Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(66 comments on 51 notes)

1 - 50 of 51 Sort order
Red
2016 Domaine de Chevalier Pessac-Léognan Red Bordeaux Blend
4/3/2024 - jcbd9415 Does not like this wine:
91 points
Just had it yesterday, funny because I generally agree with a couple of these reviews. It did feel pretty light/thin but I do think that's a character of Pessac. I also felt the bitterness on the after taste after being opened a couple hours, seemed out of balance which is strange for a wine of this caliber. I was really unimpressed. Langoa barton 2020 destroys this wine at half the cost. Pass unfortunately, I really really wanted to like this but just didn't. The poop manure on the nose didn't help either. :(
  • EMAZurich commented:

    4/5/24, 12:23 AM - My two cents if I may - I assume DdC2016 is shut down and sleeping currently, this would explain why you got a thin/weak wine out of balance.
    LB2000 is in full fruit phase (before shutting down soon) so this is a bombastic, full throttle fruit bomb compared to a shut down wine from a classic vintage.
    Give the DdC a few years in the cellar and try again, I think from 2028 on you should find an open & mature wine with finesse, class & elegance. Cheers!

  • EMAZurich commented:

    4/5/24, 9:20 AM - Perhaps variation in transport/storage temperature? Don’t know but my Bordeaux 16’ are all shut down still - not representative though as my Celler runs at 12 degrees celsius.
    Whatever it may be - enjoy your wines over the weekend! Cheers!

White
2017 Tement Sauvignon Blanc Grosse Lage STK Zieregg Südsteiermark
2/21/2024 - Montesquieu wrote:
92 points
Three years since my last tasting and review, I'm giving this the same score and wondering if even more time is needed for this to become something different than a very primary, crisp, minerally, flinty, grapefruit-infused wine. Consumed over about an hour from PnP, so my notes don't reflect long aeration. I have another 8 bottles from this and two other vintages, but I may conclude this style isn't my favorite.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    2/21/24, 11:56 PM - Wait. Zieregg starts to shine with 10+years after vintage. However, it won’t turn into your typical Loire SB, more yellow and dark fruited, powerful and dense. Like Burgundy from Côte d’Or with a more SB touch… but very Chardonnay like

Red
2003 Montevetrano Montevetrano Colli di Salerno IGT Red Blend
12/14/2023 - robmatic wrote:
92 points
Super herbal, with rosemary and caraway leading the charge. Youthful, tannic, succulent. Huge personality.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    12/15/23, 12:14 PM - Yep, that’s it… nailed it!

Red
2004 Montevetrano Montevetrano Colli di Salerno IGT Red Blend
Very good. I have to say goodbye to this old friend as this is my final bottle. This has been so satisfying over the past decade, such a great value, too. Definitely on the backside of its curve, with slightly more tertiary than secondary at this stage. Pitch perfect acid/sweet tannins, elegant, long. Regal, like Sylvia. Memorable like her, too. A joy. highly recommended. Very good through four hours open. Now and the next several years.

https://www.ItalianWine.blog
  • EMAZurich commented:

    8/11/23, 6:19 AM - Hi Tim, hope all well.
    Thanks for the note on the 2004, sounds like I have to open one soon. One regular plus one magnum to go for me.
    Cheers, Edgar

White
2019 Tement Sauvignon Blanc Erste Lage STK Ried Grassnitzberg Südsteiermark
7/28/2023 - bobbylion Likes this wine:
93 points
I am not at Parkers 96, but this is very good now and he seems to know where this is going

This is pretty full now without being fat. It has complex flowery nose and some nice sweetness

Parker’s review says it should get into its own by 2028 - I don’t know. Pretty good now for me.

Raising my score to 93 on day three in the fridge - half bottle. Beautiful salinity joins Mineral notes and gives the whole thing a great lift. Ordered another half case. Great value for 25 euros.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    7/28/23, 11:57 AM - Hi Bobby, I neither have Parkers plate (and don’t know if I really would want to) but my experience with Tement‘s SBs (1st growth and „grosse Lage“) shows that he is just about right with timing. Around 10 these SBs turn into themselves, become more yellow fruited and similar to aged Chardonnays.
    So, if you like the punchy, acidic and typical SB (gooseberries, elderflower, cat pee, etc) style drink them now, otherwise be patient.
    Cheers, Edgar

White
2019 Schloss Gobelsburg Grüner Veltliner 1ÖTW Ried Lamm Kamptal
7/14/2023 - Doc Malvern wrote:
90 points
Technically a very good wine, but to me needs rich food to balance it out and show it at its best. It’s quite rich and fruity with peach, apricot, honey, passion fruit, pineapple, and white pepper flavours. Rounded acidity, textured, a slight fruit sweetness and very long finish.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    7/15/23, 1:50 AM - A suggestion.. Try it with, let’s say, 10 years of bottle age.
    2019 was a fantastic vintage in Austria and this shows in the very fruit forward aroma profiles and we’ll pronounced acidity.
    It’s like a red Bordeaux - initially you have a fruit forward phase and then a leaner, more balanced and elegant wine develops with time.
    I’m aware not everyone likes mature whites and not everyone wants to wait 10 years to drink a white wine.

White - Sparkling
N.V. Gosset Champagne Brut Grande Réserve Champagne Blend
6/19/2023 - pmarlo Likes this wine:
90 points
Golden yellow and vigorous bubbles. Citrus but restrained. This may be orange or lemon, but also the slightest tinge of grapefruit. Not saline at all. Slightly bitter and all notes are within first half hour. Ben Christensen says quickness across the palate and I agree, yet there is an aftertaste that lingers. Nice dryness. Acid is just right and doesn't make me pucker. Other reviewers say apple, pear, and nectarines and I don't see to see this but I also don't rule it out. The real taste is elusive and seems to be a mix of several fruits. Seems like a good champagne but not complex.
Next day the wine was just as good and flavors seemed a little more intense. There was more grapefruit present. Bubbles still but not like the first day and my sealing method works decent for carbonated wines. Think this is a worthy go to. I am evaluating the large houses Gosset, Charles Heidsieck, Pol Roget, Bollinger and a few others to see which may be the best go to.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    6/22/23, 11:36 AM - I suggest to add Louis Roederer N.V. In your evaluation basket. Cheers, Edgar

  • EMAZurich commented:

    6/22/23, 12:15 PM - Good to know, thanks. Will try if I can find somewhere.

Red
2015 Weingut Josef Pöckl Rosso e Nero Neusiedlersee Red Blend
1/1/2023 - EMAZurich Likes this wine:
92 points
Halbflasche.
Ein weiteres Jahr im Keller hat dem Wein gutgetan.
Deutlich harmonischer, nach wie vor sehr präsente Säure und forsch in den Tanninen aber die (schwarzbeerige) Frucht kommt nun druckvoll durch und hält dagegen. Erste, offene Phase und in diesem Format antrinkbar aber mit Normalflaschen würde ich schon noch warten.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    1/2/23, 10:24 AM - Ja, mit Magnum würde ich definitiv noch ein paar Jahre warten. Prost und alles Gute im neuen Jahr!

Red
2004 Giacomo Borgogno & Figli Barolo Riserva Nebbiolo
12/24/2022 - Vancouver wrote:
flawed
Seriously flawed bottle. Color of prune juice, barnyard aromas, no structure or acidity and totally shot.

Just goes to show that you never know when a wine hits 20 years old or so.

Another bottle drank a year ago and purchased at the same time was worth a 93 rating....
  • EMAZurich commented:

    12/24/22, 12:13 PM - Why didn’t you opt for „flawed“ then?

Red
2013 Elio Grasso Barolo Gavarini Chiniera Nebbiolo
11/4/2022 - darrenhe wrote:
87 points
First bottle of a 6-bottle case and ultimately a bit disappointing. This will be good but just way too young on this showing. Paired with rib-eye steak and we also opened a 2007 Barolo from another (less heralded) estate which was in a much better more developed place. Probably an unfair comparison! Will leave the other bottles a good while before trying again. Did get better on day 2 after a good few hours in the decanter!
  • EMAZurich commented:

    11/10/22, 2:34 AM - The compared 2007 Barolo (from a hot and fast-forward, “in your face”-vintage) is of course in it’s best place currently at 15 years after vintage and I imagine this bursts out of the glass.
    The 2013 (a classic vintage for Barolo) is completely shut down at the moment I assume.
    I’d suggest to keep further bottles at least until 2025 and give them air when you open them.
    My 2 cents… cheers! Edgar

White
2019 Franz Hirtzberger Grüner Veltliner Smaragd Honivogl Wachau
Masterclass with Stephan Reinhardt: 2019 Grüner Veltliner (The Dolder Grand, Zurich): Glass: Schölzle Universal
Clear, medium golden color. Deep, bold and intense nose. You can almost feel the extract of this wine through the nose. On the palate very hedonistic. Lots of ripe apricot and other ripe fruit, botrytis, creamy texture. Lots of extract, very good balance, never hot. Very long finish. Give it at least a decade, better two to fully emerge. Great potential! 93+++
  • EMAZurich commented:

    4/3/22, 5:10 AM - Nice GV lineup, I hope you enjoyed.
    However, in a great GV lineup (which one would expect in the event in the Dolder) I would have exprected more regional variation, it seems to be mainly focused on Wachau.
    Only one wine from Kamptal, one from Wagram - nothing from Kremstal, Traisental or Weinviertel, the home turf of GV.
    From my experience the 2019s (especially the bigger guns as Kaptal Grub/Lamm or the better exposures of Wachau as Honivogl) are somewhat muted and dull now and do not show their great potential and brilliant structure.

Red
2016 Fontodi Flaccianello della Pieve Colli della Toscana Centrale IGT Sangiovese
Our scores are both around 80, and this is obviously not our cup of tea.

Great acidity and tannic build, but other than that... *pft* nothing. It's thin. Terribly thin.

If you like Burgundy, then you may like also this. If you are like us and don't quite "get it" with Burgundy, you're likely to feel that you wasted your money and an evening for ... nothing.

An utterly non-interesting wine.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    3/27/22, 5:08 AM - If I may add mine… I often found Flaccianello thin, boring, harsh, not worth the money…
    And it tuned out that it was in a closed stage.
    I hope you‘ll find your Flaccianello-moment Stefan!

Red
2011 Weingut Josef Pöckl Rosso e Nero Neusiedlersee Red Blend
1/7/2022 - EMAZurich Likes this wine:
94 points
(Leider die letzte) Halbflasche… andere Formate habe ich Gott sei Dank noch 😉. Und das obwohl der Rosso e Nero hier gute Abnehmer findet und meistens schnell verschwindet.
Eine Traumnase! Brombeere, Schwarzkirsche, Johannisbeere, Banane, Lakritze, Gewürze. Ich habe auch etwas Rauchiges, aber keine Sekundär-/Terriäraromen. Wirkt wie in jungem Trinkfenster. Am Gaumen druckvoll, dicht - die rot-/schwarzbeerige Frucht (Kirsche voran) und die schokoladige Süsse wird aber durch die tolle, frische Säure und die wunderschöne Mineralik in Schach gehalten. Toll eingebundene und runde, feingliedrige Tannine. Ein Traumwein, spielt in deutlich höherer Liga ohne internationale Vorbilder verschlimmbessern zu wollen.
Wanna try a great Austrian red? Try this!!!
  • EMAZurich commented:

    1/8/22, 7:46 AM - Danke für Deinen Kommentar. Das mit dem Kork ist natürlich ärgerlich - ich habe sehr viele Weine von Pöckl und wenn ich‘s recht im Kopf habe noch kaum korkende Flaschen geöffnet. Ist natürlich immer möglich aber generell scheinen die Pöckls gute Kokqualität zu kaufen.
    Prosit und happy Weekend! Edgar

Red
2014 Serafino Rivella Barbaresco Montestefano Nebbiolo
Aerate to decanter 90 minutes. I've not tasted this since release when it was wide open - and yes, I enjoyed the firmness of the tannins at the time. That said, it's a good degree more coiled than that time (nearly two years ago, already), and I was constantly swirling away to get it to try and get back to that wide open status; wasn't really in the cards. A small glass on night 2 was more complete, but I think I'll wait. All of that having been said, I bought another 2 bottles that I'll plan to open post 2024/beyond. Totally in my wheelhouse. highly recommended

http://www.italianwine.blog
  • EMAZurich commented:

    3/5/21, 12:01 PM - Ciao Tim, I just read your noted now... thanks for this highly valuable (as always) note. I had the 13 (way too young) some years ago during a great Easter lunch in Barbaresco (Antica Torre). Always good to get your thoughts on the vintage variation - I have already tried to get this into my cellar. Now I know where to start. Hope to meet you soon again. Cheers, Edgar

Red
2012 Gesellmann Blaufränkisch G Mittelburgenland
2/26/2021 - MM29 wrote:
93 points
Kein Korken, ein Deckeliwy wie wir in der Schweiz sagen. Hat mich irgendwie schockiert und irritiert. Ein Wein in dieser (Preis)Klasse zum aufschrauben? Muss mich daran gewöhnen...der Wein aus Superjahr ist sehr gut, hat womöglich noch bessere Zukunft...wenn ich nur dem Verschluss trauen könnte
  • EMAZurich commented:

    2/26/21, 11:24 PM - Seltsam, meine „G“ haben alle einen Naturkorken - auch der 12er.
    Ich habe viele Weine von Gesellmann, sind eigentlich alle (Hochberc, Bela Rex, etc) mit Naturkorken versehen. Nur beim Opus Eximium, der hier zwei Gewichtsklassen darunter spielt, habe ich in manchen Jahren Schraubverschluss gesehen - aber auch dieser Wein hatte im Jahrgang 2012 noch Naturkork.

    Wie gesagt, seltsam - aber Hauptsache der Wein war gut.

    Grüsse aus Zürich, Edgar

Red
2005 Château Clarke Listrac-Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend
10/10/2020 - bestdamncab Likes this wine:
93 points
From a magnum, nose of black cherry, licorice, and forest floor, same on the palate, showing well, at peak, time to enjoy in this format, mouth filling, tasty, big body, subtle hint of soft tannins, easily last 10 more years, long finish.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    10/14/20, 12:42 PM - Thanks for your TN, very helpful. It also gives me hope for my remaining 4 Magnums, the last one I tried some years back did not impress that much and I had some doubts about it‘s life to go. Your judgement combined with your tasting history makes the outlook a bit brighter, thanks for this! Cheers from Zurich, Edgar

Red
2016 Giacomo Conterno Barbera d'Alba Vigna Francia
9/19/2020 - Outplaying wrote:
I didn’t love this. It is rich with blue and dark fruits and a touch of wood. The 15.5% alcohol is hidden pretty well and there is a lot of acidity. We didn’t have the right food with it, so that didn’t help. Just not my style of wine.

We had this along with the 06, and it was tough to pick a favorite.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    9/20/20, 5:41 AM - Leave this alone until 2026 at least, then we‘ll see what‘s about the terroir and the winemakers qualities. I‘ve had this wine of similar vintages with 20years+ age and then it shows it‘s magic.

Red
2011 Montevetrano Montevetrano Colli di Salerno IGT Red Blend
Aerated in decanter 2 hours. Promising nose of bitter chocolate, tree bark, some cassis fruit, and soil. Palate under performs the nose. Good, linear over 2 hours; not great. NR

https://www.ItalianWine.blog
  • EMAZurich commented:

    5/29/20, 1:44 PM - Hi Tim, hope you cope well with all this pandemic shit...

    thanks for your note, so I should open my single bottle soon and not for an important occasion if I read well your judgement.

    Thanks and take care
    Edgar

  • EMAZurich commented:

    5/29/20, 1:59 PM - Will check in and report back, always a pleasure to exchange a few words with you - hope we‘ll meet again in on of those Osterie in Piemonte (or also in Ticino, Lombardia, Alto Adige, Toscana, Campania, wherever you are close to us). Stay safe, Edgar

White - Sparkling
N.V. Louis Roederer Champagne Brut Premier Champagne Blend
5/20/2020 - SMagowan Likes this wine:
91 points
Nice toast and citrus combination. No idea when disgorged. Bought bottle 4 years ago.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    5/21/20, 5:38 AM - If you want to know just enter the code on the label on their website. Cheers, Edgar

  • EMAZurich commented:

    5/26/20, 9:34 AM - You are welcome. There is actually also an App from Roederer (free), you can scan the code there.

Red
2008 Weingut Josef Pöckl Admiral Neusiedlersee Red Blend
9/8/2019 - EMAZurich Likes this wine:
94 points
Tiefstes, undurchdringliches Schwarzpurpur, ganz schmaler bordeauxroter Rand, gänzlich ohne Wasserrand. Beeindruckende Farbe. Trotz den - für heutige Verhältnisse angenehmen - „geringen“ 13.5 Volumsprozent ziehen dicke, tiefrote Tränen den Glasrand herab.

Eine unverkennbare Admiralnase. Schwarzkirsche, Johannisbeere, leicht rauchig, würzig, etwas Stangensellerie, Rosmarin und Tannenzweige, sehr konzentriert.

Am Gaumen noch sehr forsch und adstringent. Druckvolle, dunkelbeerige Frucht, dem Nasenbild gleich. Tragende, prominente Säurestruktur, forsche aber feingliedrige Tannine. Um dem Wein gute Balance zu attestieren sticht mir das -immernoch - akzentuierte Bitterl zu deutlich hervor.

Eine Macht an Körper und Struktur. Eher ein Wein zum Kauen als zum Trinken, der Verkoster sollte Messer & Gabel dabeihaben. Vielleicht auch kein Wein zum Essen. Ist alles etwas zu viel des Guten, ein angenehm frischer Barbaresco (zum Beispiel), ein klassischer Rioja oder ein Blaufränkischer (um in Österreich zu bleiben) wären zum Fleisch sicherlich besser geeignet. Wahrscheinlich wäre fast jeder andere Rotwein besserer Güte ein besserer Essensbegleiter, der Wein ist einfach zu massiv.

Bleibt ewig am Gaumen haften. Zeigt mir dadurch aber das weitere Potential dieses grossartigen Gewächses. Das Finale hat mir dann aber doch zu wenig Mineralik und Komplexität um den Wein in den 95-100er Himmel heben zu können.

Ich habe gottlob eine Vielzahl der Weine von Pöckl im Keller. Die Jahrgangstiefe ist sehr ausgeprägt, vor allem bei Admiral - obwohl ich kaum Admiral trinke. Trotzdem kaufe ich regelmässig, in der Hoffnung auf aussergewöhnliche Erlebnisse sobald der Wein wirklich reif ist.

Der 2008er ist heute sicherlich „offen“. Also, die Frucht ist da, der Wein zeigt sich bereit für eine einladende Auseinandersetzung. Heisst aber noch lange nicht, dass das Ding wirklich reif ist. Der Spitzname „Latour aus Österreich“ ist wirklich sehr passend, das braucht gewiss weitere 5-10 (vielleicht sogar 15) Jahre um „benutzerfreundlich“ zu werden.

Dann wird dieser Wein aber sicher ein aussergewöhnliches Erlebnis bieten (und 2008 ist bei Gott kein Paradejahr, meine 09er, 11er, 12er und 15er schlummern ja im Keller). Im Alter von 20+ werde ich eine dieser Flaschen einem Deuxièmes Cru aus Pauillac desselben Jahrgangs gegenüberstellen und bin mir bereits sicher den Gewinner zu kennen - zumindest beim 08er! 94

Tag 2 - heute deutlich erdiger als gestern. Das grossartige Aromenprofil von gestern ist geblieben, der Wein wirkt aber ruhiger, balancierter und erwachsener. Zumindest 5 Jahre wird man aber schon noch warten müssen. Bestätige das gestrige Rating.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    9/13/19, 11:03 AM - Tja, wenn die Muse küsst... ;-)
    Liebe Grüsse an alle, happy Weekend!

Red
2008 Domenico Clerico Barolo Ciabot Mentin Nebbiolo
6/19/2019 - kmadamskkz Likes this wine:
89 points
I'm new to Barolos, so I didn't know what to expect. Medium garnet color with a fair bit of bricking at the edge. Aromas of sour cherry and leather, with some cedar at the end. Medium body with pronounced acidity and softened but still assertive tannins, Flavors echo the aroma, with a bit more complexity. Sour dark cherry, with chewy tobacco and leather, with toasted spice on the medium finish. Have to say I like the aged flavors but the wine is out of balance, acidity and tannins are to strong for the fruit that was there. It's much better with food, I drank this both straight and with an eggplant napoleon the had nice ground pork ragu and it cut through the acidity and tannin, but I had to drink the wine after each bite, it couldn't be drank pleasantly on the side. I Don't know where WS came up with 2035, but this is past whatever prime it had, 2035 would be totally destroyed. Drink by 2025, MAX!
  • EMAZurich commented:

    6/20/19, 10:37 AM - Hi there, for Barolos I suggest to slow-ox for several hours. Usually I open the bottle the evening before, separate from sediment and pour back into the bottle. I let this sit overnight without cork in the cold cellar. Next day they use to blossom. Open bottles keep improving (recorked) over night in the fridge. I have this wine in the cellar and was not a big fan either. But for a different reason, the wine was just too polished for me, doesn’t have Barolo characteristics. But this is obviously matter of taste. Cheers from Zurich, Edgar

  • EMAZurich commented:

    6/22/19, 10:37 PM - You are warmly welcome, cheers, Edgar

Red
2009 Château Rollan de By Médoc Red Bordeaux Blend
12/9/2018 - Schönibert wrote:
91 points
Superlecker, immer noch voll auf der Frucht und gleichzeitig mit so herrlicher roter Säure und packendem Tanin ausgestattet. Man bräuchte viel mehr Flaschen, um zu sehen, was hier in 10 Jahren oder später abgeht, und auch bis dahin genug von dem Zeug reinzukippen!
  • EMAZurich commented:

    12/9/18, 10:35 AM - Lieber Schönibert, ist der schon offen? Ich hab meine Kiste noch nicht geknackt, ist wohl mal einen Versuch wert... hatte kürzlich ein paar einfacherer 09er geöffnet (Fonreaud, Citran, Galliard), waren eben auch schon bereit zum Dienst. Also muss ich wohl auch hier ans Wekzeug. Liebe Grüsse aus Zürich, Edgar

Red
2010 Tenuta San Guido Guidalberto Toscana IGT Red Bordeaux Blend
11/8/2018 - EMAZurich wrote:
89 points
Hmmm, etwas sekundäraromatischer aber dadurch nicht besser. Wirklich, aber wirklich... fad!
  • EMAZurich commented:

    11/8/18, 12:41 PM - Hi there, how are you? This was/is still a really boring bottle... maybe another day open or year in the cellar for the remaining ones helps a bit but I honestly don’t see a prosperous future for this... cheers, Edgar

Red
2015 Montevetrano Montevetrano Colli di Salerno IGT Red Blend
6/8/2018 - EMAZurich wrote:
92 points
Paitin Vertikale - Vecchie Vigne (Zurich): Hmmmm... mal sehen... hat Dichte, druckvolle Frucht, feine und elegante Tannine und gute Säure. Eben, mal sehen. Aber tolles Potential!
  • EMAZurich commented:

    6/14/18, 11:20 AM - Ja, wenn auch sonst nix zu trinken da ist was soll man schon machen?

White
2010 Weingut Hirsch Grüner Veltliner Reserve Lamm Kamptal
6/6/2018 - EMAZurich Likes this wine:
94 points
Die zwei Jahre haben dem Wein gutgetan. Nase hat den Pfeffer und die Zitrus-/Apfelaromen behalten, wirkt aber nun auch etwas dichter/bananiger. Auch Nuss und Heu sind dabei, grossartig!
Am Gaumen weiterhin druckvolle Frucht und genialer Säurebogen, der Wein bleibt dabei wunderbar schlank und mineralisch. Einfach ein grosser Veltliner! Schade, hab meine Flaschen zu schnell/früh getrunken, das war meine letzte.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    6/6/18, 8:07 AM - Hi, how are you doing? Yes, I just can encourage you to give it a shot. Cheers, Edgar

Red
2007 Weingut Josef Pöckl Admiral Neusiedlersee Red Blend
5/1/2018 - Frank Schneider wrote:
91 points
First night after 3 h of decanting nearly undrinkable. So tannic . No fun
So back in the bottle !!!
Second night after 3 h of decanting this diva lifted the skirt a little . Just allowed a tiny peep of what will come in the future. Its all in. Fruit , body, acid and a lot of tannin. Forget this for years !!!!!91 +
  • EMAZurich commented:

    5/1/18, 4:49 AM - So imagine the backward but extremely strong 2006. I agree with you thoughts about the 2007 but my 2006s (especially Magnum) I‘ll open on my retirement.

White
2016 Paitin di Pasquero-Elia Langhe Arneis Vigna Elisa Langhe DOC
3/29/2018 - EMAZurich wrote:
90 points
Piemont Trip; 3/28/2018-4/1/2018 (Barbaresco, Barolo): Bei Silvano am Weingut. Der Wein wurde zimmerwarm serviert um Nuancen besser verstehen zu können.
Eher verhaltene Nase. Am Gaumen voll, eher breit. Apfeltöne, feine Mineralik. Kein grosser Weisswein aber gut gemacht.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    3/29/18, 11:20 AM - Hi Tim,

    I‘m actually sitting for dinner with Markus (Nostrabaccus) you have been talking with over phone today. We have an appointment at Conterno Fantino at 10.00 a.m. tomorrow, would be great if you could join.

    Cheers
    Edgar

  • EMAZurich commented:

    3/29/18, 12:26 PM - I don‘t think we can do 11.00, but we have a table booked at 12.30 at Osteria I Rebbi, in Monforte. Should we add some seats for you?

  • EMAZurich commented:

    3/29/18, 1:46 PM - Great, we are all looking forward to meeting you and cracking some bottles! My wife just said „now, that’s what I call a blind tasting!“

Red
2010 Paitin di Pasquero-Elia Barbaresco Vecchie Vigne Riserva Sorì Paitin Nebbiolo
11/22/2015 - EMAZurich Likes this wine:
96 points
Piemont Tour; 11/20/2015-11/22/2015 (Monforte, Serralunga, Barolo, Barbaresco): Das wird gross!

Viiiel komplexer, dichter, massiver als der parallel verkostete 07er. Ein deutlicher Schritt nach oben, der Wein vibriert! Fleischig, konzentriert, tolles Frucht/Säurespiel - ich muss die Kisten ganz nach hinten/unten schlichten (irgendwo zwischen den 10er Bordeaux verstecken)
  • EMAZurich commented:

    11/16/17, 10:55 AM - Ja, ich mag Silvanos Weine sehr. Ich könnte bei ihm immer "einmal alles" kaufen. Preis/Leistungssieger im Piemont und die Riservas könne gut und gern mit den grossen Namen mithalten, nur zum Bruchteil des Preises. Ich würde mal schauen ob Du die Weine nicht über einen Onlinehändler findest. Wo in Deutschland bist Du zu Hause? Schönen Abend & Prost! Edgar

Red
2010 Fattoria Galardi Terra di Lavoro Roccamonfina IGT Aglianico
8/11/2017 - EMAZurich Likes this wine:
98 points
Grosser Repekt vor diesem grossen Wein. Das können keine Menschen machen, das macht die Natur.
Kirscharomen, furchtbar grosse Nase zwischen dichter rotbeeriger Frucht und Raucharomen.
Grosse Mineralik, tolle Säure, dichte Frucht. Wie ein wirklich grosser Bordeaux mit süditalienischem Charakter...
  • EMAZurich commented:

    11/16/17, 10:53 AM - vielleicht liegt's an der Luft? Ich lasse die meisten Rotweine (auch sehr reife Weine) meistens offen über Nacht im kalten Keller stehen und geniesse sie dann am Folgetag, meist am Abend... dann sind sie gross! Das Konzept geht mit Nebbiolos aber auch mit dichten, strukturierten Aglianicos gut auf. Der 10er TdL ist sicher noch gut verschlossen, den würde ich vor 2020 nicht anfassen...

Red
2004 Giuseppe E Figlio Mascarello Barolo Monprivato Nebbiolo
1/27/2017 - EMAZurich wrote:
91 points
Hmmm, seeeehr verhalten. Ich tippe auf geschlossene Gesellschaft, der Wein zeigt sich sehr geizig mit Reizen...
  • EMAZurich commented:

    11/16/17, 10:47 AM - Guten Abend, ich bin erstmal der Edgar, der ein "Du" und kein "Sie" ist... so vieles von Mascarello habe ich noch nicht gekostet - aber die paar, die ich verkosten durfte lebten immer erst in schöner Reife (15 Jahre plus) auf. Wird aber nie ein Showstopper oder ein dicker Brummer, schlägt sehr leise, elegante Töne an. Liebe Grüsse aus Zürich, Edgar

Red
2004 Bruno Giacosa Barbaresco Rabajà Nebbiolo
9/23/2017 - Nanda wrote:
95 points
Dinner with Friends (Brasserie Margeuax): Decanted for ~3.5 hours, back into the bottle and served a few hours later. Gorgeous nose is prototypical Nebbiolo -- black and red cherry, licorice, florals and just a hint of road tar. A palate like only Giacosa renders with that concentrated, dense fruit that is simply weightless. Softened by the air as the fruit and fine tannins are in harmony. Delicious, but quite young and primary. Upside from here as the best is yet to come.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    9/24/17, 10:21 AM - Hi there Nanda. If you like Giacosa Barbarescos try also Paitin. I had a match of Giacosa Rabaja vs. Paitin Vecchie Vigne, both 2004 vintage. For me Paitin made it clearly, for a friction of the price. If you can get hold of Paitin in US, try a bottle... cheers mate! Edgar

Red
2012 Vietti Langhe Nebbiolo Perbacco Langhe DOC
2/18/2017 - EMAZurich Likes this wine:
92 points
Nach dem Öffnen (und kellerkalt bei 11 Grad Keller) sehr verhaltene Nase, am Gaumen auch eher nichtssagend. Nach einer Stunde geht's los... tolle, explosive Nase nach Veilchen, Weichselkirsche und Marzipan.
Am Gaumen wunderbare Balance zwischen druckvoller, rotbeeriger Frucht, feinen aber sehr präsenten Tanninen und stützender Säure. Ein Gedicht von einem Wein! 91

Tag 2 - 1/3 der Flasche über Nacht verkorkt im Kühlschrank. Heute noch feingliedriger, in sich ruhend.
Der Gaumen wirkt dichter und das Finale erinnert eher an einen Barolo von besserer Güte als an einem einfachen Nebbiolo. Heute 92.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    2/19/17, 11:50 PM - Hi there Doug Fir,

    "Weichselkirsche" (=German) or simply "Weichsel" in Austria is "sour cherry". Same fruit as Cherry but less sweet with pale colour.

    "druckvoller" means more powerful or more pressure.

    Coming back to your question... yes, I think the Nebbiolo Perbacco is an outstanding value.

    Is has more from a Barolo charakter than from a Barbaresco, so I'd compare it with an entry level Barolo. Indeed, with current maturity stage I prefer the Nebbiolo Perbacco to the Barolo Castiglione, the entry level Barolo from Vietti. It Shows currently sweeter fruit, less tannins and acidity and hence is much more approachable (but has aging potential as well).

    If you consider that the price of Perbacco is half the price of Castiglione (from the Producer and also in Swiss retail) and the charackter is similar I'd opt for Perbacco if you want to drink it soon.

    On the long run this is likely to change, I prefer Baroli with 12+ years as they become smoother and more balanced then.

    Happy to share my experiences anytime, just shout...

    Cheers,
    Edgar

Red
2007 Conterno Fantino Barolo Sorì Ginestra Nebbiolo
1/7/2017 - repoper wrote:
95 points
Short decant before first glass. Nose is absolutely amazing. Bursting with dark fruits and really aramatic balsamic vinegar smells like a fine perfume. It still extremely dark and it just coats the entire glass as I swirl it. Wow. Still very primary at 10 years old but this is one fantastic wine that will develop into something very very special. It feel like thick paint in the mouth completely coating every pour. Tar, iron and blood orange peal, maybe some earth. Really interesting bit of sweetness on the finish. Still extremly tanic but not totally undrinkable. This is the first i've tried out of my case and I'm glad for the remaining 11. I would hold for a minimum of 5 more years, matbe 7-10. It has got me curious about the '04 & '06 of his which I havent even dared to look at. 95 today with upside.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    1/8/17, 12:33 AM - Hi Repoper, the 04s are currently around the same stage as the 07s, also given the similarities of vintage. If you have more try one, they are awesome! The 06s, coming from a very classic/cool vintage, do. show high acidity and sharp tannins which need still years to come together. Cheers, Edgar

Red
2011 Michele Satta Cavaliere Toscana IGT Sangiovese
10/18/2016 - EMAZurich Likes this wine:
94 points
Dunkles Rubin, schwarzer Kern und leichter Ziegelrand. Die Nase zeigt bereits Eleganz an, ist zwar von erdigen Tönen geprägt aber auch von reifer Frucht. Nichts schwächelt, nichts ist zu aufdringlich.
Am Gaumen breitschultrig wenn auch feingliedrig, seidene Textur, rote Fruchtstruktur mit reifen/erdigen Tönen - alles toll balanciert mit schönem Säurerückgrat und frischen aber feinen Tanninen. Einfach toll, kann die Reife kaum erwarten!
  • EMAZurich commented:

    10/19/16, 10:01 AM - Hi there Wine Strategies,

    I agree with you, he's a great producer. We discovered his wines last year during summer Holiday and visited the vinery this summer for the first time. I use to buy the major part of my cellar directly from the vinery to get to know the people.

    By the way, before the Cavaliere we had the GiovinRe 2014 (100% Viognier from Bolgheri) with the appetizers. Pears, raisins but without becoming sweet, walnut... even if I am not a big fan of Italian whites (except Arneis) this is a great white wine which matches perfectly with game-cold cuts. Try this if you can find!

    Kind regards from Zurich, Edgar

  • EMAZurich commented:

    10/19/16, 10:45 PM - Hi Tim,
    I envy you for wine travelling 3 months in a row. I will try to some of your recommendations.

    If you are 3 months in Italy you might consider to insert a brief jump to Austria. Southern Styria would be extremely close to the region of Friuli/Veneto. World class Sauvignon Blancs grow there (and also Chardonnays, which are called Morillon in Styria) and the 2015 vintage, which should be abvailable now, is extremely ripe and rich. If you are interested I can give you many contacts, also for other Austrian wineregions.

    Have fun on your wine-tour!
    Cheers, Edgar

Red
2009 Château Le Grand Verdus Grande Réserve Bordeaux Supérieur Red Bordeaux Blend
6/24/2016 - EMAZurich wrote:
90 points
Einmal eine erste Flasche kosten...
Ja, weder Nase noch Gaumen wirklich aufregend. Nullachtfünfzehnbordeaux, glatt, international - nicht schlecht aber nicht gut. Naja...
Ein veritabler Mitwochenwein aber für den Jahrgang enttäuschend. 89

Tag 2 - heute deutlich schöner. Schwarzbeerig, Teer, Lakritz mit schöner Mineralik und leichtem Honighauch im Finale. Heute 91, belassen wir das finale Voting im Moment bei 90...
  • EMAZurich commented:

    6/25/16, 11:20 PM - Yes, indeed, it was a first bottle to try how advanced the case is. I'll start to drink these by 2019 probably. Cheers, Edgar

Red
2000 Château Lagrange (St. Julien) Red Bordeaux Blend
3/6/2016 - Shoebox Likes this wine:
89 points
Archetypal medoc nose. Deep violet colour. Creamy with blackcurrants and sour cherries. Quite layered with savoury notes. Hint of violets.
At it's peak now. 2nd tasting of this recently.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    3/6/16, 9:12 PM - Hi there Shoebox, thanks for your note! Did you feel the wine evolved with air? Would you recommend decanting? Kind regards from Zurich, Edgar

Red
2006 Château Montrose St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
1/15/2016 - robertdtwo Likes this wine:
91 points
Two-hour Vinturi decant. Still tannic and a bit musty with tobacco and earthy notes most prominent. I've been waiting for years for bottle age to justify this purchase, but it's just not happening. HUGE DISAPPOINTMENT and since this was my first foray into this vineyard, I think I'm bailing...no thanks! When the threshold is a hundred bucks, expectations are high. Goodbye!
  • EMAZurich commented:

    1/15/16, 11:58 PM - In my opinion this wine is far from being ready. 10 years from now and you can start to try. Montrose mid 90s are drinking well now. Kind regards from Zurich, Edgar

Red
2010 Giacomo Conterno Barbera d'Alba Cascina Francia
3/27/2015 - Champagneinhand Likes this wine:
91 points
Fun wine that I opened to accompany pizza and some other snacks for the second night f the sweet 16 Friday edition. Sweet florals emerge from the glass after letting sit for a half and hour. Swirling brings up the red fruit, soil, a touch of provencal herbs, and some green notes but the red fruit is very ripe. a touch of the higher abv, but nice nose. On the palate it is red cherries, red currants, spicy acidity with a touch of baking spices from a touch of oak, which, I should say, were still in my bottle which I decanted and, was surprised to see oak pieces, about 2-3cm in length, and very unpleasant to see come out in a plop into the decanter. I actually had to pour into a second decanter as these were big scraps of long but thin oak. They did leave a nice vanilla smell with the red berries, but if this fell into your glass you would be pretty upset. I was very surprised, not knowing if this was the bottom of the barrel or pieces in stainless. Either way it actually improves the nose and palate, just watch out when decanting.

Overall this was very pleasant with the spice and berries. I don't see this going many places other than where this is now. It should hold a while but I wouldn't hold past 2019. Enjoyed. Great CT secret sant gift from 2013.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    8/22/15, 8:08 AM - Hi there Champagneinhand,
    Well, I agree that this wine is very good today but if you have some more I'd reccomend to hold one bottle for several years... You might be surprised about the potential of high level Barberas.
    I had some aged Barberas like Bricco dell'Uccellone or Bricco della Bigotta (Braida) and I would consider the Cascina Francia from Conterno to be on a similar level.

    15+ years contribute very well to the development of these wines... Try it!

    Kind regards from Zurich, Edgar

  • EMAZurich commented:

    8/22/15, 11:35 PM - Bricco dell'Uccellone 1990 was one of the best wines I ever tasted. My last bottle we had more or less one year ago.
    The character of Barbera changes then also and it's quite similar to aged Barolo - it's the terroir coming out more and more.
    I don't think that many Barberas will have the potential to go on the long haul like this but I consider Cascina Francia from GC to be one of them.

    I'll save one of mine, together with one Bricco dell'Uccellone and a Barbera from Mascarello (all from the outstanding vintage 2010) for a tasing around 2025/2030...

    Cheers, Edgar

Red
2002 Château Phélan Ségur St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
3/7/2015 - EMAZurich wrote:
90 points
Kühle Johannisbeernase, scho n hier schlägt das Schlanke des Jahres durch... Am Gaumen kühl und schlank, mineralisch und schwarzbeerig mit zartbitterem Lakritz im Finale. Ein schöner, klassischer Bordeaux aber für das Außergewöhnliche fehlt hier doch Einiges.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    8/15/15, 12:13 AM - Hallo Nubian,
    Nun, ich denke, das hängt ganz von der persönlichen Vorliebe ab wie "reif" man Bordeaux mag. Der Wein ist sicherlich offen und trinkfertig, also aus der verschlossenen Phase heraus. Jetzt ist auch noch Frucht da, die immer mehr durch erdige Töne ersetzt wird. Wenn Du vom Wein nach einigen Tagen an der Luft beeindruckt warst ist das ein Zeichen, dass Dir der Wein mit etwas mehr Reife besser gefällt, also mit weiteren Flaschen etwas warten.

    Hope this helps, Prost!
    Edgar

  • EMAZurich commented:

    8/16/15, 8:56 PM - Hallo Rainer,
    Ja, voll und ganz Deiner Meinung. Für mich ist Phelan Segur einer der besten Weine, vor allem extrem viel Wein fürs Geld. Auch sehr verlässlich, beweist sich auch in schwierigen Jahren (siehe 2002) immer wieder.
    Bei 2005 würde ich aufpassen, da kommt es auf Deinen Keller an. Meine sind noch nicht trinkfertig aber die liegen auch bei 11 Grad... Da brauchen die Dinger etwas länger...
    Sonst einfach mal eine Flasche aufmachen, sollte mit etwas Dekantierzeit sicherlich gut zu trinken sein.
    Liebe Grüsse, Edgar

Red
1994 Château Montrose St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
4/25/2015 - Zweder wrote:
94 points
This is another note of the same wine on the same day. The story is that we got both wine completely blind, not even knowing it was a Bordeaux. The first glass (which is my other tasting note) came from a 0.75 bottle and this note is from the wine that came from magnum. And no one of the six tasters recognized these two wines as being the same wine. The wine from magnum showed a beautiful and smoky bouquet with dark forest fruits and beautiful luxurious oak as well as a pleasant touch of barnyard. On the palate cassis, luxurious oak, a touch of pleasant sweetness, some good chocolate, beautifully fresh acidity and soft tannin. Also this wine from magnum is fully mature, but showed just a bit more freshness and a longer future ahead. We thanked our host for pouring those two mature bottles completely blind to experience the difference because of the bottle size. This magnum wine scored one point more.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    7/4/15, 5:45 AM - Hi there Zweder, do you know if the win was decanted? What would you recommend? Thanks for your feedback, kind regards from Zurich! Edgar

  • EMAZurich commented:

    7/4/15, 7:44 PM - Many thanks for your feedback, very helpful! Edgar

Red
1973 Château Mouton Rothschild Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
9/16/2014 - EMAZurich wrote:
93 points
Transparentes Ziegelrot, orange gegen den Rand, breiter Wasserrand.

Nase nach... nach... whooooow, da kommt eine Aromenvielfalt, nicht aufdringlich sonder eher zart angedeutet, aber so viel wie ich es noch bei keinem Wein erlebt habe. Gewürze, Leder, erdige Aromen, Pilze, doch Frucht aber gedörrt, trotzdem nicht eingedickt süss... eher fein und elegant, sooo feingliedrig.

Am Gaumen kein aufdringlicher, arroganter Superstar, eher ein introvertierter und schüchterner Denker, ein tiefsinniger Zeitgenosse. Die Aromenvielfalt präsentiert sich wieder mit einem leicht süsslichem Finale.

Ein toller Wein der eher kurz endet, aber dieses kurze Ende bleibt irgendwie trotzdem lange haften... ein toller Wein, der vor allem durch seine Feinheit und Eleganz beeindruckt. Es ist wie... wie wenn man einen noch so tollen Designeranzug aus feinstem Hause mit Handwerkskunst eines erfahrenen Herrenschneiders alter Schule vergleicht - das kann dann doch um einiges mehr! Bin schwer beeindruckt!

Der Wein hält sich unbeeindruckt für ca. eine Stunde, dann beginnt sich das Aromenspiel Richting Säure zu verabschieden, aber gaaaaaanz
langsam... sagen wir mit der Abgeklärtheit und Ruhe eines alten aber über allen Dingen stehenden Weisen.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    7/4/15, 1:23 PM - Well, you find me embarassed... A autentic expession of my thoughts in English... Thanks HowardTheDuck! Kind regard from Zurich, Edgar

White
2008 Domaine William Fèvre Chablis Grand Cru Bougros Côte Bouguerots Chardonnay
7/3/2015 - rosenst1 wrote:
92 points
PnP. Perfect cork. Light straw color; immediate nose of chalk, sea air, limestone and citrus. On the palate this has an intense minteral taste with very bracing acidity. With air it develops a silky quality on the mid-palate and the acidity recedes somewhat. Still a baby and more classic than some other vintages of this bottling which sometimes has a more exotic character. This went beautifully with some grilled local halibut.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    7/4/15, 5:51 AM - Hi Rosenst1, thanks for your helpful note! What would you recommend in terms of decanting? Did you see improvement/change over the time you consumed the bottle? Thanks and kind regards from Zurich, Edgar

  • EMAZurich commented:

    7/4/15, 11:13 AM - Many thanks for your suggestion! I'm quite new to Burgudy whites (since my youth I was rather focused on Austria for whites). Hence I'm doing my first steps and will try one of these in my cellar with a decant. Have a great weekend with great wines! Edgar

Red
2006 Château Léoville Barton St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend
2/21/2015 - DeGuoRen wrote:
89 points
Typical cabernet nose, slightly alcoholic. Mouth: After pop and pour tannic, quite acid, slightly watery and nothing going on. After 6 hours in the decanter much better, more dark cabernet aromas with fine tannin and balancing acid. After two days in the open bottle and decant for another hour the remaining half bottle, everything quite balanced. Rather cold style, at the moment still to young, will open the next bottle in some years.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    6/24/15, 9:04 PM - Agree... I think 06 is quite similar to 96 (the Leo Barton 96 is still not really ready BTW).
    I drink the simpler reds of this vintage but Leos or Montrose will remain several years in my cellar before being touched.
    Thanks for this interesting review, 6 hours decant, two days in the bottle and another hour of decant shows the material this wine is made of... Cheers, Edgar

Red
1999 Domaine de la Romanée-Conti Vosne-Romanée 1er Cru Cuvée Duvault-Blochet Pinot Noir
4/1/2014 - ubercuvee wrote:
Very Fine, but I struggle to see that the new found price tag of $400-500/bt makes any sense here. Just lacks the precision and drive that you hope for at that price point. I couldn't find much of the classic DRC notes I look for in bottling like La Tache (wild strawberries, etc). I'd suggest Rousseau's CSJ or Mugnier's Amoureuses are probably a better bet if you want a 'luxe' 1er from a great maker.
The occasion however was lovely: the now mrs ubercuvee said "yes"....
  • EMAZurich commented:

    6/4/15, 8:23 AM - Hi there Alex, that's wonderful news!!!!

    Best wishes to you and Mrs. Ubercuvee!

    Kind regards from Zurich,
    Edgar

    PS: also I would marry you with your cellar BTW

Red
2010 Paitin di Pasquero-Elia Barbaresco Sorì Paitin Nebbiolo
1/5/2015 - la turque wrote:
88 points
Given the earlier notes, opened and decanted this well in advance, thinking that the large amount of air would coax out the fruit. Not so. The wine is light in colour, medium bodied at best. A nose of tar and some red fruits, but on the palate green and lean. I've read the comments about Wine Access recommendations, but also am aware that Tanzer, whose palate I trust, gave this wine 93 points a year ago. What am I missing? Dumb phase? Is the fruit there? Or did they just get it awfully wrong? Very disappointing bottle.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    1/6/15, 6:17 AM - Hi there La Turque!
    I think the wine is simply closed down (or better, it might be still in it's fruit period but the decant closed it).

    According my experience with Barbarescos (or anyway generally with red wines) is that young fruitful wines need to be drank immediately as the air accellerates the develpoment and closes the wine down.

    Barbarescos (and Barolos) need a lot of air to open up and I do open them generally one day before I drink them but - depending on the vintage - starting with age 8+. Especially the 2010s have a high acidity/tannin-structure so there is low fun level when they are young.

    Kind regards from Zurich, Edgar

  • EMAZurich commented:

    1/6/15, 7:36 AM - Let me know when you are around and I'll organize something...

Red
2007 Vietti Barolo Lazzarito Nebbiolo
10/23/2014 - KPB wrote:
89 points
Disappointing. Although appealing on the nose, with sweet fruit, the body is thin and finishes on harsh tannins. Overrated, and overpriced... In its favor, the wine was much better after three days under nitrogen in my countertop unit. But that's a long time for a decant, and even in the better mood, I still don't see where the stellar scores (94+ IWC) came from. Maybe deserved 90 on the last glass...
  • EMAZurich commented:

    10/23/14, 8:52 PM - I think this is just sleeping well, the character you describe is exactly a closed down Barolo, which usually does not reveil anything but acidity and harsh tannins. If you have other bottles just wait (Baroli use to open up lovely around the age of 12). Best regards from Zurich, Edgar

Red
2008 Silvano Bolmida Barolo Riserva Bussia Nebbiolo
9/26/2014 - yofog wrote:
65 day maceration, 4 1/2 years in barrel. More of that piney quality, and plenty of oak...but it works, it's a part of the whole. The nose on this is incredible. Steamed edamame? I don't know, but I like it.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    9/27/14, 11:24 AM - Hi there Yofog,

    You mentioned the nose of Silvanos wines which always is incredible...

    Well, we know Silvano now for 10 years more or less and we visit his vinery almost once a year. He became something similar to a friend during all these years.

    What I can tell you about his wines and their aging potential is that the wines never are or will become blockbusters, they are very burgundian in terms of body and extraction. But the nose is incredible and nothing compares to them. With some more years of aging this nose becomes even more intensive and develops a character which is unique in Piemonte.

    So, if you have the chance to buy some of these I would reccomend to do so, leave them alone somewhere in your cellar for 5-8 years and you won't regret!

    Kind regards from Zurich, Edgar

    PS: try also the Barbera, it is on Piemont's top level and a steal!

Red
2011 Azelia Dolcetto d'Alba Bricco dell'Oriolo
9/13/2014 - NostraBacchus Likes this wine:
87 points
Unfortunately my last bottle. Pretty dark ruby/purple color. Perfumed nose of sweet strawberries and red cherries, cinnamon and some flowers as well as some earthy notes. On the palate there are similar notes. Medium-bodied with almost medium acidity and low-medium tannin. Good finish. This is a very juicy, uncomplicated Dolcetto but full of fruit and varietal character. I really like it.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    9/13/14, 2:13 PM - Hoi Nostrabacchus, wenn das Deine letzte Flasche war und Du den Wein gerne hast kann ich aushelfen - ich hab' noch drei im Keller und die würden irgendwann ihr Ende in einer Sosse finden... Ich mag' den Wein so ganz und gar nicht! Lass mich dich wissen wann/wo wir uns kurz treffen können, ich hab' die drei Flaschen dann mit. (Ich wohne in Uetikon am See und arbeite am Bellevue, wären schon mal zwei guten Anhaltspunkte für ein Treffen). Schönen Abend, Edgar

  • EMAZurich commented:

    9/14/14, 9:17 AM - edgar_magyar@hotmail.com oder edgar.magyar@publicis.ch

    Freu' mich von Dir zu hören, schönen Sonntagabend!
    Edgar

Red
2007 Vietti Barolo Castiglione Nebbiolo
8/24/2014 - Bradetti wrote:
88 points
Had this wine w/o food. Needed some hours to show bouquet of red berries, especially sour cherry at the first evening and sweet cherry at the second one. But on the palate it could not keep the nice level. Very dry which absorbed most of the other tastes. On the first evening it was ok, but on the second it was not nice. In general I am disappointed a bit about this wine.
Lately I had the same vintage Barbera "Cascina Francia" from G. Conterno. In terms of complexity, depth and soft tannins this was several levels above Vietti´s Castiglione.
Maybe that Barolo needs much more time to soften... I hope the other Barolos in my cellar will be better. This one here was my second Barolo.
  • EMAZurich commented:

    8/25/14, 7:19 AM - Dear Bradetti,
    I experienced that most of the Barolos open up in age 10-12.
    It might be the case here as "very dry palate", perhaps combined with high acid level, indicates somehow that this Barolo-baby is sleeping well.

    I remember the 2007 Castiglione as very fruity, sweet but balanced, delicious wine during it's fruit-period when it was botteled. I'll give mine a try in 2020...

    Cheers from Zurich! Edgar

Red
2002 Weingut Josef Pöckl Admiral Neusiedlersee Red Blend
7/26/2014 - EMAZurich Likes this wine:
92 points
Eine ganz besondere Flasche, da wir sie zu unserer Hochzeit im 2004 von Familie Pöckl geschenkt und signiert bekommen haben. Nun feiern wir den 10. Hochzeitstag und haben das Geschenk geöffnet...

Sehr dunkle Farbe, schwarzer Kern mit ziegelrotem Rand. Tolle schwarzbeerige Nase, tief & streng, Gewürze nach Salbei, Rosmarin. An Gaumen noch immer sehr adstringierend, feste Säure und Frucht nach schwarzen Beeren. Teer, Lakritz...

Nach ca. einer halben Stunde wird der Wein runder, es kommt eine tolle Restsüsse hinzu. Tolles, langes Finale...

Der Wein scheint immer noch zu jung, ich werde Admiral ab nun generell erst ab Alter 12 kosten...

Tag 2 - der Wein macht nach 24 Stunden an der Luft keinen Wank, etwas runder und noch mehr Restsüsse nach Röstaromen und Karamell präsent. Weiterentwicklung ist garantiert!
  • EMAZurich commented:

    7/28/14, 11:16 PM - Hoi Stefan, danke für den Kommentar, Admiral beatätigt sich also als der Burgenländische La Tour... hast Du auch Erfahrungen mit Rosso e Nero und Reve de Jeunesse gemacht?

  • EMAZurich commented:

    7/29/14, 11:23 AM - Na da sollten wir doch mal gemeinsam anstossen... Bin im Moment in der Toscana aber ab kommender Woche wieder unter edgar_magyar@hotmail.com erreichbar. Liebe Grüsse & schönen Abend!

1 - 50 of 51
More results
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close