Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(28 comments on 25 notes)

1 - 25 of 25 Sort order
Red
2013 Virage Vineyards Cabernet Franc Barrel Select Napa Valley
4/14/2024 - Rbhan12 Likes this wine:
92 points
This is 100% single barrel Cabernet Franc from one block in Rutherford. Labeled as 13.9 ABV. Decanted for 2h and back to bottle.

IMO there is too much oak on this wine. It still drinks quite young, so maybe that will recede and integrate better with time. There is nice freshness and acidity here with that hint of Rutherford dust on the tannins. I saved half the bottle for tonight and will follow up.

At least from Day 1, I feel confident putting this away for another 10 years.

Day 2: Nose is much more typical of CF. Nice complexity of dusty earth, fresh tobacco, red currants. Palate shows more of a "cool streak" to the red fruit, a typical freshness I associate with CF. Still has proper red fruit underneath.

Overall, the first day was more true to Rutherford and an oakier style, whereas the second day was more refined and more CF-like for me. For my last bottle I will be decanting for 1-2h then back to bottle for 24h. 92-93+
  • Maphill01 commented:

    4/15/24, 9:51 PM - Thanks for taking one for the team to get a look at this wine. For what it’s worth, Emily states in her tasting note that this is a long term ager- so 5+ years of positive development seem likely.

White
2021 Rivers-Marie Chardonnay B. Thieriot Vineyard Sonoma Coast
2023 Napa; 2/5/2023-2/9/2023 (Napa with a connection in Houston): 2021 Theriot- from a non-Chardonnay aficionado who leans towards Chablis this actually pleased my palate. More ‘sophisticated’ on the palate than the Sonoma Coast, I found this quite good, a bit more texture and glycerin feel, more lemon curd, slightly less crisp. Buoyed my decision to buy RM Chardonnay at release for first time ever.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    2/10/24, 3:01 PM - Your note inspired me to do the same thing, and I came to the same conclusion!

White
2021 Goodfellow Family Cellars Blanc Whistling Ridge Vineyard Ribbon Ridge White Blend
54/20/20/6…Riesling/Pinot Noir/Pinot Blanc/Gewurtztraminer. Nicely aromatic, lychee, citrus fruit. Same on the palate, lean body, sweet and tart, along with a nice vinous character, I assume from the pinot noir. ~12%abv, crushable in the best way.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    12/24/23, 5:19 PM - Both interesting and easy to drink…the crack indeed! Glad to have a few more of these.

Red
2016 Franny Beck Pinot Noir La Chenaie Vineyard Eola - Amity Hills
7/31/2023 - Maphill01 wrote:
flawed
Another flawed bottle. This one suffered from excess VA. Shame because there seemed to be some nice fruit underneath. But it was enough to be distracting, in a negative way, so down the drain.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    8/1/23, 10:40 AM - Michael, I will contact you, thanks for the offer. For the record, these two bottles aside, I have enjoyed all the other Franny Beck wines I've tried.

    Darius, I opened a 2017 Chenaie back in April that showed nicely (you can see my note on CT)

Red
2016 Château Lilian Ladouys St. Estèphe Red Bordeaux Blend
6/26/2023 - Maphill01 wrote:
PNP. Plum and meaty notes on the nose, almost like a Syrah. More typical palate, blackberry, black cherry. Dark chocolate on the finish. A bit of a dancing bear, dark and brambly, yet medium bodied, with nice acidity. Approachable and interesting now, with stuffing and structure for another 3-5 years of development. At this price I may go back for more bottles to track its progress.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    7/14/23, 2:24 PM - I've been stocking up on '16s and this is a lot of wine for the price. I'd be happy to have a case or two. Cheers!

Red
2016 Château Grand-Puy-Lacoste Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
10/28/2022 - Maphill01 wrote:
Has the stuffing to get much better with time. But today, so primary, lacking complexity. Revisit in 2025+
  • Maphill01 commented:

    10/28/22, 9:41 PM - Haha, very true, more like 2035 for proper drinking. I enjoyed a 2000 last year that still had room to develop. I have a bunch of the 2016s, so I guess it was more of a note to self to check on its progress. Cheers!

Red
2008 Château Haut-Bailly Pessac-Léognan Red Bordeaux Blend
7/25/2022 - Maphill01 wrote:
Splash decant, no sediment to speak of. Leather and cassis on the nose. Same on the palate, plus graphite. Some bitter tannins on the long finish.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    7/27/22, 8:35 AM - I think you are right. I like to pop and pour to follow the evolution, but I usually drink Bordeaux at 20+ yrs. I wanted to check in on this, and a short decant probably would have got me to the sweet spot sooner.

Red
2018 Carlisle Syrah Sonoma County
3/19/2022 - Maphill01 wrote:
PNP. blackberry, blueberry pepper. Ripe fruit, full bodied, with fresh acidity and a bit of tannin providing balance. Straightforward, enjoyable Syrah.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    3/19/22, 5:57 PM - Thanks for the catch! Sloppy translation of a few different wines. Fixed the note.

White
2020 Rivers-Marie Chardonnay Sonoma Coast
2/11/2022 - Maphill01 wrote:
PNP. Pale straw color. Nice citrus. Touch of light oak. Creamy mouthfeel, yeasty on the back end. More full bodied, 14.5% ABV. Straightforward, but nicely done, entry level Sonoma chard.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    2/11/22, 4:06 PM - You know, as I was writing the note, I had a feeling I was going to misread the oak treatment! I've been on an Oregon chard kick recently, and I think that threw off my palate. Thanks for the info, cheers!

Red
2015 Daou Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Estate Cabernet "Soul of a Lion" Paso Robles Adelaida District
6/27/2021 - Maphill01 wrote:
Plum, blueberry, blackberry and oak. Ripe fruit, slightly drying tannins. Not the best value, but this is well made in the modern style.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    6/29/21, 9:49 PM - This was an impulse purchase at the winery. I had been a fan of Daou’s entry level wines, but not as much recently. I held onto this for three years, afraid it would be an ooze monster, but was pleasantly surprised. It was ripe for sure, but the fruit was focused, and everything was in balance. I have a couple more and am thinking in five and ten more years, just to see how this style ages.

White - Sparkling
N.V. Billecart-Salmon Champagne Brut Réserve Champagne Blend
6/25/2021 - Maphill01 wrote:
Out of 375. Toast, brioche, citrus and apple underneath. More of a full, creamy mouthfeel, medium weight. Decent acidity keeps this from being too heavy. Benefited from a little air. A bit more going on than your average entry level champagne.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    6/25/21, 11:42 PM - I’ve mostly had the NV rose, but this got a thumbs up from both me and the wife!

Red
2016 Beckmen Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Santa Ynez Valley
6/17/2021 - Maphill01 wrote:
Splash decanted for an hour. Aromatic nose of blueberry and raspberry. On the palate, cherry, cassis and vanilla. Crowd pleasing style.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    6/21/21, 5:38 PM - Cheers! I enjoyed this over several nights. Given the bigger style, I preferred this one glass at a time. Flavorful and fun.

Red
1996 Château Rauzan-Ségla Margaux Red Bordeaux Blend
4/9/2021 - Maphill01 wrote:
PNP followed over the night. This was delightful for the first five hours, elegant body, with lovely floral notes and red and black fruit, fresh and soft tannins. Wet earth and truffles. After 4-5 hours the fruit faded and this became more austere. Bottle was from auction. Update: came back into balance at the end of the night, interesting to see the evolution, overall a classic Margaux.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    6/9/21, 5:33 PM - That was an error, thanks for pointing that out!

Red
2012 Scarecrow Cabernet Sauvignon Monsieur Étain Rutherford
PNP, best after a few hours. Black cherry and plum. Cocoa, vanilla, graphite. Long finish of dark chocolate. Nice balance of powerful dark fruit and Rutherford dust. Open for business, a great modern Napa cab.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    5/6/21, 6:42 AM - I would recommend you decant for the best showing. I like to pop and pour to see how the wine evolves over an evening, and this was lovely from the beginning, but it hit another gear after some time to open up. Cheers!

  • Maphill01 commented:

    5/6/21, 7:31 AM - Have no fear, this will go 5+ years easy with proper storage (cool, dark place, ideally sub 65 degrees)

  • Maphill01 commented:

    5/10/21, 5:05 PM - I think 90 minutes would do the trick. Cheers!

Red
2004 Patricia Green Cellars Pinot Noir Balcombe Vineyard Dundee Hills
2/26/2021 - Maphill01 wrote:
Decanted 1 hour, fair bit of sediment. Cloudy brick color. Sappy red fruit, raspberry, strawberry. Some cola, baking spice and earthy notes. I did get the same effervescence mentioned below, but it blew off after an hour. Nicely aged classic Pinot.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    3/1/21, 6:43 PM - Yes, this was from the library release, so good provenance. I will say I’ve bought aged PGC from other sources and found them to be pretty robust, even one that had clear signs of seepage (to be clear that one was NOT from the winery).

  • Maphill01 commented:

    3/1/21, 8:05 PM - Decanting definitely helped, and it was still going strong late in the evening. So no worries about the wine fading after opening. I bought a mixed case from the library release, looking forward to them. Cheers!

Red
2000 Vieux Château Certan Pomerol Red Bordeaux Blend
Decanted for sediment. Inky color. Lovely aromatics of plum and boysenberry. Rich forest floor and cocoa. Hint of menthol. Sensual, with perfect ripeness, still elegant and fresh. Sweet tannins on the long finish. In a perfect place of early maturity.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    12/31/20, 2:51 PM - The fruit was definitely still present, but it was at a point where the tertiary flavors could provide nuance and added complexity. The beginning of a long window, there is no rush, and many will no doubt even prefer additional time in bottle. I should add this was my first VCC, so your mileage may vary. Cheers!

Red
2005 Château Branaire-Ducru St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend
Decanted an hour. Inky. Nice aromatics, matching the palate. Cassis, blackberry, wet earth, tobacco. Sweet tannins, very slightly bitter, chewy. Medium+ body. Still mostly big dark fruit, nice acidity for lift. Delicious alone and with food.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    12/27/20, 8:32 PM - That would be fitting, since it was your earlier note that motivated me to open this one! Glad I’ve got a few more. Cheers!

Red
2015 Briceland Vineyards Pinot Noir Ronda's Vineyard Humboldt County
PNP, started thin, but opened up after an hour in the glass. Classic old world Pinot profile. The pale magenta color belies the ripe, but focused fruit, along with some earthy soil. Cranberry, orange peel, strawberry. Nicely balanced with clean tannins and fresh acidic lift. Only 12.9% ABV. This was fun and interesting to drink, at a great price.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    12/16/20, 12:24 PM - I know, “ripe” is a risky term to use. That’s why I added “focused” and “classic old world Pinot”, but then it feels like I’m just filling out my tasting note bingo card. I can say this was flat out delicious! Cheers!

Red
2009 Château Bellevue St. Émilion Grand Cru Red Bordeaux Blend
10/30/2020 - Maphill01 wrote:
PNP. Nose of black cherry and plum. On the palate ripe black fruit and black currants. Notes of coffee and licorice. Smooth tannins, long slightly bitter finish. 90%+ merlot. 15% ABV.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    10/30/20, 8:07 PM - No I didn’t. Was nice out the gate, then tightened up a bit. Did you find it better upon opening, or with more air?

Red
2003 Château Léoville Poyferré St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend
Dark garnet color, beautiful nose of damp purple fruits... plum and cassis. Some dark cocoa and cedar. Lush and juicy, but not jammy or hot. Still some (fine) tannins, almost a bit dry, but subtle and integrated. Ready to go, but still early drinking window.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    8/17/20, 6:44 PM - Thanks...it was really good, glad I’ve got a couple more to follow. Cheers!

Red
2018 Bedrock Wine Co. Old Hill Ranch Heritage Sonoma Valley Red Blend
5/13/2020 - GrapeScott wrote:
93 points
Even while (slowly) pouring a glass with the Coravin, the seductive jammy aromas from this wine jumped out of the glass. Has the peppery, brambly aromas of zinfandel with pronounced minerality, and some floral and red fruit notes from whatever other 30 grapes are in the blend. Rich and complex, yet not a bruiser and surprisingly light on its feet, finishing with moderate silky tannins. Big peppery black raspberry fruit profile, accented by herbs and crushed rocks. A paradoxical wine that is both assertive and subtle, in your face and sneaky. As good a young zinfandel-based wine as I've ever had. This vineyard produces ageless wines, and I have one of Morgan's father's OH zins that is 20 years its senior. If I had a time machine I would try them both side-by-side today, and each at 20 years of age.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    6/18/20, 7:36 PM - Great note. I totally got the duality between big/complex, while still light/elegant. Cheers!

Red
2016 Produttori del Barbaresco Barbaresco Nebbiolo
5/16/2020 - jviz wrote:
91 points
Awesome nose, blasting with cherry and a little green tannin. Light in body and good now or in 10 years. Impressive
  • Maphill01 commented:

    6/14/20, 8:08 PM - This note convinced me to pop one - blasting with cherry indeed! Glad I have a few more to follow over time. Cheers!

Red
2014 Realm Cellars The Tempest Napa Valley Red Bordeaux Blend
PNP opaque color. Dark fruit, berries, cocoa and chocolate. Lush mouthfeel, slightly chewy tannins. Rich intense palate. Ready to go. Well made, modern style, for the hedonistic types.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    5/12/20, 11:12 PM - This would be great with a nice steak.

White - Off-dry
2001 Dönnhoff Norheimer Kirschheck Riesling Spätlese Nahe
Pale gold. Medium sweet. Citrus lemon. Peach and apple. Honey. Finish of minerals. A special zing I can’t place, this is my first aged Riesling, could this be the petrol I hear about? Delicious.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    3/13/20, 7:34 PM - Having another glass, great pairing with spicy Indian food. Delightful (again), but no obvious petrol.

Red
2011 Futo Oakville Red Bordeaux Blend
10/14/2019 - Maphill01 wrote:
Pnp, opened up after an hour. cassis on the nose. On the palate, Black fruit, oak, chocolate. Getting a bit of astringent or pepper at the end. Others mentioned Jalapeño, some combination of strong herbs and the alcohol. A tough year but this lacked focus and structure. I would not buy again at this price.
  • Maphill01 commented:

    10/15/19, 7:22 AM - To be fair, this continued to improve through the night, although it never fully came together. Could have been a bad bottle. Cheers!

1 - 25 of 25
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close