4/5/24, 12:23 AM - My two cents if I may - I assume DdC2016 is shut down and sleeping currently, this would explain why you got a thin/weak wine out of balance.LB2000 is in full fruit phase (before shutting down soon) so this is a bombastic, full throttle fruit bomb compared to a shut down wine from a classic vintage.Give the DdC a few years in the cellar and try again, I think from 2028 on you should find an open & mature wine with finesse, class & elegance. Cheers!
4/5/24, 9:20 AM - Perhaps variation in transport/storage temperature? Don’t know but my Bordeaux 16’ are all shut down still - not representative though as my Celler runs at 12 degrees celsius. Whatever it may be - enjoy your wines over the weekend! Cheers!
2/21/24, 11:56 PM - Wait. Zieregg starts to shine with 10+years after vintage. However, it won’t turn into your typical Loire SB, more yellow and dark fruited, powerful and dense. Like Burgundy from Côte d’Or with a more SB touch… but very Chardonnay like
12/15/23, 12:14 PM - Yep, that’s it… nailed it!
8/11/23, 6:19 AM - Hi Tim, hope all well.Thanks for the note on the 2004, sounds like I have to open one soon. One regular plus one magnum to go for me.Cheers, Edgar
7/28/23, 11:57 AM - Hi Bobby, I neither have Parkers plate (and don’t know if I really would want to) but my experience with Tement‘s SBs (1st growth and „grosse Lage“) shows that he is just about right with timing. Around 10 these SBs turn into themselves, become more yellow fruited and similar to aged Chardonnays. So, if you like the punchy, acidic and typical SB (gooseberries, elderflower, cat pee, etc) style drink them now, otherwise be patient. Cheers, Edgar
7/15/23, 1:50 AM - A suggestion.. Try it with, let’s say, 10 years of bottle age.2019 was a fantastic vintage in Austria and this shows in the very fruit forward aroma profiles and we’ll pronounced acidity. It’s like a red Bordeaux - initially you have a fruit forward phase and then a leaner, more balanced and elegant wine develops with time.I’m aware not everyone likes mature whites and not everyone wants to wait 10 years to drink a white wine.
6/22/23, 11:36 AM - I suggest to add Louis Roederer N.V. In your evaluation basket. Cheers, Edgar
6/22/23, 12:15 PM - Good to know, thanks. Will try if I can find somewhere.
1/2/23, 10:24 AM - Ja, mit Magnum würde ich definitiv noch ein paar Jahre warten. Prost und alles Gute im neuen Jahr!
12/24/22, 12:13 PM - Why didn’t you opt for „flawed“ then?
11/10/22, 2:34 AM - The compared 2007 Barolo (from a hot and fast-forward, “in your face”-vintage) is of course in it’s best place currently at 15 years after vintage and I imagine this bursts out of the glass.The 2013 (a classic vintage for Barolo) is completely shut down at the moment I assume.I’d suggest to keep further bottles at least until 2025 and give them air when you open them. My 2 cents… cheers! Edgar
4/3/22, 5:10 AM - Nice GV lineup, I hope you enjoyed.However, in a great GV lineup (which one would expect in the event in the Dolder) I would have exprected more regional variation, it seems to be mainly focused on Wachau.Only one wine from Kamptal, one from Wagram - nothing from Kremstal, Traisental or Weinviertel, the home turf of GV. From my experience the 2019s (especially the bigger guns as Kaptal Grub/Lamm or the better exposures of Wachau as Honivogl) are somewhat muted and dull now and do not show their great potential and brilliant structure.
3/27/22, 5:08 AM - If I may add mine… I often found Flaccianello thin, boring, harsh, not worth the money… And it tuned out that it was in a closed stage. I hope you‘ll find your Flaccianello-moment Stefan!
1/8/22, 7:46 AM - Danke für Deinen Kommentar. Das mit dem Kork ist natürlich ärgerlich - ich habe sehr viele Weine von Pöckl und wenn ich‘s recht im Kopf habe noch kaum korkende Flaschen geöffnet. Ist natürlich immer möglich aber generell scheinen die Pöckls gute Kokqualität zu kaufen.Prosit und happy Weekend! Edgar
3/5/21, 12:01 PM - Ciao Tim, I just read your noted now... thanks for this highly valuable (as always) note. I had the 13 (way too young) some years ago during a great Easter lunch in Barbaresco (Antica Torre). Always good to get your thoughts on the vintage variation - I have already tried to get this into my cellar. Now I know where to start. Hope to meet you soon again. Cheers, Edgar
2/26/21, 11:24 PM - Seltsam, meine „G“ haben alle einen Naturkorken - auch der 12er. Ich habe viele Weine von Gesellmann, sind eigentlich alle (Hochberc, Bela Rex, etc) mit Naturkorken versehen. Nur beim Opus Eximium, der hier zwei Gewichtsklassen darunter spielt, habe ich in manchen Jahren Schraubverschluss gesehen - aber auch dieser Wein hatte im Jahrgang 2012 noch Naturkork.Wie gesagt, seltsam - aber Hauptsache der Wein war gut. Grüsse aus Zürich, Edgar
10/14/20, 12:42 PM - Thanks for your TN, very helpful. It also gives me hope for my remaining 4 Magnums, the last one I tried some years back did not impress that much and I had some doubts about it‘s life to go. Your judgement combined with your tasting history makes the outlook a bit brighter, thanks for this! Cheers from Zurich, Edgar
9/20/20, 5:41 AM - Leave this alone until 2026 at least, then we‘ll see what‘s about the terroir and the winemakers qualities. I‘ve had this wine of similar vintages with 20years+ age and then it shows it‘s magic.
5/29/20, 1:44 PM - Hi Tim, hope you cope well with all this pandemic shit... thanks for your note, so I should open my single bottle soon and not for an important occasion if I read well your judgement. Thanks and take careEdgar
5/29/20, 1:59 PM - Will check in and report back, always a pleasure to exchange a few words with you - hope we‘ll meet again in on of those Osterie in Piemonte (or also in Ticino, Lombardia, Alto Adige, Toscana, Campania, wherever you are close to us). Stay safe, Edgar
5/21/20, 5:38 AM - If you want to know just enter the code on the label on their website. Cheers, Edgar
5/26/20, 9:34 AM - You are welcome. There is actually also an App from Roederer (free), you can scan the code there.
9/13/19, 11:03 AM - Tja, wenn die Muse küsst... ;-)Liebe Grüsse an alle, happy Weekend!
6/20/19, 10:37 AM - Hi there, for Barolos I suggest to slow-ox for several hours. Usually I open the bottle the evening before, separate from sediment and pour back into the bottle. I let this sit overnight without cork in the cold cellar. Next day they use to blossom. Open bottles keep improving (recorked) over night in the fridge. I have this wine in the cellar and was not a big fan either. But for a different reason, the wine was just too polished for me, doesn’t have Barolo characteristics. But this is obviously matter of taste. Cheers from Zurich, Edgar
6/22/19, 10:37 PM - You are warmly welcome, cheers, Edgar
12/9/18, 10:35 AM - Lieber Schönibert, ist der schon offen? Ich hab meine Kiste noch nicht geknackt, ist wohl mal einen Versuch wert... hatte kürzlich ein paar einfacherer 09er geöffnet (Fonreaud, Citran, Galliard), waren eben auch schon bereit zum Dienst. Also muss ich wohl auch hier ans Wekzeug. Liebe Grüsse aus Zürich, Edgar
11/8/18, 12:41 PM - Hi there, how are you? This was/is still a really boring bottle... maybe another day open or year in the cellar for the remaining ones helps a bit but I honestly don’t see a prosperous future for this... cheers, Edgar
6/14/18, 11:20 AM - Ja, wenn auch sonst nix zu trinken da ist was soll man schon machen?
6/6/18, 8:07 AM - Hi, how are you doing? Yes, I just can encourage you to give it a shot. Cheers, Edgar
5/1/18, 4:49 AM - So imagine the backward but extremely strong 2006. I agree with you thoughts about the 2007 but my 2006s (especially Magnum) I‘ll open on my retirement.
3/29/18, 11:20 AM - Hi Tim,I‘m actually sitting for dinner with Markus (Nostrabaccus) you have been talking with over phone today. We have an appointment at Conterno Fantino at 10.00 a.m. tomorrow, would be great if you could join.CheersEdgar
3/29/18, 12:26 PM - I don‘t think we can do 11.00, but we have a table booked at 12.30 at Osteria I Rebbi, in Monforte. Should we add some seats for you?
3/29/18, 1:46 PM - Great, we are all looking forward to meeting you and cracking some bottles! My wife just said „now, that’s what I call a blind tasting!“
11/16/17, 10:55 AM - Ja, ich mag Silvanos Weine sehr. Ich könnte bei ihm immer "einmal alles" kaufen. Preis/Leistungssieger im Piemont und die Riservas könne gut und gern mit den grossen Namen mithalten, nur zum Bruchteil des Preises. Ich würde mal schauen ob Du die Weine nicht über einen Onlinehändler findest. Wo in Deutschland bist Du zu Hause? Schönen Abend & Prost! Edgar
11/16/17, 10:53 AM - vielleicht liegt's an der Luft? Ich lasse die meisten Rotweine (auch sehr reife Weine) meistens offen über Nacht im kalten Keller stehen und geniesse sie dann am Folgetag, meist am Abend... dann sind sie gross! Das Konzept geht mit Nebbiolos aber auch mit dichten, strukturierten Aglianicos gut auf. Der 10er TdL ist sicher noch gut verschlossen, den würde ich vor 2020 nicht anfassen...
11/16/17, 10:47 AM - Guten Abend, ich bin erstmal der Edgar, der ein "Du" und kein "Sie" ist... so vieles von Mascarello habe ich noch nicht gekostet - aber die paar, die ich verkosten durfte lebten immer erst in schöner Reife (15 Jahre plus) auf. Wird aber nie ein Showstopper oder ein dicker Brummer, schlägt sehr leise, elegante Töne an. Liebe Grüsse aus Zürich, Edgar
9/24/17, 10:21 AM - Hi there Nanda. If you like Giacosa Barbarescos try also Paitin. I had a match of Giacosa Rabaja vs. Paitin Vecchie Vigne, both 2004 vintage. For me Paitin made it clearly, for a friction of the price. If you can get hold of Paitin in US, try a bottle... cheers mate! Edgar
2/19/17, 11:50 PM - Hi there Doug Fir,"Weichselkirsche" (=German) or simply "Weichsel" in Austria is "sour cherry". Same fruit as Cherry but less sweet with pale colour."druckvoller" means more powerful or more pressure. Coming back to your question... yes, I think the Nebbiolo Perbacco is an outstanding value.Is has more from a Barolo charakter than from a Barbaresco, so I'd compare it with an entry level Barolo. Indeed, with current maturity stage I prefer the Nebbiolo Perbacco to the Barolo Castiglione, the entry level Barolo from Vietti. It Shows currently sweeter fruit, less tannins and acidity and hence is much more approachable (but has aging potential as well).If you consider that the price of Perbacco is half the price of Castiglione (from the Producer and also in Swiss retail) and the charackter is similar I'd opt for Perbacco if you want to drink it soon.On the long run this is likely to change, I prefer Baroli with 12+ years as they become smoother and more balanced then. Happy to share my experiences anytime, just shout...Cheers,Edgar
1/8/17, 12:33 AM - Hi Repoper, the 04s are currently around the same stage as the 07s, also given the similarities of vintage. If you have more try one, they are awesome! The 06s, coming from a very classic/cool vintage, do. show high acidity and sharp tannins which need still years to come together. Cheers, Edgar
10/19/16, 10:01 AM - Hi there Wine Strategies,I agree with you, he's a great producer. We discovered his wines last year during summer Holiday and visited the vinery this summer for the first time. I use to buy the major part of my cellar directly from the vinery to get to know the people. By the way, before the Cavaliere we had the GiovinRe 2014 (100% Viognier from Bolgheri) with the appetizers. Pears, raisins but without becoming sweet, walnut... even if I am not a big fan of Italian whites (except Arneis) this is a great white wine which matches perfectly with game-cold cuts. Try this if you can find!Kind regards from Zurich, Edgar
10/19/16, 10:45 PM - Hi Tim,I envy you for wine travelling 3 months in a row. I will try to some of your recommendations.If you are 3 months in Italy you might consider to insert a brief jump to Austria. Southern Styria would be extremely close to the region of Friuli/Veneto. World class Sauvignon Blancs grow there (and also Chardonnays, which are called Morillon in Styria) and the 2015 vintage, which should be abvailable now, is extremely ripe and rich. If you are interested I can give you many contacts, also for other Austrian wineregions.Have fun on your wine-tour!Cheers, Edgar
6/25/16, 11:20 PM - Yes, indeed, it was a first bottle to try how advanced the case is. I'll start to drink these by 2019 probably. Cheers, Edgar
3/6/16, 9:12 PM - Hi there Shoebox, thanks for your note! Did you feel the wine evolved with air? Would you recommend decanting? Kind regards from Zurich, Edgar
1/15/16, 11:58 PM - In my opinion this wine is far from being ready. 10 years from now and you can start to try. Montrose mid 90s are drinking well now. Kind regards from Zurich, Edgar
8/22/15, 8:08 AM - Hi there Champagneinhand,Well, I agree that this wine is very good today but if you have some more I'd reccomend to hold one bottle for several years... You might be surprised about the potential of high level Barberas.I had some aged Barberas like Bricco dell'Uccellone or Bricco della Bigotta (Braida) and I would consider the Cascina Francia from Conterno to be on a similar level.15+ years contribute very well to the development of these wines... Try it!Kind regards from Zurich, Edgar
8/22/15, 11:35 PM - Bricco dell'Uccellone 1990 was one of the best wines I ever tasted. My last bottle we had more or less one year ago.The character of Barbera changes then also and it's quite similar to aged Barolo - it's the terroir coming out more and more.I don't think that many Barberas will have the potential to go on the long haul like this but I consider Cascina Francia from GC to be one of them. I'll save one of mine, together with one Bricco dell'Uccellone and a Barbera from Mascarello (all from the outstanding vintage 2010) for a tasing around 2025/2030...Cheers, Edgar
8/15/15, 12:13 AM - Hallo Nubian,Nun, ich denke, das hängt ganz von der persönlichen Vorliebe ab wie "reif" man Bordeaux mag. Der Wein ist sicherlich offen und trinkfertig, also aus der verschlossenen Phase heraus. Jetzt ist auch noch Frucht da, die immer mehr durch erdige Töne ersetzt wird. Wenn Du vom Wein nach einigen Tagen an der Luft beeindruckt warst ist das ein Zeichen, dass Dir der Wein mit etwas mehr Reife besser gefällt, also mit weiteren Flaschen etwas warten.Hope this helps, Prost!Edgar
8/16/15, 8:56 PM - Hallo Rainer,Ja, voll und ganz Deiner Meinung. Für mich ist Phelan Segur einer der besten Weine, vor allem extrem viel Wein fürs Geld. Auch sehr verlässlich, beweist sich auch in schwierigen Jahren (siehe 2002) immer wieder.Bei 2005 würde ich aufpassen, da kommt es auf Deinen Keller an. Meine sind noch nicht trinkfertig aber die liegen auch bei 11 Grad... Da brauchen die Dinger etwas länger... Sonst einfach mal eine Flasche aufmachen, sollte mit etwas Dekantierzeit sicherlich gut zu trinken sein.Liebe Grüsse, Edgar
7/4/15, 5:45 AM - Hi there Zweder, do you know if the win was decanted? What would you recommend? Thanks for your feedback, kind regards from Zurich! Edgar
7/4/15, 7:44 PM - Many thanks for your feedback, very helpful! Edgar
7/4/15, 1:23 PM - Well, you find me embarassed... A autentic expession of my thoughts in English... Thanks HowardTheDuck! Kind regard from Zurich, Edgar
7/4/15, 5:51 AM - Hi Rosenst1, thanks for your helpful note! What would you recommend in terms of decanting? Did you see improvement/change over the time you consumed the bottle? Thanks and kind regards from Zurich, Edgar
7/4/15, 11:13 AM - Many thanks for your suggestion! I'm quite new to Burgudy whites (since my youth I was rather focused on Austria for whites). Hence I'm doing my first steps and will try one of these in my cellar with a decant. Have a great weekend with great wines! Edgar
6/24/15, 9:04 PM - Agree... I think 06 is quite similar to 96 (the Leo Barton 96 is still not really ready BTW).I drink the simpler reds of this vintage but Leos or Montrose will remain several years in my cellar before being touched.Thanks for this interesting review, 6 hours decant, two days in the bottle and another hour of decant shows the material this wine is made of... Cheers, Edgar
6/4/15, 8:23 AM - Hi there Alex, that's wonderful news!!!! Best wishes to you and Mrs. Ubercuvee!Kind regards from Zurich,Edgar PS: also I would marry you with your cellar BTW
1/6/15, 6:17 AM - Hi there La Turque!I think the wine is simply closed down (or better, it might be still in it's fruit period but the decant closed it).According my experience with Barbarescos (or anyway generally with red wines) is that young fruitful wines need to be drank immediately as the air accellerates the develpoment and closes the wine down.Barbarescos (and Barolos) need a lot of air to open up and I do open them generally one day before I drink them but - depending on the vintage - starting with age 8+. Especially the 2010s have a high acidity/tannin-structure so there is low fun level when they are young. Kind regards from Zurich, Edgar
1/6/15, 7:36 AM - Let me know when you are around and I'll organize something...
10/23/14, 8:52 PM - I think this is just sleeping well, the character you describe is exactly a closed down Barolo, which usually does not reveil anything but acidity and harsh tannins. If you have other bottles just wait (Baroli use to open up lovely around the age of 12). Best regards from Zurich, Edgar
9/27/14, 11:24 AM - Hi there Yofog,You mentioned the nose of Silvanos wines which always is incredible...Well, we know Silvano now for 10 years more or less and we visit his vinery almost once a year. He became something similar to a friend during all these years.What I can tell you about his wines and their aging potential is that the wines never are or will become blockbusters, they are very burgundian in terms of body and extraction. But the nose is incredible and nothing compares to them. With some more years of aging this nose becomes even more intensive and develops a character which is unique in Piemonte.So, if you have the chance to buy some of these I would reccomend to do so, leave them alone somewhere in your cellar for 5-8 years and you won't regret!Kind regards from Zurich, EdgarPS: try also the Barbera, it is on Piemont's top level and a steal!
9/13/14, 2:13 PM - Hoi Nostrabacchus, wenn das Deine letzte Flasche war und Du den Wein gerne hast kann ich aushelfen - ich hab' noch drei im Keller und die würden irgendwann ihr Ende in einer Sosse finden... Ich mag' den Wein so ganz und gar nicht! Lass mich dich wissen wann/wo wir uns kurz treffen können, ich hab' die drei Flaschen dann mit. (Ich wohne in Uetikon am See und arbeite am Bellevue, wären schon mal zwei guten Anhaltspunkte für ein Treffen). Schönen Abend, Edgar
9/14/14, 9:17 AM - edgar_magyar@hotmail.com oder edgar.magyar@publicis.chFreu' mich von Dir zu hören, schönen Sonntagabend!Edgar
8/25/14, 7:19 AM - Dear Bradetti,I experienced that most of the Barolos open up in age 10-12.It might be the case here as "very dry palate", perhaps combined with high acid level, indicates somehow that this Barolo-baby is sleeping well.I remember the 2007 Castiglione as very fruity, sweet but balanced, delicious wine during it's fruit-period when it was botteled. I'll give mine a try in 2020...Cheers from Zurich! Edgar
7/28/14, 11:16 PM - Hoi Stefan, danke für den Kommentar, Admiral beatätigt sich also als der Burgenländische La Tour... hast Du auch Erfahrungen mit Rosso e Nero und Reve de Jeunesse gemacht?
7/29/14, 11:23 AM - Na da sollten wir doch mal gemeinsam anstossen... Bin im Moment in der Toscana aber ab kommender Woche wieder unter edgar_magyar@hotmail.com erreichbar. Liebe Grüsse & schönen Abend!
Thanks for letting us know about this problem. We will review your comments and be in touch soon with an update.
Search