4/13/24, 12:06 PM - Thanks for this great note! Been 9 years since my last bottle and you’ve inspired me to crack another soon.
4/6/24, 5:25 PM - Thanks for the great note and early look! Always nervous to open these young, they often need time. 2021 Temperance Hill does but Whistling Ridge is ready to go.
1/2/23, 5:44 AM - I noticed you posted the exact same note for the 2014. Which wine does the note apply to? Thanks.
12/31/22, 10:10 AM - Great note! You’ve inspired me to open one soon, maybe tonight. You marked it as flawed though, fyi… clearly not from your note.
12/4/22, 2:30 PM - Thanks for the evocative note! Glad to hear this is still going strong.
12/4/22, 3:02 PM - One down, two left!!
10/23/22, 2:15 PM - Not a Pinot
3/28/22, 9:12 PM - Thanks Rich, I appreciate your notes too. You know, I’m just in the drink while the drinking’s good camp. I’m sitting on a ton of 2012s, 2013s, 2018s… I haven’t come across many 2018s that feel ready yet, even Evangelho or Esola… but when I find one like the 2019 Esola I figure how much better can it get?
10/22/21, 2:02 PM - Thanks. I only bought one but have a couple of ‘18s I’ll let age. I’m more of an Esola, Evangelho, Bedrock, Old Hill guy myself.
4/23/20, 5:30 AM - Thanks for the great note.
3/21/20, 7:24 PM - Thanks Rich. They killed it with this one.
5/28/19, 5:38 PM - Thanks for the comment, I appreciate reading your thoughts. I agree it’s a big but balanced wine that should improve. I’m holding 4+ cases of Bedrock syrahs going back to 2009, so I’m counting on them improving! I didn’t realize how extensive the fire damage was at Sky Vineyard, so sad.
5/20/17, 6:59 PM - If you mistake this for a saignee and think it lacks fruit I question your palate or bottle. Another great vintage of Lulu, one of my two or three favorites and I've had all of them.
12/9/16, 2:31 PM - Great note, great wine, and with 18 bottles, great score by you!
9/9/16, 7:08 PM - This great note makes me both glad and sad that I have (only) one left.
9/5/16, 10:36 AM - You might consider recalibrating your scoring if you give an 87 to a "completely unbalanced" wine.
4/24/16, 6:18 AM - Not odd, cork taint usually comes from an individual cork and very, very rarely affects all the corks used to bottle a specific wine.
4/15/15, 3:27 PM - There was a significant change in winemaking style starting in 2006, changing the extraction and oak regimens at the domaine. Wines from 2006 and later are much less tannic and rustic than those from preceding vintages. So your idea of tasting '07 or '08 to experience this wine "before the fruit fades" won't work exactly as you expect... later wines started quite differently. That being said, in my experience, the old-school Faiveley rusticity mellows with sufficient age, revealing fruit beneath the tannin at 20+ years of age. So find a 90s version of this if you can. I'm holding my 2005s for at least 10 more years.
12/4/14, 8:56 PM - I've had 4 of these and none of them resembled your note. This wine is fabulous, not dark yellow and as of a year ago, not honeyed. I'd also guess heat damage. I've read that Half Wit won't hold shipping for mild weather so that suggests they may not be that concerned about storage temps. Couple of supporting links:http://www.wineberserkers.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=94763#p1360178http://www.wineberserkers.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=103300#p1519085
10/7/14, 5:07 PM - Strange that they released a bottling of this wine that spent 7 years in oak! Mine certainly didn't, as I bought it over 4 years ago. Can you upload a photo of the label? I'd be curious to see if it's any different from mine. Thanks for the note.
10/7/14, 5:50 PM - Thanks for the information. I think we definitely have different wines... I know the one I tasted in 2011 and the 1.5L bottle I have in my cellar (purchased in 2010) did not spend 7 years in oak! But they were/are certainly labeled Federspiel Vom Stein. Very strange and interesting that they bottle this multiple times. I do think my label looks slightly different than yours, but I'll have to go to my offsite cellar to confirm. Cheers.
9/29/14, 3:02 PM - Nice note! I'm not sure what they'll turn into either but I'm optimistic given their good acidities and overall balance. I'm looking forward to finding out.
9/30/14, 12:16 PM - Yes, several times (notes in CT), drank my last bottle earlier this month. It was still youthful and quite floral, but drinking wonderfully.
4/5/14, 2:34 PM - Thanks for this note Richard. I have a lone magnum of this, any thoughts on drinking window?
4/8/14, 6:29 AM - Thank you Richard! Much appreciated.
3/14/14, 6:08 PM - Great note, great observation that it hits all areas of the palate. Couldn't agree more.
3/14/14, 10:03 AM - Nice note and I love the pairing! Cheers.
2/20/14, 1:32 PM - Bridge night and a great Chablis... sounds like heaven! Thanks for the note, I haven't opened any of my bottles yet.
2/6/14, 9:54 AM - Great note Ken! I loved my last bottle, almost two years ago, you have me anticipating opening another soon. This is an estate wine, for what it's worth, Rhys owns and farms the vineyard even though it's in Anderson Valley.
1/14/14, 8:22 AM - Thanks for this note. So it tastes like a very complex, very compelling... Syrah?? Cab franc??
1/14/14, 3:56 PM - Thanks Wes. I'll definitely hold my two bottles awhile.
12/13/13, 6:10 PM - 10 months ago I thought this was pretty mute, maybe I'll try another bottle soon. Like FMIII, I loaded up on '10 Huet Secs. Thanks for the notes.
9/2/13, 1:48 PM - I've also been bothered by oak in Rhys chards (although I noticed very little in the two '10s tasted on pick-up days). Interestingly, Kevin Harvey doesn't think their chards show oak influence, as explained in this post: http://www.wineberserkers.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=1&t=70402&start=140#p960454Thanks for the nice note Frank.
8/24/13, 11:33 AM - Dry? Another taster below wrote that this has 105g/L residual sugar... was this a different bottling?
8/24/13, 12:07 PM - Thanks. Maybe I'll pull a bottle soon.
8/13/13, 8:23 PM - Totally agree Dan. I think M-M did really well in '09 and this is a great example. Zach
8/5/13, 6:03 AM - Thanks Harley. Cheers, Zach
7/26/13, 9:11 PM - Wow. Shocking given quality of the '09 and this producer in general. What do you think of H-N on the whole?
7/26/13, 9:38 PM - Thanks. Understood this was the '10. Appreciate your many notes.
4/2/13, 9:17 PM - Thanks for the comment Frank. I still have a nice stash of the '10 Huets (including that fabulous Le Mont sec!) but the Chidaines weren't distributed long or wide here in the Bay Area. The '11 Clos de Breuil is around but I haven't tried it yet. Cheers.
4/3/13, 8:34 AM - From what I've read about '11 Huets and Chidaines, buying one to taste sounds like good advice. Thanks. Zach
7/26/13, 9:01 AM - Awesome. Was planning on going to VVW tomorrow to taste the '11 Arlauds anyway. Thank you!
6/29/13, 11:09 AM - Thanks for the note Frank. Sounds like you prefer the '08? Or at least it sounds like I would prefer the '08 from your note. I'm down to my last bottle, but I have 4 of these '10s awaiting pickup. Wish I had one today for this heat wave! Zach
6/29/13, 2:39 PM - I've tried 3 of the '10 Chidaines so far but not the Tuffeaux. Saw a nice offer for it this week but didn't bite... would prefer to buy it locally. Will look forward to your note.
6/26/13, 7:12 PM - Thanks Frank. And thanks for your comments, it's always nice to know these get read. Jamie mentioned that he has a lot of this still, so I imagine you can order some more if you'd like. Cheers.
6/26/13, 7:10 PM - I thought this was showing great from pop and pour but it did show more structure than the others in the flight so it might benefit from more air. Really a pour and follow for my palate, I found a lot to like right off the bat. I can't comment on your choice of Anthill or RM unfortunately.
6/7/13, 8:46 PM - The '12 is out at retail now so I'm not sure how much of the '11 is still around. Click the "Where to Buy" button to find it on wine-searcher. I know the '12 is available at K&L and they ship to every state that allows wine shipments.
4/30/13, 8:50 AM - Thanks for the note Patrick. Picked some of this up from K&L recently, great price!
5/17/13, 9:35 AM - If you bought them at K&L, don't worry, they'll give you credit for flawed bottles.
3/31/13, 4:59 PM - Just one flight of four. More on offer but unfortunately my time was limited.
3/30/13, 10:14 AM - Nice note! But this isn't a rosé it just looks like one.
2/5/13, 6:53 AM - Nice note William. At the tasting room I was told that this saw 20 days of skin contact.
1/8/13, 8:47 PM - I'm surprised that you think this is such a big wine as that hasn't been my experience. Generally I find this bottling to show the more elegant side of syrah (as you noted). Did you find it big for a syrah? Or just big for your palate?
1/9/13, 8:20 AM - Thanks xwine. I enjoy your notes, please keep them up. Cheers!
12/6/12, 12:51 PM - Nice note Pete. We opened two bottles with our Thanksgiving dinner and I had an almost identical impression to yours. Including the should have bought more!
12/3/12, 10:26 AM - Thanks Brig. I like most of what I've tasted from Bryan Harrington... mostly Pinots but he's branching out into other varieties and makes a great Nebbiolo, among others. I agree this Tannat would be fun in a blind tasting.
10/30/11, 9:00 PM - A 2009 already shutting down? Wow. How many times have you had this?
9/17/11, 12:17 PM - How did it taste?
4/24/11, 6:52 PM - Keith, I have a few of these and your note obviously has me worried. I've tasted a fair number of '06s (not this one) and haven't come across anything remotely like the green meanies. When you say that the wine "picked up a level of delicacy" after 2 hours in the decanter... did the greenness subside? If you have/had more bottles, when would you open another? Thanks.
4/24/11, 6:48 PM - Dave, fyi this is Chardonnay, not SB. Thanks for the note.
4/12/11, 4:47 PM - Thanks smoke. If you have multiple bottles, I definitely wouldn't hesitate to pop one soon.
11/30/10, 9:26 PM - Almost certainly not past its prime, more likely shut down, like so many '05s are right now. I wouldn't touch another for 5 years, but it may take even longer than that for many '05s to come around.
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search