29 AM - I may have had more bottles of this wine than any other (!). The wine may sometimes seem awkward, out of balance, but it should never come across as lacking body. Sometimes I guess it might appear shrill or overly volatile. It's a huge beast of a wine, all sweet fruit and aromatics, and masses of alcohol - for better or worse.

    By the way.... I don't find this needing air now - pop open and pour.

Red
2007 Zlatan Otok Zlatan Plavac Grand Cru Sveta Nedjelja Hvar Plavac Mali
12/21/2010 - Rob-Rah wrote:
94 points
Bouquet of this one different from previous vintages I have tried. Less of the baked fig. More freshness, and an unexpected precision of cassis (almost cabernet-esque!). Palate elegant and rounded. Again, less of the heady mix of wet hay, baked figs and raisins and port flavour. There seems to be less residual sugar than previous vintages as well as carrying its alcohol level more deftly and lightly. More freshness of blackcurrant. Superb structure.

Lovely, and remarkable for Plavac mali. But I hope this marks a vintage variation (2007 was the most recent very good vintage in the region since 2002 amd 2003), and not a change towards a more "international" style. I like all that caramel-fig-and-eucalyptus stuff that is typical for coastal Plavac mali...!
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    2/22/15, 2:57 AM - I don't yet know the 2009 personally - though the vintage conditions were good. The wine is normally made to be able to be drunk on release if you want to though: the fruit quality is very high and is fantastic in youth. I like them at 7-10 years best, but they will keep longer. Open it if you like - you ought not to be disappointed.

Red
2005 La Rioja Alta Rioja Viña Arana Reserva Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
1/23/2015 - NineteenEightyTwo wrote:
87 points
Medium-light rosewood color. This has an airy, bright nose of red fruit. The palate is similarly light-bodied; smooth, with very faint flavors of cranberries. Overall this is very clean, showing minimal oak. There's a little bit of tannin left, but this wine has basically reached maturity. Several hours of aeration did not cause the nose or palate to expand at all. An understated effort that pairs easily with food, this is neither dramatically overpriced nor a screaming value at $25/bottle.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    1/24/15, 11:21 AM - I suspect a badly-stored bottle.... the ones I have had have been youthful, full of fruit and gloss

Red
2001 La Rioja Alta Rioja Viña Ardanza Reserva Especial Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
3/23/2014 - Crispin Likes this wine:
91 points
Excellent. Brick red. Took an hour to open up, still plenty of tannin but once open it was fruity with vanilla and cedar. Going to leave remaining bottles for a few years.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    3/23/14, 10:06 AM - Harley... that comment seems to refer to my own latest review of this wine today. If you look at my range of comments on this same wine, you will see that I am indeed describing bottle variation, and tracking each bottle quite open-mindedly, and have posted quite a few notes about this wine and its different qualities in each bottle. Judging from my own experience of the half case I have had so far, and that of other reviewers here, there is a significant issue with bottle variation for this wine in this vintage.

White - Sweet/Dessert
1993 Kiona Chenin Blanc Ice Wine Red Mountain
1/26/2014 - Deven Blackburn Likes this wine:
95 points
Heaven on the nose. Peachy, white flower aromas - I could sniff this all night without getting bored. Surprisingly fresh fruit on the palate for 10+ year old ice wine. Pleasant surprise!!
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    1/27/14, 11:53 AM - 20+ year!

White
2010 A.J. Adam Hofberg Riesling Kabinett Mosel Saar Ruwer
6/24/2013 - Orlandus wrote:
flawed
Rich Riesling character with some complexity. However, its natural sweetness was overwhelmed by a strong sour fruit taste evident on opening and which did not improve after two days in the fridge. Judging from other comments, this is just a bad bottle, although it had been well stored since purchase and did not show any oxidation. I have drunk hundreds of Mosels over the years, so it's not that I don't know what to expect. Approach with caution.
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    6/26/13, 2:43 AM - I've had several bottles of AJ Adam Kab and Spat from 2009, 2010 and 2011, and never had a problem with any of them. You must have been very unlucky as at the moment there's no reason to worry about the quality of the bottling in general.

Red - Fortified
1994 Tesco Finest Porto Vintage Port Blend
1/10/2013 - mattmoy_2000 wrote:
A nice port, opening up to honeyish flavours after a (long) while decanted (a couple of weeks). Still fruity and young, but with an ever so slight colour change towards the orange/brown.
No detailed notes, but an enjoyable glass.
Was opened for a birthday party meal on 08/12/12 but not really touched. Drank slowly over the next few weeks, watching the flavour evolve. Re-bottled half-bottle of decanted stuff in a smaller bottle to travel home for xmas with.
Cork showed no signs of staining, and was simply branded "Vintage Port 1994", suggesting a re-corking to hide the Quarles-Harris origin of the wine. (Label simply said "Symingtons"
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    1/10/13, 10:00 AM - I'm not sure that the 1994 Symingtons from Tesco is still technically "Quarles Harris".... I created this CT entry as at the time I purchased that was what I was told. Though my initial purchase was almost 10 years ago if my memory serves me. Tesco will probably have a range of option from Porto when it comes to filling their bottles.

    There's a little discussion about this here:
    - http://www.theportforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=4581&start=28
    - http://www.theportforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=1136
    - http://www.theportforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=13601

Red
2009 Zlatan Otok Crljenak Kaštelanski Vinogorje Makarska Split-Omiš-Makarska
9/21/2012 - mstrigel wrote:
a slight taste if plum, much less intense as classic zinfandel (crljenak supposingly the grandfather if zinfandel)
  • Rob-Rah commented:

    10/16/12, 1:16 PM - Crljenak Kaštelanski IS Zinfandel. Not the grandfather of it.

1 - 29 of 29
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close