Important Update From the Founder Read message >

Comments on my notes

(210 comments on 162 notes)

1 - 50 of 162 Sort order
Red
1996 Château Léoville Las Cases St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend
4/26/2024 - dream Likes this wine:
96 points
A huge, extremely high-class wine with first-growth quality written all over it. Deep, dark and magisterial with a great sense of power and the finest silk woven into the texture. Easily the youngest wine on the table and not fully revealing itself until perhaps the last sip. Don’t drink this without at least a 6-hour decant but better to wait as this is an astounding vintage of LLC that should blossom over the next decade. 96+
  • FredericoWines commented:

    4/26/24, 7:26 AM - Thanks for the notes. Curious to know how an 6-hour long decant did to a 27-year old wine, even for this 2nd growth Bordeaux. Does it really need that?

  • FredericoWines commented:

    4/26/24, 8:39 AM - Zimmy, thx for sharing your experience. I had '96 Leoville Barton, Cos and Lynch Bages and found them very drinkable without or with 1-2 Hrs decant. Maybe LLC is on a different level. Will crack one of my only by yeat end to see.

  • FredericoWines commented:

    4/26/24, 5:49 PM - Looking forward to your notes, Zimmy

White
2021 Domaine Huet Vouvray Sec Le Mont Chenin Blanc
3/2/2024 - Andrew Vaughan Likes this wine:
93 points
Delightful on a sunny spring afternoon. Important to serve at proper temperature.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    3/22/24, 6:59 AM - What serving temperature would you suggest?

Red
2014 Château Grand-Puy-Lacoste Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
3/21/2024 - acidqueen wrote:
92 points
We decided to pull an early bottle of this since we have two cases. I rarely expect much from top level Bordeaux at 10 years and this was no different. Still, very enjoyable now and I expect the score to go up in the future. Decanted 90 minutes and drank with dinner. First whiff was decidedly oaky! This tempered over the decant but was still prominent. Good black fruit and cedar notes but clearly very young at this point. Good acid. Still very reticent. An interesting test, but not a wine I want to drink in less than 5 years and more likely 10 for my tastes. I want to see the oak integrate and the wine relax overall. I expect it will be much more enjoyable and I look forward to it.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    3/21/24, 4:56 PM - I had the same wine just last week and didn't find it too oaky but sweet vanilla that I liked.

Red
2016 Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon Estate St. Helena
3/17/2024 - randyjc wrote:
93 points
I expected greatness but got less. Beautiful appearance and nose and feels all lush and seductive in the mouth but at the end of the evening this was a date with an incredibly beautiful but uninteresting woman. There just seemed as if there should have been more of everything. Nice flavors though slightly muted. It did have some elegance, at least compared to most Napa cabernet. I’m glad I received this as a gift and didn’t pay the $200+ price for it. Definitely not worth that.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    3/18/24, 7:39 AM - Hope you'll change your view after a couple years, likely 3 or 4+ years. Cheers!

White - Off-dry
2015 Domaine Huet Vouvray Demi-Sec Clos du Bourg Chenin Blanc
3/12/2024 - drwine2001 wrote:
Deep yellow. Crystalline, clear, pure quince and honey. Off dry, rich, focused, and penetrating. Despite the color, nothing advanced about the palate. Classic Demi-Sec. Loved this bottle.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    3/13/24, 9:24 AM - Hi Dr. Wine, could you elaborate on "despite the color, nothing advanced about the palate"?

  • FredericoWines commented:

    3/13/24, 10:58 AM - Thanks. That means your palate is satisfied 😀

Red
2013 Antinori Tignanello Toscana IGT SuperTuscan Blend
3/12/2024 - papabluez wrote:
94 points
Thought this might have been flawed upon opening, even after 90 minute decant, so took to my local wineshop where awesome palates prevail. They said, perhaps imbalanced but nothing really wrong, so took home and double, triple, quadruple decanted for 3 more hours. Took to my blind tasting wine club, where it finished in the top 3 out of 12 super Tuscans!!
Folks these have to be heavily decanted.......even at 11 year old, and will obviously prevail years from now! Enjoy!!
  • FredericoWines commented:

    3/12/24, 3:34 PM - Hmm, your bottle was special. I had mine 3 years ago with an hour long decant and it sang

Red
2009 Marqués de Murrieta Rioja Castillo Ygay Gran Reserva Especial Tempranillo Blend, Tempranillo
3/10/2024 - edjBoca Does not like this wine:
80 points
Thin and dead on opening....did not improve.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    3/10/24, 5:42 PM - You might get a flawed bottle

White
2020 Dog Point Vineyard Section 94 Marlborough Sauvignon Blanc
One of the weirdest wines i have had. Taste like sweaty oily ferrymen where the wine trickles from the head, filters through the hair between the buttcheeks before being bottled. Smells like it taste. Disgusting
  • FredericoWines commented:

    2/18/24, 6:54 AM - Your bottle must be an outlier 🤔

White
2022 Greywacke Sauvignon Blanc Marlborough
1/15/2024 - cweiner Likes this wine:
90 points
Vintage erroneously entered as 2022. It is 2023.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    1/15/24, 8:13 AM - You may delete the note by Edit function and re-enter to the correct vintage

Red
2014 Penfolds Shiraz St. Henri South Australia
1/5/2024 - FredericoWines Likes this wine:
93 points
Opened this to pair with a reverse seared New York strip. Was afraid of opening it too early with less than 1 hour of decant, but I was wrong. I thoroughly enjoyed it over the hour and half at dinner. Rich and smooth with sweet tannins, which were not excessive nor bitter. Satisfying nose of red fruits and mocha. Thanks to the use of very old oak vats, it is not a tannic or jammy style typical of Australian shiraz.

No idea what the price is for current release, but I paid CAD 68 at Costco five years ago and still thought it was a good deal.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    1/7/24, 5:47 AM - Flat fingers lol. Now corrected. Thx

Red
2017 Black Hills Estate Nota Bene Okanagan Valley VQA Red Bordeaux Blend
12/29/2023 - rexmerlot wrote:
89 points
Clear dark purple in colour. Notes of cassis, licorice and black chocolate. Drank next to a 2003 and 2010, and found this bottle too young. Again nice acidity, tannins were a little rough in comparison to the other bottles. But i think that is just due to the age of wine. Put it aside to drink the next day.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    12/29/23, 2:28 PM - Looking forward to your notes

Red
2016 Produttori del Barbaresco Barbaresco Nebbiolo
12/1/2023 - Alexander Smith Likes this wine:
94 points
PnP this a wonderfully elegant and silky Produttori del Barbaresco, this shows how wonderful this vintage and producer are. I believe I purchased this for just under $50 cad. I realize drinking this bottle, that Nebbiolo is probably one of my favourite varietals, and I wish I drank more of them.

Pretty aromas of cherries, crushed roses, tar, smoke, volcanic ash, crushed stones and black tea. The palate is bight yet with succulent fruit and finely gravely stones, tea and pepper, the mid-palate has this wonderful floral and slight kirsch profile leading to a silky yet slightly electric finish.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    12/1/23, 5:42 PM - I have some '13 Riserva, are they ready?

  • FredericoWines commented:

    12/2/23, 2:49 PM - Thx for advices

White - Sparkling
N.V. Louis Roederer Champagne Brut Premier Champagne Blend
10/28/2023 - sirpat00 wrote:
89 points
Maturing profile showing some age. Pear fruit, smoke as well as autolytic and nutty notes. Latter more prevalent on the palate. Still drinks nicely but judging from this badge it would appear 5-8 years drinking window if you want to catch this in its prime.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    11/10/23, 9:56 AM - Do you know the harvest year and disgorgement date of your bottle?

White - Sparkling
N.V. Louis Roederer Champagne Brut Premier Champagne Blend
10/9/2023 - Purple Tooth wrote:
93 points
Italy pains me to see this blend being discontinued. This was always an aged champagne lovers NV, with lots of bruised red apples and beautiful yeasted nuts and zip. I loved drinking this from a Burgundy glass because the aroma is so attractively champagne. If you are holding on to a few of these relics as I am, I would not hold them too long. This one showed a bit of tilting...DRINK
  • FredericoWines commented:

    10/12/23, 11:57 AM - Any info on base wine and disgorgement date of the bottle that you drank?

White - Sparkling
N.V. André Clouet Champagne Un jour de 1911... Pinot Noir
10/1/2023 - aquacongas Likes this wine:
93 points
not blind, base 2008
Today a bit more aged than usually. Still fresh and not over his peak but I expected a touch fresher. 93
  • FredericoWines commented:

    10/2/23, 5:43 AM - Thanks for the notes. How did you tell the base wine vintage? The booklet that comes with my bottle only says it was disgorged on Aug 30, 2022

  • FredericoWines commented:

    10/3/23, 6:20 AM - My booklet doesn't say that but listed notes from 3 people. Are you one of them? Richard Juhlin, Jose Polo and Raffaele Alajmo. However, there is no mention of what base wine was used in my bottle

Red
2013 Fontodi Flaccianello della Pieve Colli della Toscana Centrale IGT Sangiovese
8/25/2023 - HalaniMD Likes this wine:
96 points
100% sangiovese (don't know why I thought this was a super tuscan). The color was dark ruby. On the nose, the first notes I got were dark fruits and cinnamon. On the palate, plenty of fruit again dark and hints of clove and tar. The tannins were well-integrated with a really long finish. Drank the entire bottle. Would buy again in a heartbeat. Wish I had bought several bottles to taste over time.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    8/25/23, 11:25 AM - Prior to 1996, Chianti wines were not permitted to be 100% Sangiovese. Flaccianello was introduced before that year and could only used IGT designation. As it enjoyed such rave reviews since launch, they don't bother to re-label it as Chianti, which is now perceived as inferior to Super Tuscans.

White - Sparkling
2018 Laherte Frères Champagne Extra Brut Les Vignes d’Autrefois Pinot Meunier
5/17/2023 - adnorthup wrote:
really spicy Meunier notes. Has that nice ripe apple, but the spice is the leading flavor. It takes an hour, but the vibrancy starts to melt into the fruit, giving it a nice balance. It’s still a little tough around the edges at this youthful stage, but showing promise.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    5/18/23, 5:55 AM - How long bottle cellaring do you think it's ready?

  • FredericoWines commented:

    5/18/23, 7:21 AM - Thx

White - Sparkling
2018 Laherte Frères Champagne Extra Brut Les Vignes d’Autrefois Pinot Meunier
5/7/2023 - Dukes88 Likes this wine:
94 points
Amazing!!! I am not the best for TN on champagne but that showed very well! Brioche note, fine bubble, balanced acidity. @ 120 cad that feels like a steal.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    5/17/23, 7:56 PM - Glad I just read your notes after I picked up two bottles which were on sale for CAD89 each

White
2020 El Enemigo Chardonnay Mendoza
5/3/2023 - melvinyeowq wrote:
86 points
S$100-$150 open theme: The person who brought this sneakily poured this into a Bordeaux bottle, leading everyone to guess a Bordeaux white. Was quite certain this was a new-world though, except I didn’t have a clue what or where - not surprised on revealing, since I have literally zero South American wines. Non-existent acidity, tropical grapefruit notes with greenness. Pass.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    5/4/23, 8:14 AM - Hmm, your notes are completely different from mine when I had it last month. It was good enough that I bought more bottles since then.

Red
2013 Antinori Tignanello Toscana IGT SuperTuscan Blend
Disappointing. Drab, lacking fruit and structure, worse with extended decanting. Presumably past its prime.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    5/1/23, 11:06 AM - It's only 10 years old (young) and it already passed its prime?

  • FredericoWines commented:

    5/1/23, 1:59 PM - Exactly Randy. As for QPR, I paid '13, '15 & "16 for $100 Cdn ($80 USD) a bottle. I consider it being acceptable

Red
2021 Coudert Fleurie Clos de la Roilette Cuvée Tardive Gamay
4/30/2023 - David_K wrote:
89 points
Very good in this challenging vintage. But also light in structure and probably won't make old bones.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    4/30/23, 4:03 PM - I have different prospective on 2021. I thought it's less ripe than 2020 &2019 and returns to more elegant style with lighter body and less alcohol, which a Beaujolais should be

Red
2016 Bosquet des Papes Châteauneuf-du-Pape Chante Le Merle Vieilles Vignes Red Rhone Blend
4/29/2023 - WineDuq Does not like this wine:
88 points
Alcohol and stewed/baked fruit on the nose. No freshness. 2015 was the same. Shows all of its 15.5% alcohol. Ripe fruit sweetness, but the alcohol dominates and the baked notes not to my taste. Seems like a relic from the Parkerized wines of the early 2000s. Pass on this producer in the future.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    4/30/23, 6:58 AM - I had '15 and find similar experience but not as bad as you did. I still considered it a well made wine but may need a few more years in bottle. Here's my notes back in Jun 2020:

    "Decanted for one hour. Strawberry and cherry nose. Surprised that it was light body and light/bright ruby color. If I tasted it blinded I'd say it's a Burgundian style Pinot Noir. But the 15.5% ABV showed its heat. Although a light and elegant style, I still felt the tannins were unsettled. Would it be better with one or two more hours of decant or one to two years of cellaring? I don't know and I will not know as it's my only bottle. Look forward to my another bottle of '16 in 3-5 years though."

    I have 3 '16s and will open one to see.

Red
2016 Château de Saint Cosme Gigondas Red Rhone Blend
3/29/2023 - Montesquieu wrote:
flawed
Both bottles tasted at Aureole were strangely effervescent, unlike the many other vintages I've enjoyed of this wine. That distracted and disappointed me from the rest of the experience, as I'm not a big fan of effervescence in red wines. I had originally rated this in the 80s, but I'll give the bottles benefit of the doubt and change that to "Flawed". This is otherwise one of my and my wife's favorite wines.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    3/29/23, 7:21 AM - Possibly an off bottle. Sorry.

White - Sparkling
N.V. Collard-Picard Champagne Cuvée Prestige Brut Champagne Blend
11/9/2019 - Papies wrote:
91 points
29 July 2019 Disgorged, No Malolactic and bottled at Extra Brut Dosage.
Quite the solid offering here and a very nice to cross paths with grower champagnes like this. Extra brut but quite round and with a nice rich profile. Less of a yeasty champagne more of a riper fruit , less sharp more giving. Very good 91
  • FredericoWines commented:

    3/26/23, 3:02 PM - Came across your old post after picking up two bottles. Wondering how you could tell the disgorgement date from the black label. Mine has this coding: L1702221184

White - Sparkling
N.V. Collard-Picard Champagne Cuvée Prestige Brut Champagne Blend
5/1/2022 - Papies wrote:
90 points
20 April 2020Disgorged, No Malolactic and bottled at Extra Brut Dosage of 4g/l.
Very much apple driven on the nose, soft rich feel, less of a toasty edge. Well made wine but was a bit not together. 89-90
  • FredericoWines commented:

    3/24/23, 9:20 PM - I picked up two bottles today. Courious how you could tell the date of disgorgement from label. Mine has this coding: L1702221184

Red
2021 Marcel Lapierre Morgon Gamay
1/30/2023 - Rbhan12 Likes this wine:
90 points
PnP, put on ice bath and followed for a few hours.

Nose was initially explosive with tart pomegranate and funky underripe strawberry but has taken a more true strawberry and mineral tone. Palate has crunchy acidity with true strawberry, lots of minerals, violets. Medium light body and very gulpable. Finish is a bit short but shows the same berries albeit at a slightly darker tone. Very fine tannins here as well.

Nice wine but IMO there is better Bojo at better prices. Drink now and within the next 3-5 years. I don't see this going decades.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    2/21/23, 7:13 AM - Nice note. Would be glad to hear from you on any other better Bojo of similar price range

White
2020 Kirkland Signature Chablis 1er Cru Chardonnay
1/25/2023 - Jimdish25 wrote:
90 points
So this is my first time trying this wine and I'm happy with the purchase. It has a nice nose and the bouquet of oak and fruit matches up pretty closely with the palate profile. Apricot and Granny Smith with a smooth almost oily attack. Not overly complex or sharp but balanced with an illusion of greater maturity than it's age would assume. I'm actually a bit high after 1.5 glasses and that's unusual for me. It's an easy drinking Chardonnay with a sunny disposition but feels like it has some pedigree and terroir of either place or vintage. This is nice. Maybe not for aging but I'd go back for for another 6 bottles as I purchased 3. The last on the shelf and 2 from a case on the cart we cracked open. Is it Wednesday night? Well this is a pretty solid Wednesday night Chablis. On to the North Coast Pinot!
  • FredericoWines commented:

    1/27/23, 9:46 PM - Chablis and oak? It doesn't sound right

Red
2014 Château Grand-Puy-Lacoste Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
11/26/2022 - John McCabe wrote:
93 points
Was surprised to come across these back vintages at Costco for about $65 plus tax so took the plunge as I like this producer. I've always found the '14 Bordeaux vintage a bit awkward and needing more time than most and this was no exception. While some are opening up, this one still needs more time but it still had quite a bit of charm and elements of the house style - led pencil, camphor and some creme-de-casis but the tannins still a bit stifling. I prefer other vintages. On day #2, this didn't improve much; still a bit awkward, muddled and closed, but the hints of quality where there. Maybe it shows better in ten five years, but otherwise I'd opt for better vintages - even the young '19 has more obvious charm.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    11/26/22, 11:52 AM - To the contrary, I'd say '14 may be more approachable than other hot vintages like '15. BTW, $65 to refill it s a very good deal

White - Sparkling
N.V. Bollinger Champagne Special Cuvée Brut Champagne Blend
11/10/2022 - ChateauShiny wrote:
94 points
Code on the cork indicates a January 2022 disgorgement. A few streams of everlasting fine bubbles in the glass. Nose of toast, almonds, green apples, a bit of buttered brioche, and a tiny hint of vanilla.

The acidity draws the moisture away and provides the structure for this wine to shine right at the start of the sip. Palate of toasted bread and nuts supported by green apples, lemon oil and zest, spices, and a bit of creamy salted caramel. The chalky mineral finish starts with green apple skin and notes of pear. Then saline, caramel, and toast combine a pleasant mild dash of spices and black pepper that build up and persist.

This young bottle did not have the hollow mid-palate that I noticed in the past. This feels like time in the cellar will do it well and I will stock up on more. Although I am finding at $55/btl is on the edge I am willing to pay.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    11/11/22, 6:15 AM - Also my favorite champagne. I still paid US$45 when it was on sale two years ago but regular price now is US$70. I'm in Canada though

White - Sparkling
N.V. Louis Roederer Champagne Brut Premier Champagne Blend
9/17/2022 - asparagus Likes this wine:
88 points
This bottle was either 60s or 70s. Bought from Morgan Fine Wines. Aged for sure, but still had slight effervescence. Toffee and honey. Interesting but probably on the donwslope
  • FredericoWines commented:

    9/17/22, 7:57 AM - A 50+ year old non vintage champagne!

Red
2015 Château Pape Clément Pessac-Léognan Red Bordeaux Blend
9/10/2022 - John McCabe wrote:
93 points
This was quite attractive, black and blue fruit, some minerality, creme de casis and dryness on the finish, but just hints really. This is pretty classy but missing any x factor perhaps. Showing pretty well at this age, but clearly will benefit from more time. 93+pts.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    9/10/22, 1:48 PM - I hope it's in dumb phase and will wake up in few years

Red
2014 Château Grand-Puy-Lacoste Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
7/31/2022 - Anchun wrote:
93 points
I usually do not touch Bordeaux younger than 10 years, actually rarely younger than 15 years. So there was the choice of opening something way too young but reasonabled priced, something mature but expensive, or a 15 min driver to my wine cellar…. So after contemplating for 2 hours, I went for the 2014. By then there was no time left for a proper decant. But this one really surprised me. The 2014 is drinking really great right now. It is elegant and graceful, nothing flashy or overpowering, but beautifully balanced and classy. Cassis, red and black current, some forest floor, cedar, tobacco, and some graphite. The tannins are polished and smooth. It is just a very fine traditional Pauillac. I wrote it before with other vintages, but GPL is the best price quality ratio you get.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    8/2/22, 8:07 AM - Just curious, how much did you pay for the bottle?

  • FredericoWines commented:

    8/2/22, 11:22 AM - Thx for info

Red
2014 Château Lynch-Bages Pauillac Red Bordeaux Blend
7/23/2022 - Iti Bun-an Likes this wine:
96 points
Vintage 2014 is only 4.3* at vivino. Should have been 4.4* if properly decanted. Tastingbook says 5hrs decanting time but i decanted it 6hrs (decanter) this time & it was perfect! Previously i followed 5hrs and it was not as good as tonight.
No wonder JS rated it 96*👍
  • FredericoWines commented:

    7/23/22, 12:35 PM - Yes, I usually discount JS rating by 5+/- points to match my personal taste

Red
2016 Château Beausejour (Duffau Lagarrosse) St. Émilion Grand Cru Red Bordeaux Blend
4/17/2022 - zimmy07 Likes this wine:
98 points
Holy moly, this wine was humming tonight!!!! 5 hour decant and drank over 2.5 hours. Yes, it is young, but it is approachable. Blue fruits, espresso and hazlenuts with an underbelly of tobacco. I will buy more of this for sure. For the price point, not sure there is a better bottle of wine around. Hold for anotehr decade easy, but with a 4-5 hour decant, let it rip!
  • FredericoWines commented:

    4/17/22, 8:42 PM - Zimmy, would you mind telling how much this bottle costs?

Red
2016 Beringer Vineyards Cabernet Sauvignon Private Reserve Napa Valley
4/13/2022 - mhekman Likes this wine:
93 points
Color (15/15): opaque purple / black...wow, this is dark!
Bouquet (19/20): tart cherry, a little cola, hint of black berry and leather...pleasant and rounds out into a full, powerful bouquet with time
Palate: (27/30): refreshing cherry, blackberry with a hint of strawberry that has a dry, tannic spine in the mid-palate before softening into a lingering fruity finish
Overall (32/35): very nice wine that gets better with air and likely improves further with time. I think this wine has upside but don't understand James Suckling's score of 99. 95+ potential is my best guess...will try another bottle in 2023.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    4/14/22, 6:53 AM - Thanks for the notes, very helpful. I'd open my '13 now while waiting for the ' 16 to get to where it can be.

    I usually discount JS' scores by 4-5 points to align with mine.

White - Sparkling
N.V. Jacquesson & Fils Champagne Cuvée No. 734 Dégorgement Tardif Champagne Blend
2/11/2022 - Lehto Likes this wine:
94 points
Based on the 2006 vintage with 27% reserve wines. 54% Chardonnay, 20% Pinot Noir and 26% Pinot Meunier, disgorged in October 2014 with 3.5g/liter dosage. About 7 years on the lees!

The champagne poured such a lovely rich golden color with a lot of bubbles still, creating a beautiful mousse.

The nose was a true powerhouse and so explosive... Yellow and baked apple with a hint of citrus but all of it completely overshadowed by oak, toasted brioche, roasted nuts, mushroom, vanilla toffee, gun powder and a salinity just blending the complexity and depth all together.

The palate was just so creamy in texture with a perfect maturity coming from yellow and baked apple that was followed by ripe peach, citrus and grapefruit. Then comes all of the toasted brioche, nuts, oak, vanilla, salted caramel and just a slightly tropical note with some earthy mushroom tone. The acidity was so precise and sharp still, just adding even more layers to unfold with every sip. The aging, acidity, saline minerality and beautiful craftsmanship has just created the perfect depth, complexity and balance in this stunning champagne.

Could definitely improve even more in a few years because of the high acidity still left, if you're into the even more mature notes. What an absolute treat!!!
  • FredericoWines commented:

    2/13/22, 4:34 AM - Good notes. You made me want to open my only bottle of Jacquesson, a 737 DT sooner

White - Sparkling
N.V. Bollinger Champagne Special Cuvée Brut Champagne Blend
2/9/2022 - ikkaariainen Likes this wine:
92 points
Definitely recommend and a very good QPR champagne at the average CT price. Clear yellow with a greenish tint, small intense bubbles, good mouth feel, medium bodied and a pleasant long aftertaste. Nose initially quite acidic with strong lees and eventually opened up to much warmer notes of yellow apple, green seedless grapes and white peach. Excellent flavor profile, a bit cleaner then the nose would suggest, rich flavors of lees and baked bread up front followed by a complex mix of a hint of underlying cinnamon overlayed by a little ginger, green tea, white peach, apple, a hint of white pepper and ending on a warm note of burnt sugar / caramel. Being N/V I don't really know when this was actually disgorged, there may be something on the label to indicate that for all I know, but this particular bottle could very easily be laid down for 10-12 years - youthful and probably approaching but not quite at prime yet, this will integrate a little better over the next few years.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    2/10/22, 8:29 AM - Look for a code on the label on bottle neck

Red
2010 Château de Beaucastel Châteauneuf-du-Pape Red Rhone Blend
2/6/2022 - napasoutherner Likes this wine:
95 points
Beautiful wine and a surprise winner for the night. Not a Syrah bomb I thought might happen. This was pure elegance with light spice and earth but very rounded and supple. Long finish. Love this wine!
  • FredericoWines commented:

    2/7/22, 8:08 AM - Thanks for your note. BTW, CdP is not a pure Syrah wine. It's a blend of more than 10 varietals mainly of Grenache, Mourvedre, Syrah and many others. For Beaucastel '10, it's a classic blend of 30% Grenache, 30% Mourvedre, 10% Syrah, 10% Counoise and the balance the other permitted varietals in the appellation. So lack of obvious Syrah characters is not surprising.

White - Sparkling
N.V. Roederer Estate Brut Anderson Valley Champagne Blend
right off the cork I just notice how briny and mineral the nose is... sourdough ....its well chilled coming across with vanilla, yellow fruit, apple lemon peel, loving that savory sourdough nose....one of the most champenois domestic bottles I've come across...my last note here was in 2020...this is right off the pull while that bottle had 3hr slow ox...reminds me to give it some air...after someone asked I searched for disgorgment date near top of label disgorged 1/2021 L1012.... the reserve wine really adding on nose...
  • FredericoWines commented:

    2/2/22, 6:19 PM - May I know the disgorgement date of this bottle?

  • FredericoWines commented:

    2/2/22, 7:07 PM - Wow, literally right frim cellar caves to your glass

Red
2018 Antinori Tignanello Toscana IGT SuperTuscan Blend
8/17/2021 - Drunk Crocodile Likes this wine:
94 points
Powerful.. 💪 Bordeaux style..
I think of St.Estephe in particular

Dark ruby on the eyes with narrow rim.

Pronounce intensity on the nose with black fruit forward, black currant plum violet oak pepper mint.
Enjoyable..🥰

Dry, med+ acidity, med tannin not fine also not too rough, med bitterness.
Pronounce intensity on the palates, med+ alcohol, full body, long aftertaste.

I can't tell any of Sangiovese..😂 in the wine..

SV&cs&cf
  • FredericoWines commented:

    1/30/22, 12:11 PM - When did Sangiovese become one of the varietals used in St. Esthephe in Bordeaux? LoL

White - Sparkling
2008 Dom Pérignon Champagne Champagne Blend
1/9/2022 - wcf1946 Likes this wine:
90 points
Way overhyped for the quality. For $246 I would rate it a ZERO. Good, not great. Piper-Heidsieck Red is better IMHO.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    1/11/22, 12:13 PM - wcf1946, do you mean Piper-Heidseick Rare or the regular NV with label?

  • FredericoWines commented:

    1/11/22, 12:43 PM - I'd tried Piper NV red label and found it just meh. Charles-Heidseick Brut Reserve is definitely better but still no match for DP, particularly '08

  • FredericoWines commented:

    1/11/22, 2:11 PM - 10xM, Rare is better than Dom P, could be. But no way is Piper NV red label :)

Red
2020 Coudert Fleurie Clos de la Roilette Cuvée Tardive Gamay
11/4/2021 - 10xM wrote:
No decant. PnP.
Muted aromas.
Acid is alive and kicking on this one.
Cranberries/red fruits with high acidity fills my mouth. seems to have structure for long term aging but right now it is so young that the acid is blocking so much of the taste. Will update more as night goes on if there are any changes.

Day 5: wine bottle has been recorked and left in room temperature for 5 days. The wine is balanced now and acid is Integrated. Fruit is more on the foreground. Good easy drinking.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    12/19/21, 2:28 PM - I also wonder how the normale and Cuvee Tardive differ for the same 2020 vintage? (Other than the latter may prefer some years of waiting to show its true color)

White - Sweet/Dessert
2016 Domaine Huet Vouvray Moelleux Clos du Bourg Chenin Blanc
11/4/2021 - peternelson Likes this wine:
89 points
Med. gold, slight orange; almond, honey, med.- sweetness (as far as sweet wines go), a little bitter finish, wheat bread aspect, lower acidity on this. OK, but a top Chenin must have good acidity in my opinion. Not my fav. Interestingly enough, this came in 2nd place. DD at Akbar blind--Loire Whites.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    11/7/21, 3:22 PM - That doesn't seem right.Chenin Blanc from Loire should have high acidity. I can only hope yours is an off bottle

Red
1996 Château Léoville Las Cases St. Julien Red Bordeaux Blend
8/25/2021 - Ozen Likes this wine:
96 points
Leoville Las Cases is my favourite Saint Julien and candidate for premier cru.
Drinking this next to the Leoville Barton 2003 which surprised with a wonderful rich palette.

But, the Las Cases is its superior with an impressive, wonderfully aristocratic kingly depth and complexity that is a true aristocrat. The only downside is a very slightly drying finish.
The trick with LLC is plenty of airing before tasting, and this one even better the next day (with cork in the bottle). LLC is a royal wine. The 1996 slightly more masculine than usual, but truly grand vin! Perfectly balanced with a long harmonious finish.

This is ready to start drinking but at the same time has years of development ahead for even more depth.

To compare: the 1990 is more spectacular, while the 1998 is lovely and more fully mature now.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    8/25/21, 7:43 AM - 8 hour decant for a 25 year old wine? Wow!

White - Sparkling
N.V. Bollinger Champagne Special Cuvée Brut Champagne Blend
8/12/2021 - jmcelroy wrote:
86 points
Over the hill? Golden color, very little effervescence. However after 20 to 30 minutes the wine started to open and developed rather complex flavors. Not bad for a NV Champagne that has been cellared for 20 years. Will be interesting to see how my last bottle from this trio turns out.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    8/13/21, 7:35 AM - Do you know the disgorgement date of this bottle?

Red
2014 Spottswoode Cabernet Sauvignon Estate St. Helena
6/19/2021 - rkww Likes this wine:
96 points
Having enjoyed two bottles in a four-month span this year, I'm confident that I will love the 2014 Spottswoode someday, but also that it isn't quite ready to drink yet. During both experiences, we decanted the wine for 3-5 hours and felt it only started to open up at the very end of those windows. The tannins remained voluminous and firm throughout, lending incredible structure and ageability but impeding enjoyment in the short term. Still, the bouquet of dark black fruits, plum, cacao, charred wood, and mint brought smiles to our tables, and it's clear that a beautiful balance will emerge in time. Give these until at least 2024 and drink through the 2030s (or perhaps even beyond).
  • FredericoWines commented:

    7/17/21, 10:02 AM - Not sure if I have that patience to wait to 2030's. I have bottles of '14-16 waiting.

Red
2015 Fontodi Flaccianello della Pieve Colli della Toscana Centrale IGT Sangiovese
Cristal and Fontodi Flaccianello plus Riverain and Schrader (served blind) (Foretti's in Corona Del Mar): I had this back in 2019, and I thought the wine then had a lot of power. Last night, it was poured again, this time part of a flight of three other Flaccianello (the 2006, 2010 and 2012). All were served blind side by side so I had a chance too sit with all 4 wines and evaluate them carefully. For me, this was the star wine of the flight. I was sitting next to Viet Ly and he mentioned a lavender flower quality, something he also framed by the word 'soapy'. We had some discussion at the table about it, with some consensus about a kind of lavender resin, if that makes sense. For me, it was just like a dried floral note that I really dug. This started out juicy and with air, that quality transformed into something more concentrated and powerful, like the bottle back in 2019. There is the core of red fruit here, but also a shading of black, that is joined by a tarry kind of black quality. Finishes with a dusty tannin. Really enjoyed this.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    6/25/21, 2:25 PM - Frank, how long did you decant it? I have 3 bottles each of 15 and 16 and excited to know how much longer I should wait

Red
2013 Fontodi Flaccianello della Pieve Colli della Toscana Centrale IGT Sangiovese
6/24/2021 - Andybe Does not like this wine:
89 points
Tight, impenetrable, inky. The way we know a chianti. Terrible after 8 years. How long must we wait to drink this 2013. A bottle that cost me € 60,= but now already € 100,= for not being drinkable. And oh oh what do we like this shit reading the other comments.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    6/24/21, 5:05 PM - Maybe you're just an outlier. I'm with the other 90+ people on this one.l

Red
2015 Château Pape Clément Pessac-Léognan Red Bordeaux Blend
6/11/2021 - wizlb Likes this wine:
96 points
I really enjoyed this wine, it was a pop and pour night in cold Sydney, CPC is a full body wine, and a long finish.


If you get an opportunity pick up a bottle or two.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    6/11/21, 2:48 PM - PnP and still so good, really? Others commented that either long decant or few more years needed

  • FredericoWines commented:

    6/11/21, 3:34 PM - Great. I can open mine sooner than I thought

Red
2016 Fratelli Alessandria Barolo Nebbiolo
5/9/2021 - MAXIMUM SATISFACTION wrote:
90 points
As I did several months back you can say this is young but drinkable. In reality it’s painfully too early (tannic and acidic). At the end of the day why would you hold a bottle like the for ten years? Just buy older ones retail.
  • FredericoWines commented:

    5/12/21, 6:52 AM - Cabfrancophile. Agreed as there is no old vintage stuff available at reputable wine shops in my area. Only to buy new vintage and sit tight. BTW, how much longer should we wait for the '16 Fratelli Alessandria Barolo to be ready? I got three bottles waiting in my passive cellar

  • FredericoWines commented:

    5/12/21, 8:45 AM - Thank you Cabfrancophile

1 - 50 of 162
More results
© 2003-24 CellarTracker! LLC.

Report a Problem

Close