12/22/20, 5:40 AM - Why the score if it's not been drunk?
6/22/20, 9:46 AM - Just checking this note is against the right wine....?
5/22/20, 2:08 AM - I think you’re missing zeroes from those last two numbers!
5/22/20, 5:29 AM - Yeah I assumed that.... but genuine word of caution: the wine is highly likely to get worse and worse to drink over the next few years, hitting a peak of rubbishness around age 8-12, which is right when you are suggesting drinking it. These Bordeaux tend to need drinking either young for the quality fruit and structure, or else matured properly. In-the-middle is almost never a good plan.
5/22/20, 12:21 PM - Somewhere in its 20s is not at all "old" for a good Bordeaux vintage. 50s is getting a bit grey for many though: though of course plenty will be lovely then. Don't expect any loss of vibrancy or really loss of much fruit for a good Bordeaux in it's 20s: only an increase in overall deliciousness and a degree of flavour breadth that is absent from the younger wine. For example, top bottles from 1990 - for me - are at their chocolately- stewed-plums peak now. None of the top wines taste "old" in any sense whatsoever: they are vivid. Beyond 1990, it's only 4 years ago I had my last Latour '75: no sign of "age" but plenty of "maturity" - if the distinction makes sense. I finished up some other 1980s bottles around 5-10 years ago, and for me that was their peak. 1982s and things like Margaux and Palmer 1983 will run and run: I've had only a few examples at ages around 30-40 showing no signs of being tired or lacking fruit. I think maybe there could be a popular misconception about what aged Bordeaux is like. Something to do with fusty gentlemens' clubs, tobacco, armchairs and fires and musty, fusty characteristics. None of it. :P
3/14/20, 3:01 PM - I'm not sure with this vineyard. The fruit is so good, and it's drinking so well at the moment I'm not sure what is to be gained from age. Some of the other Furst 2011s indeed need a while more though. For me anyway.....
1/29/20, 11:36 AM - Oh that's a very kind comment! On this wine, I think there are infinitely better south African Syrahs to be had.
12/29/19, 10:54 AM - Any chance of a pic of the front and back labels? The standard wine is definitely Croatian, not Bosnian, so I am curious what the label said.
10/31/19, 9:56 AM - 50 points??
10/27/19, 5:13 AM - Far, far too young! Leave until the later 2020s, and ought to last until the 2050s with ease.
10/26/19, 1:41 AM - If you want tertiary leave until some time c.2030!
10/16/19, 12:54 AM - What is a muddled strawberry seed?
8/14/19, 9:43 AM - Yes, Ch Simone red is lovely close to the vintage, and shuts down usually quite hard around age 2-3 to somewhere 8-10, and then opens up again beautifully.(The whites can also close down like this; the roses I prefer young to aged).
8/10/19, 7:15 AM - They all got consumed within a year or two of that note! They were drinkably pleasant and too great a risk to hog the cellar with long-term in the end.
5/31/19, 11:43 AM - I just bought another 12. The stuff is amazing, and vintages are going up in price since 2015.
5/11/19, 2:01 AM - Anything more enlightening?
7/25/18, 2:50 AM - A very low score (84) compared to your tasting note!?
6/29/18, 6:08 AM - No, I think this has the stuffing to go. Chianti classico, Brunello and other well-made structured Sangiovese like this are usually super with plenty of age.
5/25/18, 1:05 AM - I think a typo in the score there :)
4/4/18, 5:33 AM - My suspicion is just “boring” too
1/26/18, 10:20 AM - Is your score correct (98) on this one?
8/18/17, 7:10 AM - Too young. It is barely out of cask.
5/16/17, 12:41 PM - Coudoulet is not French, but is Provençal for "pebble" (like the ones all over CdP).
11/11/16, 4:54 AM - Most definitely flawed
11/12/16, 11:29 AM - I may have had more bottles of this wine than any other (!). The wine may sometimes seem awkward, out of balance, but it should never come across as lacking body. Sometimes I guess it might appear shrill or overly volatile. It's a huge beast of a wine, all sweet fruit and aromatics, and masses of alcohol - for better or worse. By the way.... I don't find this needing air now - pop open and pour.
2/22/15, 2:57 AM - I don't yet know the 2009 personally - though the vintage conditions were good. The wine is normally made to be able to be drunk on release if you want to though: the fruit quality is very high and is fantastic in youth. I like them at 7-10 years best, but they will keep longer. Open it if you like - you ought not to be disappointed.
1/24/15, 11:21 AM - I suspect a badly-stored bottle.... the ones I have had have been youthful, full of fruit and gloss
3/23/14, 10:06 AM - Harley... that comment seems to refer to my own latest review of this wine today. If you look at my range of comments on this same wine, you will see that I am indeed describing bottle variation, and tracking each bottle quite open-mindedly, and have posted quite a few notes about this wine and its different qualities in each bottle. Judging from my own experience of the half case I have had so far, and that of other reviewers here, there is a significant issue with bottle variation for this wine in this vintage.
1/27/14, 11:53 AM - 20+ year!
6/26/13, 2:43 AM - I've had several bottles of AJ Adam Kab and Spat from 2009, 2010 and 2011, and never had a problem with any of them. You must have been very unlucky as at the moment there's no reason to worry about the quality of the bottling in general.
1/10/13, 10:00 AM - I'm not sure that the 1994 Symingtons from Tesco is still technically "Quarles Harris".... I created this CT entry as at the time I purchased that was what I was told. Though my initial purchase was almost 10 years ago if my memory serves me. Tesco will probably have a range of option from Porto when it comes to filling their bottles.There's a little discussion about this here:- http://www.theportforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=4581&start=28- http://www.theportforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=1136- http://www.theportforum.com/viewtopic.php?p=13601
10/16/12, 1:16 PM - Crljenak Kaštelanski IS Zinfandel. Not the grandfather of it.
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search